Is Avengers: Infinity War a top 10 film of all time?

Top 10 in comic book movies? Hell yes!

Top 10 in movies in general? Hell no!

Of ALL movies? No, not even close.

It’s an easy top 10 for CBMs though

When have I ever rated it higher than TDK and Logan and Thanos over Vader and Joker?

@skywalker95: It's just opinions, but I was saying that the IW hype was high when I wasn't here at the time.

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/whose-the-better-villain-thanos-mcu-or-darth-vader-1957399/

Lol I forgot about that, yeah the hype took over me.

But where did I say IW is better than TDK and Logan.

Of all time? no

What DOFP comparison? And no, not even close. It gets stomped by films that I would never consider for top 10 status.

Not even close, though it would be in my top 10 CBMs (and maybe top 100 best movies).

Lol no

Yes for cmb tho

Absolutely not, despite it being the best MCU movie

Another day, another troll.

In its own genre? Sure.

In the entirety of cinema/films? Nah

Not even top 150 of all time

and it's hardly top 20 CBM

Hell no.

Top ten comic book movies sure but even then it is not even top 5.

maybe top ten in entertainment value, but not top ten in quality.

No lol, not even a top ten CBM.

Not even close

No

I mean, its all opinion in the end of the day, so sure, why not.

I mean from a pure film critic consesus, no.

But if someone have it in their top ten mpvies, I would understand.

Infinity War and Endgame will eventually be hasbeen films once a new, never-before-seen cinematic experience crushes both at the box office. Screw you Disney!

No CBM is in the top 10 list of all time

Oh God, no. It’s not even Top-100 of all time. As point of reference, I prefer Endgame to Infinity War and I wouldn’t place it in my Top-100 either. There’s around 130 years of cinema. That’s a lot of movies to consider before adding Infinity War to the top of film history.

It surprises me that this Detective alt lasted so long.

No, lmao.

Hell no

Hey thanks for the super helpful reply. I'm not sure how I missed that thread. I haven't quite mastered the search function on here. I think I'll pass with him this time around. If i want any further guideline we will contact you here https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/is-avengers-infinity-war-a-top-10-film-of-all-time-2094879/https://floridaloteryresults.com/

i personally don’t think it’s as good as days of future past, but it’s definitely in the top ten best comic book movies of all time for sure

It's a fun movie with some good stuff in it. Better than a lot of movies. Still it wouldn't make my list for top 10 films.

Nor would it crack my top 10 comic movie list.

I'm not sure it would crack my top ten MCU film list.

It's honestly probably bottom of the list for Avengers films for me.

Again that doesn't make it bad, as the MCU tends to turn out solid movies. It's just not my favorite.

Definitely above Endgame

👆

It's the last time we get the best version of the Hulk and he still hardly did 💩 besides get his ass handed to him by Thanos. Still at least he did something and sadly it was the last time we will see savage/ gladiator Hulk.

Definitively above Endgame and perhaps the best In all of MCU , but top Ten in all of cinema? please , not even top Fifty for me ( Ofcourse the answer is subjective )

Not even close.

Even if we narrow it to Hollywood only, I don't think it's even a top 100 film.

Yes.

I could probably fit both TDK and IW in my top 10, yeah. Other CBMs, not so much.

No

Top 3 MCU-Marvel

Top 5 CBM

.........

Subjectively and Objectively no.

All I can say is you should probably watch more movies if you genuinely believe that.

of all time? nah not even close

of CBM? honestly it depends some have surpassed it quite espectacularly