Avatar image for valorknight
#1051 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

7/10.

Tokyo Ghoul Chapter 66
Tokyo Ghoul Chapter 66

Ken Kaneki finally lays the smackdown on Yamori, the guy who tortured him for ten days straight and murdered multiple people that he had sworn to protect.

Avatar image for cosmic_reign
#1052 Edited by cosmic_reign (3024 posts) - - Show Bio

6.7- The caption/description helps.

No Caption Provided

X-Men: Second Coming

Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1053 Edited by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

6.

Saga (2014) 21
Saga (2014) 21

Avatar image for vertigo-
#1054 Edited by Vertigo- (16999 posts) - - Show Bio

8.

No Caption Provided

Starlight issue 6

Online
Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1055 Posted by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

6. Nice dialogue and scene composition but the art is not my cup of tea.

Saga (2017) 42
Saga (2017) 42

Marko and Alana end up miscarrying their second child after barely escaping the death of a planet.

Avatar image for warlockmage
#1056 Edited by Warlockmage (8161 posts) - - Show Bio

meh 6/10 desired emotional impact is not there

No Caption Provided

Online
Avatar image for omega_kai
#1057 Posted by Omega_kai (2874 posts) - - Show Bio
No Caption Provided

5

Avatar image for valorknight
#1058 Edited by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

10/10, that's a fantastic page.

Baki - Son of Ogre Chapter 159
Baki - Son of Ogre Chapter 159

In the above scans, the protagonist gets his opponent into a rear naked choke and manages to jump thirty meters into the air in order to body drop him all the way back down.

Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1059 Edited by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

6. Nothing special honestly. Though it's surprisingly detailed for manga art that doesn't involve guys like Naoki Urasawa, Makoto Yukimura & Kentaro Miura

Y: The Last Man (2002) 2
Y: The Last Man (2002) 2

Avatar image for valorknight
#1060 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

4/10, I don't like the art or the subject matter at all.

Grashros Chapter 1
Grashros Chapter 1

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1061 Edited by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

6/10

No Caption Provided

One Piece Chapter 63 "I'm not gonna die"

Avatar image for valorknight
#1062 Edited by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

4/10; I love One Piece, but it doesn't have very good art.

Grashros Chapter 6
Grashros Chapter 6

Avatar image for warlockmage
#1063 Posted by Warlockmage (8161 posts) - - Show Bio

5

No Caption Provided

Online
Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1065 Edited by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio
Pluto Chapter 8
Pluto Chapter 8

The robot serial killer known as Pluto claims another victim.

OT: 5. Love Manapul's art but the establishing shot is nothing special.

Avatar image for valorknight
#1066 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

@piratekingoda: Here we go, I guess:

  1. I never said that it did.
  2. No. If it's any consolation, I also rated your page based on the subject matter (I just didn't find it all too interesting).

OT: I'll give it a 7/10 for the perspective.

Grashros Chapter 16
Grashros Chapter 16

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1067 Edited by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

@valorknight: Just because some artwork isn't so overly complicated and detailed doesn't mean it's bad and is the art the only thing you're looking at? I thought we were judging how the panels were overall, art included, the OP even said, "It could be based off of artistic value or technical skill, emotional or plot significance, or just completely arbitrary"At the end of the day with your pic even though it is well drawn I am just looking at an animal, where as in the other pic Luffy is doing something crazy epic only Luffy does ......oh and 6.5/10 for the one above me. (sorry if there is confusion now I always end up editing my posts lol)

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for valorknight
#1068 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

6/10 at best.

Graineliers Chapter 15
Graineliers Chapter 15

Avatar image for lazorguns
#1069 Edited by lazorguns (1665 posts) - - Show Bio

6.

Birds of Prey Vol. 2 #3
Birds of Prey Vol. 2 #3

Avatar image for valorknight
#1070 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

4/10.

Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 143
Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 143

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1071 Edited by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

@valorknight: 7/10 and hahahahaha awww come ON man...... REALLY bro?? xD 6/10 at best??? Ahhh son you're TRIPPIN LOOOOL XDDD

ok, ok..... If I can have just a moment of your time. Can I at least explain why I believe those last pics I posted were better than a 4 and 6?

Don't get me wrong... I understand where you guys are coming from. You are all probably older and more educated than I am

HOWEVER......

If you ask me what the MOST important thing is... it's not all that "technical" stuff... it's not the artwork or the perspective or ANY of that.....

NO.......the most important thing is..................... is it memorable?

You see, when I saw Luffy just punch a wall of spikes with his BARE HAND like that.... I REMEMBERED that S*** lol

I said to myself, "Damn... this dude just punched through a spiked cape with his BARE fist!!! That's crazy!! This dude is a badass!"

But for the last few pics that you've posted.... I just don't have that feeling... they aren't memorable at all. They don't excite me, or inspire me, or just get me hyped or anything... it's just a picture of a girl staring at the sky... you can give it the best artwork in the world (which it almost has lol) but it still isn't MEMORABLE... even IF it has a few more shooting stars then your average sky.. I've seen hundreds of girls stare at the sky hundreds of times IRL and in fiction... But I don't think I've EVER seen a dude just punch a wall of spikes like that lol

I mean just....... God damn... that sense of impact... the expression on Krieg's face.... you really think that's just a 4/10? ;( ;( ;( ;( ;(

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree, but that's fine, please don't think I am trying to attack you or anything. I have nothing BUT respect for you and this site. So if I offended you I apologize please know I didn't mean anything by it. I am just a nerd online talking about One Piece lol

Oh but that doesn't mean you are off the hook mister.... far from it xD

Now you have forced my hand lmao..... NOW I am NOT going to STOP until I find a One Piece picture that you like gosh darn it!!!! :O

So..... how about this one? xc pretty good, no? Solid artwork, nice sense of distance......eh? ..........EH? :D

No Caption Provided

Avatar image for valorknight
#1072 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

@piratekingoda: There is no need to flip out just because you didn't get the rating that you wanted. I have a different opinion that you, it's as simple as that.

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1073 Edited by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

@valorknight: Again..... I'm sorry if I offended you. Please know just because I write a lot doesn't mean I am flipping out lol I am just trying to talk about One Piece. I'm a nerd. Got nothing else better to do lol

I understand you are probably older than me and have had way more online arguments with people..... so I am sure you are probably sick of it at this point. It was my fault to ask.... sorry again... I just wanted to talk to someone about One Piece. I didn't mean anything to you personally..... Did I ever insult you? If I did it was on accident and again.... I apologize.

If it seems like I'm shouting at you I swear I'm not haha honestly I'm just trying to put emphasis in my words so my meaning stands out.

Avatar image for valorknight
#1074 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

@valorknight: Again..... I'm sorry if I offended you. Please know just because I write a lot doesn't mean I am flipping out lol I am just trying to talk about One Piece. I'm a nerd. Got nothing else better to do lol

I understand you are probably older than me and have had way more online arguments with people..... so I am sure you are probably sick of it at this point. It was my fault to ask.... sorry again... I just wanted to talk to someone about One Piece. I didn't mean anything to you personally..... Did I ever insult you? If I did it was on accident and again.... I apologize.

If it seems like I'm shouting at you I swear I'm not haha honestly I'm just trying to put emphasis in my words so my meaning stands out.

It's not a problem, bud. I just didn't see the point in writing multiple paragraphs over something like this. I do like One Piece, I just don't think it has very many pages that are still great without the context behind them.

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1075 Edited by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

@valorknight: Alright..... at least you like One Piece... I'll put my gun away LOL no jk xD

1 thing you do have to admit though.... compared to most other manga... it's usually hard to tell what it's from based off a single picture.

But when you're given a One Piece panel..... You know that's from One Piece. The style is too iconic!(:

Avatar image for valorknight
#1076 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

@piratekingoda: I actually disagree. I can usually tell what manga a page is from, as most artists have their own unique art styles.

