Whose "controversial" action bugged you the most? Sylvie's or Star lord (MCU)

Still Star Lord in my opinion; they had Thanos beat and he ruined it. Sylvie has only one thing driving her for at least 1,000 years. You can’t expect someone to just stop what is essentially their life’s work on what could possibly be a lie.

Star Lord is more stupid because he knows exactly what would happen if he smacked Thanos in the face. Thanos will awaken and beat the crap out of everyone. Half the universe dies.

Sylvie doesn't know with certainty that fake Kang was telling the truth. It's stupid for her to not consider it, but it's not impossible for him to make bullshit up to prevent her from taking his life (obviously it's not true, but she can't know that).

Sylvie because she is annoying

Bump

I don’t believe that Sylvie’s decision was necessarily wrong. All of the information she had was from someone she just met who was the leader of an organization which was built on a foundation of lies. That same organization destroyed her life and countless others. When backed into a corner and the knife pressed against his throat suddenly he’s not really the bad guy? He’s the best choice of an infinite number of potential choices, so he claims? If she was second guessing Loki, why would she believe this man at the end of time who offered no proof? The same person who destroyed her life?

Star-Lord had full knowledge of Thanos’s danger. He acted irrationally due to hysterical grief, but he didn’t put any thought into his action even though he knew the consequences.

You could say both characters acted selfishly, but given the evidence at the time, Sylvie’s decision makes more sense.

Both were pretty stupid so I can’t really choose

Sylvie's action had much more meaning behind it than Star-Lord needing to throw a few meaningless gun slaps at a being that wasn't hurt by a piece of spaceship debris falling on him.

Sylvie's action made a lot of sense actually. Spent her whole life running cause of this man, her reality wiped, while he showed no remorse, told a convenient story that made her killing him the wrong choice, but also coincidentally gave her the free will to choose which could have felt like a final plea of "take your freedom" from the man she assumed was afraid for his life. Sylvie killing him was the only logical ending to this season as she is in fact a Loki, and impulsivity is a trait that character will always identify with. Premeditated attacks met with impulse driven decision making make Loki a consistent character.

Star-Lord's decision to impulsively strike Thanos does not compare to the wonderfully crafted explosion of the multiverse. Both decisions created world altering events, but only one had logic.

I don't blame either or them, but Star-Lord should have known better. I'm still not convinced Sylvie was wrong.

post 6 and 8 said it the best

Sylvie's action is perfectly understandable, she hates his guts, doesn't trust anyone, and if killing him results in a multiversal war, that's not very different from her everyday.

Star Lord just had to wait a couple more seconds til the gauntlet was off, and endangered everyone, it felt OOC even for Starlord

That

We should be thanking Sylvie for the next 20 years and endless possibilities.

Quill’s for sure. And not in the way of like I’m concerned for the movie characters because of what he did, but more in the way that it was just annoying AF that he was written to do something like that.

I honestly feel like the writer(s) could’ve come up with something better than “hey! let’s just have Quill overreact and flock the whole thing up! Yeah, that’ll work.” C’mon guys

Star Lord's blunder was worse because he knew with absolute certainty that waking Thanos up would have resulted in them losing.

Silvie at least didn't know for sure, though that's still not a great excuse that she completely disregarded the potential outcome with Kang.

Star Lord.

Starlord.

For the record it was star lord plans that caught Thanos

Bump.