• 79 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for jonez_
#1 Posted by Jonez_ (10756 posts) - - Show Bio

The first four films of the MCU were as follows:

  1. Iron Man
  2. The Incredible Hulk
  3. Iron Man 2
  4. Thor

While the first four films of the DCEU were:

  1. Man of Steel
  2. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
  3. Suicide Squad
  4. Wonder Woman

Comparing these two franchises at an equal point in their lifespan seems more fair to me than comparing them outright.

That being said, which had a stronger start? The MCU or the DCEU?

Avatar image for the_red_king
#2 Edited by The_Red_King (6 posts) - - Show Bio

I thought spite threads were banned on CV.

I mean, sure. Iron Man 2 was kind of bad. Thor was boring.

But the Incredible Hulk was decent and I don't need to say anything about Iron Man.

Avatar image for righteous300
#3 Posted by righteous300 (3790 posts) - - Show Bio

Reviews? No. Money? Yeah.

Avatar image for jonez_
#4 Posted by Jonez_ (10756 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for zaied
#5 Edited by zaied (6704 posts) - - Show Bio

I'd still take Iron Man and The Incredible Hulk over any DCEU film so far. Wonder Woman is the only one I can say I liked to a comparable amount, so the answer is no, but barely. Thor and Iron Man 2 were okay films, as are MoS and Suicide Squad.

Online
Avatar image for angeljax
#6 Posted by AngelJax (3049 posts) - - Show Bio

No.

Avatar image for jayc1324
#7 Posted by jayc1324 (22692 posts) - - Show Bio

Nah, about equal.

Online
Avatar image for jasonhawke
#8 Posted by JasonHawke (3030 posts) - - Show Bio

No.

Avatar image for uugieboogie
#9 Edited by uugieboogie (11657 posts) - - Show Bio

Well the MCU used characters who were barely household names and a bunch of C-listers while the DCEU used some of the most popular, iconic and well known comicbook characters in the world, excluding Suicide Squad. And even then they had Batman and Joker in Suicide Squad with Joker being one of the most recognizable villains thanks to being a Batman rogue and Heath Ledger. In terms of quality I think Iron Man is better than all of the movies listed above.

Avatar image for ouroborik
#10 Posted by Ouroborik (3004 posts) - - Show Bio

I think it is, so far they have only had one bad movie

Avatar image for legacy6364
#11 Edited by LEGACY6364 (5803 posts) - - Show Bio

DCEU had for more Gross Income in it's start.

Money wise DC Stomps.

Avatar image for lubub55
#12 Posted by lubub55 (8359 posts) - - Show Bio

Iron Man > Wonder Woman > Thor > Man of Steel > Suicide Squad > Incredible Hulk > Batman v Superman > Iron Man 2

Avatar image for saberscar223
#13 Posted by Saberscar223 (1486 posts) - - Show Bio

@legacy6364: because they used Batman Superman Wonder Woman and Joker all A-B mostly Aslisters while Marvel Used Iron Man a c list character, Captain America also a c list and Thor who is debatable and Hulk was the only A lister marvel had.

Avatar image for nickzambuto
#14 Posted by nickzambuto (29271 posts) - - Show Bio

@lubub55 said:

Iron Man > Wonder Woman > Thor > Man of Steel > Suicide Squad > Incredible Hulk > Batman v Superman > Iron Man 2

I love Batman v Superman.

Avatar image for thorthunder98
#15 Posted by Thorthunder98 (3985 posts) - - Show Bio

Nope

Iron Man was great, Thor was pretty good, IM2 and Incredible Hulk were okay.

WW was great, MoS was good, BvS was boring, SS was trash

MCU wins

And the only reason the DCEU has more gross than the first few mcu films is because the mcu made CBM's mainstream and paved the way for audiences. Also add to the fact DCEU opened with two of the most popular characters in fiction throughout the world.

The better comparison would be comparing phase 1 of the mcu to DCEU up to when Justice League comes out as MCU is missing Cap 1 and Avengers 1

MCU will still win unless JL is outright amazing and revolutionary

Avatar image for joetwoface
#16 Posted by JoeTwoFace (83 posts) - - Show Bio

No. The MCU introduced the characters individually and their first crossovers felt natural. With DC BVS felt forced.