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1077 Posted by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

@valorknight: Well I mainly just said that from the last few pics that you've posted like the animals and stuff. I guess we'll just agree to disagree. I'm not downplaying other mangaka, but I at least personally haven't seen an art style as unique as One Piece.... got one to recommend me?(:

Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1078 Posted by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

6. I like the shot but it feels so bland art wise.

Vinland Saga Chapter 35
Vinland Saga Chapter 35

Thorkell takes out a horse with a single punch.

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1079 Posted by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

8/10 Dope and God damn it lol

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1080 Edited by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

5. I get that this was an iconic moment in One Piece but it has so much going on in each panel and there are more creative ways to show off rapid hitting in art.

Vinland Saga Chapter 34
Vinland Saga Chapter 34

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1081 Posted by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

8.5/10 and it was kind of the point to feel a bit overwhelming. This one?

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for valorknight
#1082 Edited by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

9/10; that's a pretty clean one.

Hellsing Chapter 58
Hellsing Chapter 58

Avatar image for cognitive
#1083 Posted by Cognitive (1410 posts) - - Show Bio

8/10

No Caption Provided

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1084 Edited by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

omg 8.5/10 I loved that part haha XD Also... as the wise Beerus once said, "It always feels good to watch a planet exploding" even if that was a moon lol

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for warlockmage
#1085 Posted by Warlockmage (8161 posts) - - Show Bio

5

No Caption Provided

Online
Avatar image for shadowwaker
#1086 Posted by Shadowwaker (2495 posts) - - Show Bio

9

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for larcadedragneel
#1087 Posted by LarcadeDragneel (1355 posts) - - Show Bio

7/10

No Caption Provided

Avatar image for shadowwaker
#1088 Posted by Shadowwaker (2495 posts) - - Show Bio

8.

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for ovy7
#1090 Edited by ovy7 (1448 posts) - - Show Bio

8/10

Umineko no Naku Koro Ni Chiru - Episode 5: End of the Golden Witch
Umineko no Naku Koro Ni Chiru - Episode 5: End of the Golden Witch
Avatar image for warlockmage
#1091 Posted by Warlockmage (8161 posts) - - Show Bio

ummm 3 i guess because of the artwork

No Caption Provided

Online
Avatar image for valorknight
#1092 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

4/10.

Pupa Chapter 8
Pupa Chapter 8

Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1093 Posted by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

6. It's fine for me detail wise but that lighting looks awkward.

Millar & McNiven's Nemesis (2011) 4
Millar & McNiven's Nemesis (2011) 4

Nemesis' reaction to surviving the POTUS' attempt on a suicide bomb attack.

Avatar image for valorknight
#1094 Posted by ValorKnight (11077 posts) - - Show Bio

7/10; the art is cool, and the humor is dark enough to make me chuckle.

Hellsing Chapter 82
Hellsing Chapter 82

Avatar image for warlockmage
#1095 Posted by Warlockmage (8161 posts) - - Show Bio

2 man that is just ugly art, how do people read Hellsing? thats like 90s comics level

No Caption Provided

Online
Avatar image for vertigo-
#1096 Edited by Vertigo- (16999 posts) - - Show Bio

5. It's alright, but I don't like the artstyle, personally.

Transmetropolitan issue 1
Transmetropolitan issue 1

Online
Avatar image for life_without_progress
#1097 Edited by Life_Without_Progress (22205 posts) - - Show Bio

7. That's how natural world building works for an established character in a newly established world.

Wonder Woman (2012) 12
Wonder Woman (2012) 12

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1098 Posted by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

7.5/10

No Caption Provided
Avatar image for adamtrmm
#1099 Posted by adamTRMM (8246 posts) - - Show Bio

It's not bad, but nothing special either.

5/10

No Caption Provided

Avatar image for deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f
#1100 Posted by deactivated-5bc07bdd89a5f (1343 posts) - - Show Bio

4.5/10

No Caption Provided