On a scale of 1 to 10 (Including decimals. I'll even take 1 to 100, I don't judge) how would you rate the comic/manga page or sequence of pages above you?
It could be based off of artistic value or technical skill, emotional or plot significance, or just completely arbitrary!
And lastly, before I forget, it can also be a two-page spread, or even just a single panel or a sequence of panels cropped from a page.
Here's mine:
On a scale of 1 to 10 (Including decimals. I'll even take 1 to 100, I don't judge) how would you rate the comic/manga page above you?
It could be based off of artistic value or technical skill, emotional or plot significance, or just completely arbitrary!
And lastly, before I forget, it can also be a two-page spread.
Here's mine:
Nice. 9/10
A spread page from Wrath of the Eternal Warrior #5 by Juan Jose Ryp
Save
8.5/10! I like how the architecture of the city is very diverse, with medieval European walls and a Mayanesque pyramid citadel with Babylonian gardens.
8.5/10! I like how the architecture of the city is very diverse, with medieval European walls and a Mayanesque pyramid citadel with Babylonian gardens.
Very simple and kind of..."generic" but I am sure there is some context that I am missing that makes it even better. 7/10.
A page from X-O Manowar #50 (2012-2016) by Roberto de La Torre
A solid 8. I'll just chuck one up that I already have saved.
Pretty nice ill give it a 7-8.
Uhh. . . 6
Inspirational speech about science and discovery from Mr. Reed Richards. 8/10.
Spread page from upcoming X-O Manowar #2 (2017) by Tomas Giorello
9, singled armed or handed character are sorta a thing for me.
8
7.
4
7.5
8 I really like the character in the top hats design.
9. Love the shading
@kingeditor: Are panels cropped from a page also allowed? Are pages from novels also allowed? Either way, can you state that in the thread's original post. Thank you.
7.9/10
A page from Unity #9 (2014) by Stephen Segovia and Brian Reber
8-8.5
From Black Widow #16:
I just realized...I have a feeling a lot of people are going to post pages from Neil Gaiman's "Sandman."
From Black Widow #16:
Art is good, but "panneling" and layout and pictures seem "generic." Still...7.8/10
A page from Matt Kindt's Marvel Knights Spider-Man #3 by Marco Rudy and Val Staples
6
from soul eater # 59
from soul eater # 59
Looks good. I am sure that it would be better with colors though. 7/10
A spread page from Matt Kindt's Divinity II #3 (2016) by Trevor Hairsine, Ryan Winn, and David Baron
I recommend you read speech bubbles for more "amazingness."
9. That was super interesting.
@tacosheep: 9 and you will have to tell me what comic that is pretty please?
9. What is that page from?
@kingeditor: 7, im not quite sure what is going on in the scene.
@tacosheep Well, if you're curious, my page is the main protagonist of the work it's from reflecting on the last 100 issues of the 300-issue series.
As for your page... I'd say an 8. Normally, I despise text boxes showing the thoughts of characters in comic books, which are all over this image. But these ones are fairly decent, and the accompanying art is very nice.
I'll actually post the page that came right before it as my next post:
@kingeditor: After reading a little more about it the story seems fairly interesting, Cerberus seems like a unusual protagonist. I'll give this new page a 8 as well, seeing his old broken body as he relives his life through some kind o flashback (i think so atleast) really adds to it.
5... creepy like i like the artwork but its creeping me the hell out
8
Who is that bunny axe murderer!? 9/10
Who is that bunny axe scythe murderer!? 9/10
His name is Oz
OT: 7
7
8. I still need to read Tomboy.
8.5, but why are all Darkness/Witchblade girls half naked? Like Jackie himself gets full body armor, but all the ladies run around in their underwear. It makes it really hard to take seriously, lmao
@kingeditor:Are panels cropped from a page also allowed? Are pages from novels also allowed? Either way, can you state that in the thread's original post. Thank you.
That spread page is filled with a lot of adrenaline and speed. 8.9/10
A spread page from Fred Van Lente's Archer and Armstrong #0 (2013) by Clayton Henry and David Baron
@ultimate_knight Oh sure, that'd be fine.
And I would give yours an 8.5/10.
@ultimate_knight Oh sure, that'd be fine.
Oh thank you. Can you also point that out in the original post if you do not mind?
He seemed to ran all the way to that guy just to smack him on the face...8/10
Save
@ultimate_knight: 8.5/10 I like when comics have pages like this where the art & colors are just as involved in telling the story as the words written in them.
7. I like the animal designs here.
8... creepy AF
8. that final panel though.
5
5
7
7 I dig the color sceme and the struggle being depicted. Not much else.
Here's a scene, from one of my more adolescent admiration.
6, some areas of the page just kind of blend together, and it hurts my eyes trying to make out what's going on.
7 .
Log in to comment