Avatar image for aros001
#17 Posted by Aros001 (2321 posts) - - Show Bio

It's hard to say. While Iron Man 2 and Incredible Hulk are rarely on anyone's favorites list (I think there are a lot of people who forget the Incredible Hulk is an MCU movie), BvS and Suicide Squad both suffered notoriously from studio over-interference and cutting out things they shouldn't have, with only the extended cut of BvS helping the movie save some face.

Plus the bar for comic book movies is higher now, so it is more of an uphill battle than Marvel had back when Iron Man came out. I like most of the DCEU movies but I hate when people say "Well, if BvS or Suicide Squad came out before the MCU then nobody would have had a problem with them." Yeah, well, them didn't. The bar has been raised and we should try to make new movies at that level or past it. That's why, even though the Christopher Reeve's Superman and Tim Burton Batman are still beloved today, we don't keep trying to make movies just like them.

Online
Avatar image for righteous300
#18 Posted by righteous300 (3790 posts) - - Show Bio

@jonez_: I'll put it like this. With the exception of IM1, I haven't watched a Phase one movie more than once. I've watched MoS and BvS separately over a dozen times.

Avatar image for blacksmith_99
#19 Posted by Blacksmith_99 (1880 posts) - - Show Bio

Money wise, the DCEU grossed much more in the box office. Source: Box Office Mojo

  • Iron Man = Worldwide: $585.174.222
  • Incredible Hulk = Worldwide: $263.427.551
  • Iron Man 2 = Worldwide: $623.933.331
  • Thor = Worldwide: $449.326.618

Total = US$1.921.861.722 Worldwide

  • Man of Steel = Worldwide: $668.045.518
  • BvS = Worldwide: $873.260.194
  • Suicide Squad = Worldwide: $745.600.054
  • Wonder Woman = Worldwide: $571.801.730

Total = US$2.858.707.496 Worldwide

However, we have to take in consideration some things. The first MCU movies, except for the Incredible Hulk, were completely based off on C-list characters such as Iron Man and Thor. While the first DCEU movies were based off on A-list characters, with the exception of Suicide Squad (which had Joker and Batman as A-list characters), with characters such as Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman. Taking in consideration that the MCU was able to pull off such a big number with "unknown" characters (funny thing is: their A-list character movie, The Incredible Hulk, was the one which grossed the least), it might be debatable wheter the DCEU has a better start money-wise or the MCU had a better start money-wise. Box Office-wise is not debatable, the DCEU movies grossed the highest.

Quality-wise is pretty much to each one's opinion, if that's the case of this thread, then the title should have been "Do you think the DCEU is off to a better start than the MCU?". Well, to my mind, their both on par with each other. Man of Steel is one of my favourite CBMs, while Wonder Woman was great. BvS and Suicide Squads were both let downs for me. In the case of the MCU, Iron Man is one of my favourite CBMs of all time, while The Incredible Hulk was fun. Thor and Iron Man 2 were just bad, IMO. So, to my mind, they're both on par with each other.

Avatar image for ready_4_madness
#20 Edited by Ready_4_Madness (8292 posts) - - Show Bio

Yeah. Man of Steel and Wonder Woman are too solid. Thor is one of the worst things I've seen, Hulk is decent and IM2 is trash, IM is amazing but it doesn't carry the rest to victory imo.

Avatar image for mrmonster
#21 Posted by mrmonster (4616 posts) - - Show Bio

Absolutely. Sure Suicide Squad and Batman v Superman weren't perfect, but they were miles above Iron Man 2, Thor, and the Incredible Hulk. And Man of Steel and Wonder Woman were both better movies than Iron Man. So yeah, I'd say the DCEU is off to a much better start.

Online
Avatar image for lestrange
#22 Posted by lestrange (279 posts) - - Show Bio

I will take DCEU list any day

Wonder Woman > Iron Man

Man of Steel > Iron Man 2

Incredible Hulk > SS

BVS > Thor

Avatar image for lubub55
#23 Posted by lubub55 (8359 posts) - - Show Bio

@lubub55 said:

Iron Man > Wonder Woman > Thor > Man of Steel > Suicide Squad > Incredible Hulk > Batman v Superman > Iron Man 2

I love Batman v Superman.

I've only seen it once, and only the theatrical cut. I thought it was underrated, but I like every film I put above it greatly. Except The Incredible Hulk, which I'd probably put below it looking back.

