Poll Elevator fight VS Warehouse fight? (82 votes)
Which fight do you like more? Elevator escape from TWS or Warehouse fight from BvS? Include the helicarrier takedown in the Elevator sequence too.
Which fight do you like more? Elevator escape from TWS or Warehouse fight from BvS? Include the helicarrier takedown in the Elevator sequence too.
The BvS Warehouse scene is the best street level action sequence in a CBM so far.
Everything about it is superior to the Elevator scene. From the dramatic setting to the set design, the stakes, the action choreography, the background score, the brutality and the details with which the moves were picturized.
The elevator scene is brawling for the most part. And the Russos feature too many cuts and an oversaturation of the shaky cam effect. Too many cuts means the actors/stuntmen aren't skilled enough to replicate the moves in one go and it also means inferior choreography in general. Shaky cam looks good to an extent and if done in a balanced manner. It portrays a sense of realism but works the best only in spy movies. Too much Shaky cam in superhero movies means we miss out on the details.
Don't even know what's so special about the elevator scene, if anything the run on the ship was much better.
"Before we get started... does anyone want to get out?"
If you hear this line and you don't get what's so special, then all I can say is you are missing out sir.
Warehouse by a country mile for me.
There was so much more at play; the gadgets, the stealth, the brutal takedowns, the damsel in distress. It was just better. The elevator scene was still pretty great, though.
Warehouse fight.
Elevator fight didn't have any lethal weapon like knife, guns, grenade or flame thrower & cap had huge stat advantage then those fodders.
Warehouse scene by a country mile. Also Batman could do the elevator fight better than Cap *runs for log off button*
Elevator was vastly superior and it feels wierd to say this but unlike Batman he actually refrained from killing his opponents if possible...
The Warehouse scene was a masterpiece by street level battle standards, the Elevator scene, as awesome as it was, did not reach the same level of choreography, blend of fighting styles or tension. If BvS did only one thing right, it's the larger scale action sequences.
Warehouse, it was almost like Arkham gameplay and was about time we saw an impressive and theatrical live action Batman fighting sequence after Nolan made him look weak.
Elevator scene. It’s not close for me.
The BvS Warehouse scene is the best street level action sequence in a CBM so far.
Everything about it is superior to the Elevator scene. From the dramatic setting to the set design, the stakes, the action choreography, the background score, the brutality and the details with which the moves were picturized.
The elevator scene is brawling for the most part. And the Russos feature too many cuts and an oversaturation of the shaky cam effect. Too many cuts means the actors/stuntmen aren't skilled enough to replicate the moves in one go and it also means inferior choreography in general. Shaky cam looks good to an extent and if done in a balanced manner. It portrays a sense of realism but works the best only in spy movies. Too much Shaky cam in superhero movies means we miss out on the details.
This.
Before Infinity War, I had Winter Soldier as the best MCU movie (and tbh I'm still not quite sure where I place IW). Conversely, I have BvS as the worst of the DCEU (yes I'd rather watch Suicide Squad). That said, I think I gotta give it to the warehouse scene here. Both were great though.
I don’t really see how it’s debatable. The warehouse scene is much more intricate and has far better choreography. A better option would be the warehouse and the highway scene.
Warehouse fight, there was way more to this and it gave you the first look at what batfleck could do.
Warehouse fight was a lot better. There was a lot more variation in the attacks Batman had to deal with, and simply more action and excitement. Guns, knives, grenades, breaking through the floor, busting people's heads with crates, just a great scene overall that showed more skill and tactics. Better than Cap bullying some humans. What the Elevator scene did well was build up to the fight and show how much more powerful Cap was, but the fight itself was not that special.
The BvS Warehouse scene is the best street level action sequence in a CBM so far.
Everything about it is superior to the Elevator scene. From the dramatic setting to the set design, the stakes, the action choreography, the background score, the brutality and the details with which the moves were picturized.
The elevator scene is brawling for the most part. And the Russos feature too many cuts and an oversaturation of the shaky cam effect. Too many cuts means the actors/stuntmen aren't skilled enough to replicate the moves in one go and it also means inferior choreography in general. Shaky cam looks good to an extent and if done in a balanced manner. It portrays a sense of realism but works the best only in spy movies. Too much Shaky cam in superhero movies means we miss out on the details.
Yep.
Warehouse and not even close.
The BvS Warehouse scene is the best street level action sequence in a CBM so far.
Everything about it is superior to the Elevator scene. From the dramatic setting to the set design, the stakes, the action choreography, the background score, the brutality and the details with which the moves were picturized.
The elevator scene is brawling for the most part. And the Russos feature too many cuts and an oversaturation of the shaky cam effect. Too many cuts means the actors/stuntmen aren't skilled enough to replicate the moves in one go and it also means inferior choreography in general. Shaky cam looks good to an extent and if done in a balanced manner. It portrays a sense of realism but works the best only in spy movies. Too much Shaky cam in superhero movies means we miss out on the details.
QFT
Warehouse, it was almost like Arkham gameplay and was about time we saw an impressive and theatrical live action Batman fighting sequence after Nolan made him look weak.
Like this
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment