Fairy Tail vs One Piece Character Tournament

I'm bored so why not

The premise is whoever you think is the better character...not power scaling debate

- Character with more votes win obviously

- First series to reach 10 points wins

- Randomly generated match ups

- Voting will be up anywhere from hrs to a day

- Please be civil

Round 1: Igneel vs Kin'emon ( Huh...battle of father figures )

Vs

My brother.... You know not what you do...

OT: Kin unless Igneel did something in the 100yq sequel

Kinemon clears FT in writing, so he wins this matchup

These kind of threads don't really work if there's such a vast gap in iconicness and pop culture relevance between the two series, between the HST it works but unless you put relatively obscure OP peeps against the most well known FT ones OP will sweep every round.

Ot: So random, Kinemon has more depth and fleshing out, Igneel is cooler and has better moments I guess but that's really due to his purpose in the story as compared to Kinemon more than anything else.

Having watched both series and read their mangas, FT had better written main and side characters. So Igneel automatically wins this. Kinmeon was annoying both personality and design wise, and essentially filler (like 99% of OP cast), and added nothing to the main plot (that's still not answered after running for +25 years).

Oh no.

Igneel etc.

Kinemon isn't even a Top 50 One Piece character yet somehow clears the series.

This won't end well. lol. And yes I am fully caught up with both series.

Igneel was one of the few badass FT characters I actually liked despite his limited screen time. While I don't dislike Kinemon either, his fake out death in Wano still leaves a bad taste in my mouth, so my vote goes to Igneel

Going with Kin'emon.

5 for Kin'emon and 3 for Igneel so far...few more hrs

Some callouts

@lilgodperv@dimitri1220@cosmicemperor@uncannyrewind@ultimatesage@flameburn146@streak619

@leothegreatest@gogito@naronu@mantraxsp@eazy_pezy

In general, One Piece has far better writing than Fairy Tail in pretty much every aspect and the same applies to characters, but it's closer IMO. However, in terms of R1, I got Igneel winning because of him being more memorable and having a much bigger and fulfilling role in the story than Kinemon. .

Igneel was not only badass but also a caring father figure. Although he wasn't present much in the series, he was still a major driving force for Natsu. Kinemon I felt was ok but at time very annoying.

Igneel I’d say due to his significance in the series to the MC.

Alright that is 6-5 for Igneel...the fire dragon king wins

Round 2: Trafalgar D Water Law vs Wendy Marvell

vs

@shirso@flameburn146@wushu59@cbarlion@molt@pics@cocacolaman@binnk@mangacomics69@dimitri1220@lilgodperv

Backing law for his character, Story & personality. Wendy's bland imo.

Law

Law with ease. Just better in every aspect

Law

Law in an absolute curbstomp for me. I don't hate Wendy by any means, but Law is probably my favorite character in OP

Law clears every single character in Fairy Tail with ease and there is zero thought that needs to be done.

Low is trash.Your typical gary sue.But Wendy is also trash.Pass for me

For round 1, Igneel is above Kinemon. He subverted expectations of what he was supposed to be and plays a more active role in the series even in memory and while Kin isn’t bad he doesn’t have any nuance to his character.

For round 2, Law is just better at every turn really. Way more compelling.

@dertilt said:

Law EASILY. Bro could honestly clear the series lol.

Law Lol.

Law a gray sue? This man has been getting his ass handed to him by damn near everybody Lol.

Law suffered from disease that was suppose to kill him, saw his baby sister explode in front him, hid in a pile of dead bodies and joined a mafia at a young age with bad intentions strapped with explosives all over himself ready for war and is somehow a "Gary Sue."

lmao

Law has this in his grip.

Wendy

Wendy. Law is the most overrated one piece character. Absolutely terribly written. Just having a run of the mill sad backstory doesn't make someone good character.

Wendy is easily one of the best handled fairy tail character.

Wendy

Wendy

Dude had infinite stamina against Meme

"This is my last attack,after that im out of stamina"

1 Chapter later

"Ok,THIS is my last attack.After that im out of stamina"

1 Chapter later

Still being able to spam his DF

And like you say,let Low win a fight before claiming hes good.Loser never won a single 1on1 fight in his whole life.

Wendy

Wendy.

Law will always remain a character I can never appreciate in one piece.The author tried really hard to make law relevant in dressrossa by tying in his backstory with Doflamingo's but it became disjointed. It was never carried to his present day state or arc. His character development and revenge mission as the story progressed had no link to the pointlessly long backstory. The law from his origins story and the current law we know are like two different persons that the author tied into one in last moment to make him more relevant in the arc.

Anyway,Wendy gets my vote.She suxs in 100YQ but is decent recently

Alright while Wendy got more votes than I thought she would this is clearly a stomp in law's favor given the staggering amount of votes he has...the pirate doctor wins

Round 3: Usopp vs Acnologia

vs

Usopp. Acnologia is more or less a generic big bad archetype.

I despise Usopp but Acnologia just sucked. I'm voting Acnologia purely because I can mentally bare to go back to a scene with his presence.

If I have to vote on character work alone it's Usopp, unfortunately.

How can you despise arguably the most relatable character in One Piece bruh

Usopp easily clears Fairy Tail in it's entirety lol. I'm about to go over why.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Luffy and Usopp are part of one of the most realistic and believable arguments in terms of writing in Shonen

2. Luffy vs Usopp is one of the most iconic anime / Shonen fights period.

3. The conclusion of Luffy vs Usopp has one of the most iconic Shonen shots

4 and 5. Sogeking burning the Flag Down and Usopp screaming at Luffy who is bleeding profusely on the ground to get up.

Two more of the most iconic shots in anime / manga.

6. God Usopp. Yet another one of the most iconic shots in Shonen.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Meanwhile... Acnologia is just a generic villain who is part of one of the worst Shonen arcs an asspulls in manga history.

Lucy accidently bumps into a bookshelf to figure how to beat Acnolgia and he lose to the power of friendship. lmao

Go to 11:43 for the bookshelf part in this video. Really hilarious. lol

Acnologia. Absolutely love the concept. The way he is used as a unstoppable force of nature that the usually rainbow powered protagonists can do nothing against but to accept him for what he is - an anomaly that should be avoided at all cost. The way he goes down is lame..and he didn't need that backstory. But he still remains as the most unique character in fairy tail.

Ussopp would have been better if he stopped appearing after first 200/300 chapters or so. Now with every breath he draws he keeps sinking lower and lower..just like most of the other strawhats

Acnologia

Acnologia

@wushu59 said:

Usopp easily clears Fairy Tail in it's entirety lol. I'm about to go over why.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Luffy and Usopp are part of one of the most realistic and believable arguments in terms of writing in Shonen

2. Luffy vs Usopp is one of the most iconic anime / Shonen fights period.

3. The conclusion of Luffy vs Usopp has one of the most iconic Shonen shots

4 and 5. Sogeking burning the Flag Down and Usopp screaming at Luffy who is bleeding profusely on the ground to get up.

Two more of the most iconic shots in anime / manga.

Loading Video...

6. God Usopp. Yet another one of the most iconic shots in Shonen.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Meanwhile... Acnologia is just a generic villain who is part of one of the worst Shonen arcs an asspulls in manga history.

Lucy accidently bumps into a bookshelf to figure how to beat Acnolgia and he lose to the power of friendship. lmao

Go to 11:43 for the bookshelf part in this video. Really hilarious. lol

Loading Video...

This and props for the KoL vid