Is a Black Widow movie a good idea?

Honestly, no

Yeah, as long as it's well written and competently directed it could be quite good.

Yeah, sure, why not.

Yes i would love to see her development

Street levellers just generally aren't all that compelling so I'm gonna go with no.

Edit: aside from Batman

No it's honestly too late. Should have done this before Avebgers or right after Winter Soldier.

Too late. They should have made a movie at least in Phase 2 followed by Phase 3.

Now they better focus on a new female character

Plus they should have cast someone who can do actual stunts instead of Scarlett. It is very obvious that she is using a Stunt double whenever she fights because she is not wearing a mask unlike other like Captain America.

Whiles I don't see the point of a BW movie now, it's not necessarily a bad idea either.

Yes and long over due

I like MCU Widow but I don't care too much if she gets a solo movie. That being said, if it does get made, I'm hoping it's a origin movie detailing the events when she defected from the KGB to SHIELD. Also it should have an Agent May and Coulson cameo, that's non-negotiable.

Good idea that needs to be done she earned it

Yeah one right after IM2 wouldve been great

Now it seems pointless

Yeah, she absolutely deserves one after the Russos took over and fixed the character.

As long as the film is good, it'll be a welcome addition.

I honestly don't see why she needs a movie. She's been filler in almost every MCU movie sans IM 2

Meh, I don't really care at this point

Yeah.

@solar_nerd I personally think it's a good idea. I don't get the people calling it a "bad" idea. If there's anything movies like The Lego Movie (a 2 hour commercial for toys??? who would want to watch that?), Guardians of The Galaxy (a movie about a Raccoon and a tree? Sounds terrible) and Blade Runner 2049 (a 30 year sequel to a classic with an ambiguous ending) have proven, is that there's no such thing as a terrible idea. Everything ultimately comes down to execution, and there's no reason a Black Widow movie can't be good. I think Scarlett Johansson is a great actress and the prospect of a Black Widow movie allows them to explore a facet of the MCU that is familiar yet different.

Bring it on.

Eh maybe

Tbh, it's not a film I'm interested in watching and I do think that one should have been made sooner but I suppose I could agree that a good movie wouldn't really hurt in any way.

I'm not interested in it but that's purely due to genre preference. Just not into spy shit...

I think it will do fine money-wise though and don't have any argument why they shouldn't. Should've capitalized on her popularity sooner though, seems like it's been shrinking in recent times.

She has a nice backstory and if the movie is done right it can be entertaining and fun, but the problem is that I just don't care about the character enough.

It'd be good if they do it well, but given the current political-correctness disease of the entire media industry now, it's most likely going to end up being a feminist cringefest.

Yeah sure.......like 8 years ago.

No.

Given to the right director it has the potential to be something incredible. Given to the wrong director it'll be an average Anti-Male climatic lack luster Feminazi pile of sh**.

Yes, it's long overdue.

Yes.

What seems strange to me is that supposedly the movie happens in the 2,000.

Which can mean several things.

1-Scarlett plays a 16-year-old girl, which is a terrible idea, since she obviously does not look that age. (Avengers 2 made this mistake, with Scarlett with a blonde wig pretending be a teenager.)

2-Natasha is older than she seems, which would be a good idea.

3-Only one part occurs in the 2,000 and she is interpreted by another actress in the scenes that occur in the past.

I just hope the directors do not make the stupid mistake of believing that Scarlett can play a teenager just by wearing a blonde wig.

I find this comment comical because it could be said about any movie.

No. It would be borderline intersting. Replace it with a movie for a character with powers.

They should make a Cold War story instead of a typical MCU story

I never understood this argument. There's no "best by" date for when you can create a movie, especially in an ongoing cinematic universe like the MCU. A good movie is a good movie.

Long overdue.

You say it would be a break from their comedic pattern, but she was almost the entire source of comedy in Winter Soldier

Ot: yes and no, the character has the source material for a movie, but I'm kinda over scarjo

I'm delighted to know that my words have galvanized the humorous parts of your consciousness.

There's potential for it, just don't go the comedy route for it

It might be, but I'll need a trailer to be excited.

At this point it's not a good idea unless it's with the punisher

I would've liked her to have a movie earlier as well, but the movie can still be good.

I could get behind this.