Avatar image for nickzambuto
#24 Edited by nickzambuto (29271 posts) - - Show Bio

@lubub55 said:
@nickzambuto said:
@lubub55 said:

Iron Man > Wonder Woman > Thor > Man of Steel > Suicide Squad > Incredible Hulk > Batman v Superman > Iron Man 2

I love Batman v Superman.

I've only seen it once, and only the theatrical cut. I thought it was underrated, but I like every film I put above it greatly. Except The Incredible Hulk, which I'd probably put below it looking back.

I also love The Incredible Hulk.

Avatar image for lubub55
#25 Posted by lubub55 (8359 posts) - - Show Bio

@nickzambuto: I find it alright. Not a bad movie, but nothing special. The first scene of Bruce turning into the Hulk is one of my favourites in the MCU, though.

Avatar image for stefano
#26 Edited by Stefano (1711 posts) - - Show Bio

Since DCEU only has one good movie, no.

Avatar image for lubub55
#27 Posted by lubub55 (8359 posts) - - Show Bio

@nickzambuto:

Loading Video...

This is the part I was talking about. It's shot so well, and the lighting is amazing.

Avatar image for mazahs117
#28 Posted by MAZAHS117 (9319 posts) - - Show Bio

As far as quality goes, personally, I say they are about even; I have Iron Man and MoS about the same, IM2 and BvS cancel each other out, Incredible Hulk > Suicide Squad, Wonder Woman > Thor

Money wise? Have no idea. My bank account doesn't see a dime of these movies earnings, so I typically don't know much about or follow dollar figures these things pull in...all I do know is that they make a sh!t ton of bread

Avatar image for the_stegman
#29 Edited by The Stegman (38512 posts) - - Show Bio

Money wise yes, in terms of quality, it's opinion, but I say yes to that too.

If I had to rank them from best to worst;

1. MOS

2. Iron Man

3. WW

4. BvS

5. Thor

6. Incredible Hulk

7. Suicide Squad

8. Iron Man 2

Avatar image for asgaard
#30 Posted by Asgaard (3585 posts) - - Show Bio

#CV preferences insecurity thread number 92816826846871596269.

Avatar image for ithemanwithoutfeari
#31 Edited by ITheManWithoutFearI (4702 posts) - - Show Bio

Wonder Woman > Man of Steel > Thor > Hulk > Iron Man > Iron Man 2 > Batman v Superman > Suicide Squad (complete garbage imo)

Avatar image for superhero24
#32 Posted by Superhero24 (3157 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for kingyang
#33 Posted by Kingyang (386 posts) - - Show Bio

@lubub55: Thor better than Man of steel? 😂😂😂😂

Avatar image for lubub55
#34 Posted by lubub55 (8359 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for thelastdragonborn
#35 Posted by TheLastDragonborn (2047 posts) - - Show Bio

Hm maybe

Avatar image for manwhohaseverything
#36 Posted by Manwhohaseverything (3553 posts) - - Show Bio

Nah..MCU wins. Barely. I don't know about the Box-Office numbers really being in the DCEU's favor, because I don't know how much each movie cost to make and market. The important thing is profit margin, not just Box-Office dollars. (Same applies to comics where Marvel, even recently, always seems to "win", but my understanding is DC is winning the profit margin game in comics.) As for quality....and my personal opinions. I'd rank them:

1. Iron Man. I want to say WW, but I think that's still the high from having it be a recent view. My gut feeling says a year from now, I'll like Iron Man more.

2. WW.

3. MoS

4. Thor

5. IM2

6. BvS

Didn't see either Incredible Hulk or SS.

So..it may look even and the tie-breaker for me is razor thin, but here it is: I still think I'll see The Incredible Hulk someday. (maybe even soon). I have zero interest in SS. Also, the MCU's real heavy hitters are creeping around the corner after their first 4. And while I know that's not part of the question, we all know for the DCEU to pass up the MCU, JL will have to be amazing. I, for one, do not have much faith in the JL movie. (Though I do think Aquaman will be great...for some reason.)

Avatar image for rbt
#37 Edited by RBT (14761 posts) - - Show Bio

The way I'd rank the 8 movies-

  1. Wonder Woman
  2. Iron Man
  3. Batman v Superman
  4. Man of Steel
  5. The Incredible Hulk
  6. Thor
  7. Iron Man 2
  8. Suicide Squad

Last 3 are interchangeable.

