Is Avengers: Infinity War(2018) overrated?

Nah, at least not here.

nah

Is not a masterpiece. That´s all I need to say.

It was pretty good nonetheless

A little. It's a great movie, but it's not on the level of The Dark Knight or Logan.

Best Marvel movie to date IMO. Ebony Maw and Strange stole the show for me.

Thanos was really cool, but he wasn't menacing enough for my taste. He spared too many lives. The Gamora attachment was completely understandable though

No. It's a magnificent movie and a tremendous accomplishment.

I'd say it's the best CBM in terms of battles and bringing the fights to life though it isnt a better film than TDK but a great film nonetheless

Dang what took this thread so long lol.

And Hell no it was amazing

@grimus: The fact that Thanos sparred lives added depth to him IMO. Instead of him just being big punchy murder guy he respected those who fought for what they believe.

The only people he killed were people who tried to sneakily Attack him like a snake ( Loki) and people who he absolutely needed to do he could achieve his goal. He didn’t want to just go around killing people for fun. He had a strong sense of honor for those who fought him in battle.

I don’t think it was overrated. It absolutely delivered.

It had too much PIS, but it was very entertaining.

It's quite an achievement really. This movie had every reason to be an absolute mess with so many characters and overbearing components.

The fact the Russos delivered something far from that, exceeding my expectations at least.. I just gotta tip my hat to these guys. They killed it man. They just absolutely killed it.

@saberscar223: Very true but Loki had it coming. With Loki there is too much "Oh he's dea... wait he's ali.. wait he's dead."

Thanos was committing genocide throughout the cosmos though lol. I get that he let IM live (I think it was) because he admired him? The others didn't make sense to me

Yes.

But it's still a good move and an incredible achievement.

No

Hell NO! It has everything! Drama, Romance, Comedy, Action, Sci Fi, Adventure, Mystery it even has a fricken musical (kind of)!

No, it more than delivered on the hype, and it earned every single penny it got, and will get.

I think it is a pretty good movie.

It is better than TDK and equal to Logan in my eyes...

Nah it was fantastic

No. Honestly it may be the best CBM. I need to rewatch it again to be sure.

It was by far the best superhero movie I've ever seen, in no way was it overrated.

No, these overrated threads need to stop.

Is this thread a misunderstood masterpiece?

Compared to black panther, no.

It was good, but could've been so much more. I give it 9/10, it could've been 10/10 and people are acting as if it were.

No, it's the best MCU movie since TWS and CW on my book.

I dunno. Maybe? As a movie on its own it was definitely a spectacle and entertaining but I have a feeling Avengers 4 will really decide if IW was handled correctly.

Not at all. TDK and Logan might technically be better films, but IW stands alone when it comes to superheroes doing what superheroes do

Little bit, yeah. It was a really cool movie, but it didn't just blow me away.

Far from it.

It is among the best Superhero movies I've seen. Within MCU I'd put it up with Winter Soldier, Civil War, Guardians of the Galaxy, Iron Man, and Avengers as my favorite.

What pis

@kgb725: plot induced stupidity

Greedo

Nope. It's getting the results it deserves.

@heatforce: I'm asking what pis not what it means

It’s not a masterpiece but is the greatest and well made superhero movie I’ve ever seen after. Spiderman 2 is my favorite movie in general but in terms of superhero movies this is better

@kgb725: my bad.

I think so. I prefer MCU movies over DCEU but I didn't like Infinity War that much. Yes, it was entertaining but the amount of power inconsistency really irked me. I couldn't care less about Scarlet Witch and Vision's relationship. Plus, the "deaths" after the Thanos Snap was not convincing at all. Even Spiderman sobbing stirred no emotion for me. Everyone probably come back at the end so I was left with a "meh" feeling. It's not the best but it certainly isn't the worst. I liked Thanos, when he was actually wrecking folks, and I liked Ebony Maw. I'm glad Thor got a power boost but his Stormbreaker was wayyyyy too powerful.

As routine. Whenever a new popular movie comes out, there's going to be those who deem the movie overrated due to the hype. (Not talking to the author. Just in general)

My answer is no. It did a great job setting up Thanos to be a massive villain in the upcoming part 2 and had fantastic action scenes, great music, great writing for the characters, and had a super impactful ending.

Hell no it’s a CBM masterpiece. The best CBM and it’s showing it by dominating the box office like no other movie ever has.

Agreed. I think it's amazing to have that many big stars in a movie, have a well written plot, and everything still ties in together.

It's getting everything it deserves. Excellent film.

I guess it depends on who is rating it and what their criteria is. Is it the best movie ever made? Probably not. Is it the most entertaining? It's right up there. IMO it is easily the most powerful, compelling and intense super hero movie ever made.

Nope, best CBM to date.