Who is the most charismatic leader out of Superman, Captain America, Mister Fantastic and Professor X?

Going with Cap on this one.

Bump

Charles. He is a sociopath in comics. Also in movies young Charles was also like that in First Class.

Gotta be Supes and I don't like superman.

Xavier is too controlling literally and figuratively.

Cap is too much of a goody two shoes to understand reality which is probably why the falling out took place in civil war.

Reed is very arrogant even if he is one of the smartest on the planet makes him very hard to relate to which diminishes charisma.

Could make a argument for cap over supes but while supe is a good two shoes himself he knows when a threat is a threat no to mention batman himself likes supes. BATMAN. So yes definitely supes

It's a tie for me between Supes and Cap.

Superman or Cap, with a leaning more towards Cap

Superman is respected even by most villains; gotta go with him.

This is an interesting question/comparison. Reed and Xavier are out of their league in this category with Superman and Captain America here. While I do feel like Superman is more charismatic, I think Cap is a better field leader.

Cap has better leadership.

Superman is more charismatic/inspiring.

Captain America

Superman and Cap.

Superman and Cap both are 10/10 in charisma but superman isn't the leader of JL, so this poll goes to cap.

Cap

Sup

Chuck

Reed

Toss up between Cap and Supes.

I see leader i vote cap :)

Optimus solos

Krasinski solos

How can you bring up Civil War when Superman did worse in Doomsday clock?

Superman. Cap is a soldier so I expect him to be a bit more pragmatic

Back then, I would have said Charles Xavier, since he was supposed to be written as a teacher with a dream stemmed from his compassion. Not always write, granted, but still much better intended than current.

I wouldn't say written poorly. Mutants are just extremely arrogant right now

Why are we discussing Cap as a "goody two shoes" when we have Sups here? Cap has actually taken lives in the line of duty and protecting the Earth, Sups hasn't. The argument makes no sense. The Civil War shit was him trying to protect the lives of superheroes from people who'd abuse their secret identities being public and attack their families, which, spoiler alert, he was 100% right on lol.

They even had a What If for Civil War where Captain America's proposal for Iron Man solved the Civil War, put him in charge of the entire Initiative, and brought about Marvel's version of the Hall of Justice and a new golden age for Earth. Tony breaks down afterwards because he realises he was right all along.

How exactly are they arrogant? They haven't done anything to insinuate themselves to be arrogant as a whole. Granted, not withstanding individual mutants.

If anyone is arrogant, I would say humanity is far more arrogant than the mutants, if the cheers for mutants death across the planet after the Eternals waged war was not apparent, I can name the very many numerous times the mutants were nearly driven to extinction.

Captain America >>>> All of Transformers Character Developments

Only Optimus and a few others come close

Comic Superman

By being arrogant lol. They're beyond death and above the law you know its bad when Doom calls you out and makes a perfect point

I'm sticking with Captain America. He's a man with a small power scale but with a big heart.

@kgb725:1) “By being arrogant lol. They're beyond death“

That’s not arrogant. It’s a survival measure because they are trying to return from extinction. Again.

You can say maybe a majority are a lot more reckless or careless, but not arrogant. Again, barring the minority, a good chunk of the X-Men are extremely humble individuals. And most mutants, that are not Arakki, are following the examples of the X-Men and other mutants of high authority (who were either in X-Men adjacent teams or were X-Men themselves).

2) “and above the law”

They aren’t above the law.

They are citizens of a nation. Not a cartel. That’s why you don’t often see mutants doing as much crime as they once were.

I am assuming you didn’t read the X-Books, because the Arakki were regulated as hell when they came to Earth when they started doing things like robbing stores. When Stryfe tried to use his diplomatic immunity to gain entry into Krakoa after attacking multiple families and stealing their babies, Cable and company literally denied him of that right.

Does not sound at all like any mutant is above the laws.

3) “you know its bad when Doom calls you out and makes a perfect point”

First off, Doom of all people has no right to judge about anything. And I know he isn’t calling the mutants out because he sees an injustice and wishes them to be better. If he can’t follow his own advice, he should not be giving it out so freely.

Secondly, there is a certain irony in using an arrogant bastard to prove a society to be arrogant.

Great question. Not that familiar with the Fantastic Four, so I'm not sure if I'd vote Mr. Fantastic but out of the rest of the line up, Captain America.

1. Return from extinction? My dude every single mutant besides a very small few like Matthew Malloy are all alive. They are thriving and have absolutely nothing to worry about. And they are hiding things from the avengers

2. They have full diplomatic immunity. They can't enter Krakoa but they can still do whatever they want around the world. And let's be real it's not like they exiled Magneto when they thought he murdered wanda

3. Is doom wrong in his assessment ?

X , im a sucker for the disabled

@kgb725: But Charles is right. Mutants > humans. What's the point of hiding it?

@kgb725:

Doom is entirely wrong and this entire premise is beyond stupid.

It's like marvel ignores their own history. Where was this when the mutants were on the verge of extinction?

They spent the better part of four decades saving the world while at the same time being murdered and ridiculed by it to genocidal levels.

Let's not forget that Doom himself is not innocent in the way he has treated mutants himself.

If anything the X-Men should forcefully dominate the planet and they would be absolutely justified in doing so.