Avatar image for sergeant-rl3
#38 Posted by Sergeant-RL3 (1661 posts) - - Show Bio

Best to Worst

  1. Iron Man (No contest)
  2. Man of Steel (Krypton was cool, destruction porn though)
  3. Incredible Hulk (Abomination)
  4. Thor (Kat)
  5. Wonder Woman (Vastly Overrated)
  6. Iron Man 2 (Bad)
  7. BvS Dawn of Justice (Garbage Tier)
  8. Suicide Squid (Garbage Tier)
Avatar image for captainmarvel4ever
#39 Posted by CaptainMarvel4Ever (9866 posts) - - Show Bio

No, starting with 3 awful movies is not a good way to go

Seems like they may possibly be picking up the ball though. If not, at least Wonder Woman was good

Avatar image for all-father
#40 Posted by All-Father (2399 posts) - - Show Bio

Content Quality its the MCU

Money wise its the DCEU.

I find Iron Man more enojoyable than every DCEU movie

Avatar image for theamazingspidey
#41 Edited by TheAmazingSpidey (14114 posts) - - Show Bio

In terms of success, MCU. Taking a group of lesser-known heroes (outside of Hulk) and making them into critical and financial successes was a great start for the movie.

In terms of my personal preference?

Wonder Woman > Thor > BvS > Man of Steel > Iron Man 2 > The Incredible Hulk > Iron Man > Suicide Squad

Avatar image for thorthunder98
#42 Posted by Thorthunder98 (3985 posts) - - Show Bio

People need to remember DC aren't too great with their profits

BvS grossed $900M+ but only profited $105M when even Ant-Man profited nearly that much at $103.9M

Suicide Squad actually profited more than BvS with $158M and MoS profit wasn't high at all either at $42.7M

MCU gets quite a bit more profit from their films generally compared to DCEU

I couldn't find the profits for those specific mcu films but here's some other comparisons of profits

No Caption Provided

Avatar image for the_fub
#43 Posted by The_Fub (794 posts) - - Show Bio

@jonez_: I feel like Thor is a vastly underrated movie. It was actually pretty good in what it did, which was intoduce a completely new side of the MCU.

The early MCU movies were better made IMO (for majority, with some exceptions) some of the stuff that the DCEU did was cooler though, but I blame that on them starting later.

Avatar image for thesenate
#44 Posted by Thesenate (469 posts) - - Show Bio

@asgaard: wouldn't have it any other way.

Avatar image for peterparkerjr
#45 Posted by PeterParkerJr (6710 posts) - - Show Bio

Since we're all ranking them:

  1. Iron Man
  2. Wonder Woman
  3. Man of Steel
  4. The Incredible Hulk
  5. Batman v Superman
  6. Thor
  7. Suicide Squad
  8. Iron Man 2

IMO, The Incredible Hulk with Ed Norton and Liv Tyler is very underrated. I really like that movie.

Avatar image for slayz
#46 Posted by Slayz (2139 posts) - - Show Bio

More or less even but I would give MCU the slight edge. Suicide Squad was just so mind-numbingly bad that it brings the DCEU down.

If Suicide Squad had been a match for Iron Man 2, the DCEU comes out ahead. If we give the films values this is how I see them;

MoS: 8

BvS: 6.5

WW: 7.5

SS: 3

Total of 25.

Iron Man: 8

Incredible Hulk: 7

Thor: 6

Iron Man 2: 6

Total of 27.

Avatar image for kevd4wg
#47 Posted by Kevd4wg (707 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm not sure

I would say Iron man > Man of Steel

The Incredible Hulk < BVS

Iron Man 2 > Suicide Squad

Thor = Wonder Woman (I don't know why but I absolutely love Thor but I can recognize that wonder woman is the better directed and realized movie.)

Avatar image for helloman
#48 Posted by Helloman (7574 posts) - - Show Bio

They are about equal in those terms.

Avatar image for theamazingspidey
#49 Posted by TheAmazingSpidey (14114 posts) - - Show Bio

MCU:

Iron Man: 5/10

The Incredible Hulk: 6/10

Iron Man 2: 6.5/10

Thor: 7.5/10

Total: 25

DCEU:

Man of Steel: 6/10

BvS: 6.5/10

SS: 3/10

WW: 10/10

Total: 26

DCEU wins.

Avatar image for earthsmightiest
#50 Posted by EarthsMightiest (2680 posts) - - Show Bio

No