What is the best movie, Logan or The Winter Soldier?

Logan a million times over. Winter Soldier was great, but Logan was an absolutely perfect movie.

Logan. TWS was very good, but Logan, IMHO, was better.

Very, VERY close, but I choose Logan.

Logan. Call me a fanboy if you want. I don't care.

They were about the same.

Logan. TWS was great but Logan was a great swan song. Hell Logan is a dark and gritty comic film done right. DCEU directors should take notes.

Logan. I like Winter Soldier but never fell in love with it like everyone else.

I actually liked TWS more. Logan had a better story, but it could be better with less fighting scenes as they were rather repetitive and dragged out the plot.

Logan wins pretty handily, but they were both great movies. Logan was just nearly perfect.

tough call, both great films... only seen logan once, feel like i need to watch again to fully judge

The winter Soldier with a slight edge. While the performance in Logan was superior, the Cap was a great action movie all the way, while I think some scene could have been improved upon in Logan.

Not sure.

Logan

Logan's villains made me roll my eyes.

The Winter Soldier. Don't have the same feeling for Logan after watching 2 more times.

@lichter: We'll fight m8

They're both great.

To be honest, The Winter Soldier is more satisfying.

Logan his higher highs, but it also has lower lows.

Logan by a bit

TWS is a great comic book film, but I rank Logan alongside great films like No Country for Old Men, To Hell or high water, as future classic Neo-Westerns.

Logan.

TWS never really did it for me for some reason...

logan not by much tho

The Winter Soldier

Logan.

Why bump 3 of the same thread?

Winter Soldier.

Not even remotely close.

I didn't like Winter Solder

IMO Logan is in a league of it's own, similar to TDK, where it almost transcends superhero films. TWS is one of my favorite comic book movies, but it's not quite at that level.

Yeah, I think I like LOGAN a little better than The Winter Soldier. Tho I’d be lying if I didn’t admit there is some nostalgia/emotional feeling towards LOGAN more than Cap, just based on how long Hugh has been the character and seeing it all come to an end. It was very well executed

Logan was pretty much perfect in my eyes

Logan. More depth, better acting and overall I feel it was more than just a superhero movie

The Winter Soldier stomps

Logan. Decisively.