1.Grandmaster Luke
2.Grandmaster Yoda
3. Mace Windu(?)
4. Revan?
5. Cade Skywalker??
Curious who some more star wars savvy experts think the top five is. Genuinely curious, order and reasons would be appreciated. Thanks.
@king-ragnar: The fact that I asked about top five and you ONLY mentioned rey leads me to believe you're a fanboy or troll.
I'm totally fine with the concept of Rey being #1, her beating All Sith Sidious Grant's her this, but I kinda discount her in this because she had the power of all the jedi at that time. Not throughout the movie, and its unknown if she could ever draw on that power again.
@the_fub: are you asking in canon or legends or everything?
@incursion2: Without amps, Rey is weaker than Kit Fisto.
My top (if we are going by canon)
1-Luke (By statements, but not by feats.)
2-Yoda
3-Mace Windu
4-Anakin
5-Obi-Wan
Luke
Yoda
Mace Windu
Anakin
I’d give Obi-Wan and Rey a tie, cuz Obi-Wan was a pretty average force-user, but a great duelist. Rey was pretty powerful, and will probably become the most powerful in the future, but not the top spot yet.
Also, honorable mention to Leia, who would have been the most powerful if she trained
Ignoring Disney Canon :
1. Grandmaster Luke Skywalker
2. Grandmaster Yoda
3. Kyp Durron
4. Mace Windu
5. Revan (SoR)
Legends
1. GM Luke
2. Yoda
3. Kyp Durron
4. Mace
5. RoTS Kenobi (Reborn Revan was definitely not a jedi)
Canon
1-Yoda
2-Luke
3-Mace Windu
4-Anakin
5-Obi-Wan
Canon
#. Chosen one Anakin
1. Luke Skywalker
2. Yoda
3. Mace Windu
4. Anakin Skywalker
5. Rey / Obi Wan Kenobi
Legends I'm a little rusty but it's at least the obvious two.
1. Luke Skywalker
2. Yoda
Are people saying Mace because of his skill as a Duelist. Whenever I read about mace it’s typically centered around Vaapad and his skill with a saber.
Canon
1. Luke
2. Yoda
3. Anakin at his best/Windu
4. Kenobi
5. Rey, once she trains and gets more experience she's likely to be up there with Luke and Yoda, but without her amp from all the previous Jedi she isn't there yet.
@crater_maker: Yeah, he was the best duelist during TCW. Or at least second, Yoda being stated to be better. Him being master of the order also kinda says he's the second best jedi of TCW.
Him having Vaapad was also a great ability combat wise. Force wise he also has decent accolades as well.
Hes also got the Palpatine feat. Which I wont get into because people are very adamant on their take of it, but regardless is very impressive however you cut it.
@finalkingthanos: Honestly I'd be interested in your take for both. However I'm more leaning towards Legends because I'm less familiar with that material.
How would you judge him solely on his ability with the Force? If you were to Gauge it with Yoda or Skywalker’s.
@crater_maker: Soley the force? Not on the same tier that's for sure. Its honestly where the gap widens. Whereas I personally believe that his mastery of Shatterpoint and Vapaad puts him on the highest tier of sabre combat I feel like his force ability are subpar compared to someone like Yoda or Luke. He just (to my knowledge) doesnt have the feats to suggest he's on their level in that regard. It's why I, as well as most people that I've seen, put Mace Windu on a high tier 8, while Yoda and Luke are a comfortable tier 9 (Luke being higher on that tier undoubtedly).
1. Rey
2. GM Luke
3. Yoda
4. Anakin
5. Windu
Revan would be on this list except he is kinda his own faction at his height
@lord_tenebrous: Does Legends Yaddle have feats or do you include her simply due to her being the same species as Yoda?
@samjackson said:
Legends
1. GM Luke
2. Yoda
3. Kyp Durron
4. Mace
5. RoTS Kenobi (Reborn Revan was definitely not a jedi)
Canon
1-Yoda
2-Luke
3-Mace Windu
4-Anakin
5-Obi-Wan
Canon
0. Mortis State Anakin
1. Yoda or Luke
2. Luke or Yoda
3. Mace Windu
4. Anakin Skywalker
5. Obi Wan or Jedi Count Dooku
Idk how to rank Rey and I kinda don't want to rank her.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment