Poll Samurai or Ninja - which do you like better (30 votes)
The two notable, infamous feudal caste of Japan. Which one do you prefer and generally like better.
The two notable, infamous feudal caste of Japan. Which one do you prefer and generally like better.
Smh! another naruto vs Samurai 8 thread!
OT: honestly, samurais are better imo cause of the honor bounded traditions they have and how peaceful they lived outside of war, and how ferocis they were in war.
Smh! another naruto vs Samurai 8 thread!
OT: honestly, samurais are better imo cause of the honor bounded traditions they have and how peaceful they lived outside of war, and how ferocis they were in war.
Nothing to do with the anime.
The samurai during Edo period were a laughing stock - fat, lazy, undisciplined, drunk. You can read that in some of greatest authors books - Musashi or Daidoji Yuzan and more. Not that honorable at all. So the point about leaving peacefully and still being samurai is BS.
I grew up on Ninjas, and have personally trained to be one for most of my life -- sans the assassinating part. I know more about them than Samurai, yet I respect Samurai all the same.
If you'd pay attention in school you'd know that all Ninjas are Samurai specifically trained for espionage or assassination by their Shogun or Lord.
If you'd pay attention in school you'd know that all(?!?!?!?!) Ninjas are Samurai specifically trained for espionage or assassination by their Shogun or Lord.
I don't know who your teacher was but he should bring his certificate back. Some ninja had probably been samurai indeed at some point of their lives, but the gap is huge so calling them that all is BS. Not to mention they'd passed a long period as ronin before that most likely.
Firstly, there was one Shogun. Second, not all the daimyos were rich enough to hire ninjas. Training ninja by themselves didn't make them ninjas at all. The ninjas lived in the mountains and had been hired for specific goals unachievable for the meres or even elite samurai. Of course there were specific exceptions, but we are talking about the richest and most powerful daimyio right before Edo period.
Third, how could you claim they are the same when they are nothing alike. And Im not referring to the infamous code, I'm talking about the training, the methods, the fighting styles, the weapons. The samurai were heavily equipped warriors, masters of the sword and the blade, unbeatable for the ninjas in straight 1v1. Ninjas were, as you said assassins, spies, they were taught to climb, to kill from ambush, quickly, from the shadows. Their weapons were completely different despite the fact that they used katana.
Their goals were different, their styles, weapons, equipment, believes, skills set, anything.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment