Hotter Supergirl: Laura Vandervoort or Melissa Benoist

Laura's no less hot, but Benoist is the infinitely better Supergirl all-around in my opinion; better costume, better performance, more emotional range, more stories, etc. Again, Laura was hot yes, but I think that Melissa Benoist has owned the Supergirl role pretty thoroughly since her show started. Honestly, I would even go as far as to say that Benoist is to Supergirl what Maguire is to Spider-Man and RDJ to Iron Man.

Laura is hot, yes. But I still prefer Melissa. Just something about her. Better smile, I guess.

@ifdcruledtheworld: Better costume too.

Melissa, but it's close.

Laura stomps in hotness, Melissa barely fits in "cute enough" category imo.

I've seen Laura and tbh Melissa wins.

No pictures? Got to google them?

*grunts*

Well, there ain't much for voluptuous femme lovers in there, is it? Both are skinny girlie type with mundane faces. I wouldn't even notice them on the street.

Here; Benoist. But I don't vote.

@shroudofsorrow: I prefer Smallville over the Arrowverse, but even I agree with you. As much as it pains me to admit it, Melissa is more definitive as Supergirl than Laura, and there's no need to ask which one will be more remembered in 20 years from now.

I voted for Laura, by the way