Which CGI was worse?
I never realized how cartoony Logan’s claws looked, probably because I blocked out Origins from my mind. But Cavill’s face was... unsettling.
I never realized how cartoony Logan’s claws looked, probably because I blocked out Origins from my mind. But Cavill’s face was... unsettling.
I never realized how cartoony Logan’s claws looked, probably because I blocked out Origins from my mind. But Cavill’s face was... unsettling.
The only time Cavill’s face looked terrible to me was the phone recording in the beginning. Everything else wasn’t that bad for me.
I agree with this
As much i would like to say wolverines claws when i first saw x men origins i thought they looked really real. Henry Cavil looks goofy as fuck in that pic. He didnt look that bad throughout the rest of the movie.
Cavill...easily.
Cavill he didn't even look like himself he looked like he was wearing a mask of himself
LMFAO thats so true.
The only time Cavill’s face looked terrible to me was the phone recording in the beginning. Everything else wasn’t that bad for me.
I agree with this
He looked fine for the rest of the film ....until he spoke. Almost reminds me of Son of the Mask
I'm looking really hard and I don't notice anything wrong with Cav El's face.
Wolverine's claws are pretty bad, even by the standards of 2009. His claws literally looked better in 2000. Although I hypothesize that this has something to do with the brighter lighting in that scene. Notice how the original X Men takes place almost entirely at night. It's easier to hide things in the dark.
Hate to keep a quote going, but when you're right, you're right.
I never realized how cartoony Logan’s claws looked, probably because I blocked out Origins from my mind. But Cavill’s face was... unsettling.
Superman, taking into consideration that CGI must have improved since Origins came out. But Wolverine’s claws do look awful
Wolverine's claws.
But for real, how is it that in an age where we can take Andy Serkis and make him look like an ape, we somehow can't properly make a mustache go away without ruining the rest of the face?
cause one movie was planned around making him look like an ape, the other was something the popped on the artists at the last minute
Cgi wasnt even as advanced back when xmen origins came out. Warner bros just got lazy with the cgi, they couldve made it believable, look at what marvel does when they make actors decades younger. WB is a bunch of lazy Bimbos.
Cgi wasnt even as advanced back when xmen origins came out. Warner bros just got lazy with the cgi, they couldve made it believable, look at what marvel does when they make actors decades younger. WB is a bunch of lazy Bimbos.
Oh please. We had gotten Transformers, Spiderman 3, and Avatar. The claws looked god awful, period.
As for which cgi is worse, Wolverine's claws by far. I know a couple of college buds who good do a better than that crap.
@petey_is_spidey: Nah you cant even deny his mouth was lazily done. The cgi these days are astounding. No excuse why they couldnt do better. And then they have the balls to do a close up on that mess??? The claws>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>snydermans face.
Cmon now justice league had 2x the budget origins had, and they couldnt even get a cgi jaw done correctly?
Cavill 10000%
Even I could've done better using Microsoft Paint.
lol this
Though his claws really looked bad in that scene.
Oh come the hell on. I thought Justice League was crap too, but it's absolutely ridiculous to argue that the face CGI is worse than the claws. I can literally render better looking claws on Unity 3d. I'm being literal here, not like the people saying you can CGI a better mouth on Cavil using Microsoft paint....because you can't. Wolverines claws look like straight ps2 video game content in that scene lol
The length and mental gymnastics that DCEU fanatics will go to to defend anything in the DCEU even when it’s this ridiculous amazes me. Lmfao one movie is a panned Wolverine flick made in 09 with nowhere nears the budget of the other film. You know the film that was supposed to end the MCU. Come on one guy has claws that come out of his skin the other has his real mustache cgi’d off his face. ??
The length and mental gymnastics that DCEU fanatics will go to to defend anything in the DCEU even when it’s this ridiculous amazes me. Lmfao one movie is a panned Wolverine flick made in 09 with nowhere nears the budget of the other film. You know the film that was supposed to end the MCU. Come on one guy has claws that come out of his skin the other has his real mustache cgi’d off his face. ??
You've really just become a parody of yourself at this point lol
Anyways, how do you explain the prior X-Men movies having better looking claws then Origins?
@buttersdaman000: Come on your not even trying. For once be honest with yourself look at both pictures and tell me Cavill doesn’t look ridiculous. Far more so than Wolvies claws. Hell WB could’ve just had Logan use his claws an give Cavill a shave. ?
@buttersdaman000: Come on your not even trying. For once be honest with yourself look at both pictures and tell me Cavill doesn’t look ridiculous. Far more so than Wolvies claws. Hell WB could’ve just had Logan use his claws an give Cavill a shave. ?
Lol
I don't wanna comment on which one is bad. But which bad CGI affected me more? Definitely Cavill's face. I mean that guy looks like a God. He's probably the most good looking guy to become a superhero. I mean the face, the jawline, the physique..!! Seriously that guy belongs to a museum. And look what they did to him. He doesn't even look like a normal man let alone like Cavill in some scenes, specially when he speaks. I will never forgive the WB/DC guys for even allowing the release of CGI like this. I mean what did they think. Are the viewers blind? Are they themselves blind?
@petey_is_spidey: Nah you cant even deny his mouth was lazily done. The cgi these days are astounding. No excuse why they couldnt do better. And then they have the balls to do a close up on that mess??? The claws>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>snydermans face.
I mean don't get me wrong, the mouth is bad, but it's only really noticeable on close-ups; in a lot of the scenes I couldn't tell the difference between the real and the cgi. The claws, however, look like utterly, and completely fake. As previously pointed out, any schmo could quite literally make more realistic looking claws than that. However, as bad as the lip cgi is, most, if not everyone here could not make better looking cgi.
I mean quite literally the claws looked like a snapchat filter.
EDIT: And mind you, this discussion isn't about which cgi should have looked better, but which cgi is worse, period. And though JL had a bigger budget, the reality is that the claws in origins look far, FAR worse.
Not sure if because it's more recent or because people on this forum really hate DCEU, but Wolverine's claws are far far worse.
Don't get me wrong, Cavill's moustache CGI was horrible. I agree that it was so bad.
But Wolverine's claws looked like they came straight out of a cartoon. Like they just cropped out his claws from the 90s animated series and pasted it on his hands. There's no contest here.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment