DC or Marvel who has more iconic stories under their brand ?

  • 52 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for lightingjack
Posted by LightingJack (1474 posts) 11 days, 25 minutes ago

Poll: DC or Marvel who has more iconic stories under their brand ? (61 votes)

DC 66%
Marvel 34%

.

Avatar image for riddlersriddle
#1 Posted by Riddlersriddle (3494 posts) - - Show Bio

Honestly I feel like Marvel has more instantly recognisable stories than DC but it's pretty close

Avatar image for saberscar223
#2 Posted by Saberscar223 (4621 posts) - - Show Bio

Probably marvel most of the Dc ones I think of are Batman self centered

Avatar image for jb681131
#3 Edited by jb681131 (3385 posts) - - Show Bio

Well to decide we should make a list of iconic story:

DC:

  1. Jack Kirby's Fourth World
  2. Batman: Year One
  3. The Watchmen
  4. The Dark Knight Returns
  5. Saga of Swamp Thing (by Alan Moore)
  6. Batman: The Long Halloween
  7. The Killing Joke
  8. Crisis On Infinit Earths
  9. Batman: Knightfall
  10. Whatever Happened to the Capped Crusader ?
  11. DC: New Frontier
  12. Superman: The Man of Tomorrow
  13. The Death of Superman
  14. All-Star Superman
  15. Hal Jordan: Rebirth
  16. Sinestro Corps War
  17. Blackest Night
  18. Batman: No Man's Land
  19. The Flash: Born to Run / Flash: The Return of Barry Allen (by Mark Waid)
  20. Flashpoint
  21. Wonder Woman Gods and Mortals (By George Perez)
  22. Wonder Woman: The Hiketeia
  23. Hellblazer
  24. Sandman
  25. Kamandi
  26. Identity Crisis / Infinit Crisis / Final Crisis
  27. New Teen Titans (by Marv Wolfman)
  28. Gotham Central
  29. Batman & Son (and the Grant Morrsion run)
  30. Batman: The Owls Saga
  31. Superman: Birthright
  32. Superman: Red Son
  33. Superman: Secret Origins
  34. The Shazam! Family
  35. Kingdom Come
  36. V for Vendetta
  37. Animal Man (by Grant Morrison)
  38. Batman: Hush
  39. Arkham Asylum (by Grant Morrison)
  40. JLA (by Grant Morrison)
  41. Batman: Mad Love
  42. Batman: The Man Who Laughs
  43. Superman: Brainiac
  44. Superman: Last Son
  45. Green Lantern / Green Arrow

Marvel:

  1. Dardevil by Frank Miller
  2. X-Men: New Genesis / Dark Phoenix Saga (Chris Claremont part.1)
  3. Planet Hulk / World War Hulk
  4. The Man Without Fear
  5. Daredevil: Born Again
  6. X-Men: God Loves, Man Kills
  7. X-Men: Days of Future Past (Chris Claremont part.2)
  8. Spider-man: Death of the Stacys
  9. Spider-man: Kraven's Last Hunt
  10. The Infinity Gem Saga
  11. Old Man Logan
  12. Civil War
  13. Captain America: The Man of Tomorrow
  14. Daredevil: Yellow
  15. Spider-man: Blue
  16. Hulk: Grey
  17. Hulk: Future Imperfect / The End
  18. Spider-man: The Alian costume saga
  19. Spider-man: Big Time / Spider-island
  20. Secret War
  21. Thor Mighty Thor (by Walter Simonson)
  22. Winter Soldier (by Ed Brubaker)
  23. Death of Captain America (by Ed Brubaker)
  24. Ultimate Spider-man
  25. Spider-Verse
  26. House of M
  27. The Galaxtus Trilogy
  28. X-Men: Age of Apocalypse
  29. Annhilation
  30. Avengers vs. X-men
  31. Runaways
  32. Iron Man: Demon in a bottle
  33. Maximum Carnage
  34. Secret Invasion
  35. Fall of the Mutants
  36. Age of Apocalypse
  37. Mutant Massacre
  38. Wolverine (by Chris Claremont)
  39. The Kid Who Collects Spider-man
  40. Spider-man: Grimm Hunt / The Gauntlet
  41. PunisherMAX

Unless I missed some obvious stories, DC Wins.

Avatar image for the_agent_of_chaos
#4 Posted by The_Agent_Of_Chaos (986 posts) - - Show Bio

DC. the marvel wank is hard.

Avatar image for lightingjack
#6 Posted by LightingJack (1474 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for ghostodoofus2
#7 Posted by Ghostodoofus2 (2011 posts) - - Show Bio

@jb681131: Great list but you included V for Vendetta twice. A few more I like that I think belong in the list are the New Krypton saga, Batman: Death in the Family, Throne of Atlantis, Green Arrow: The Longbow Hunters, Teen Titans: The Judas Contract, Justice, Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow, Must There Be a Superman and Legion of Super-Heroes: The Great Darkness Saga. Although it's highly underrated and far from iconic, the Batman comics by Alan Grant and Norm Breyfogle deserve some love.

Online
Avatar image for ghostodoofus2
#8 Posted by Ghostodoofus2 (2011 posts) - - Show Bio

@jb681131: As for your Marvel list, I believe the Captain America: Man of Tomorrow you're referring to is Captain America: Man out of Time. You also should include Iron Man: Extremis.

Online
Avatar image for tomkatie
#9 Edited by Tomkatie (3488 posts) - - Show Bio

Weird comic superiority complex aside, iconic to comic fans means something totally different than iconic to casual audience fans

If you go up to someone on the street and ask for classic comic arcs they’ll probably say “Infinity War and Endgame”

Comic-wise, there are some damn classic X-Men arcs, then Infinity (Gauntlet, War, Crusade) as well as Crisis on Infinite Earths and Judas Contract. Honestly, I’d say it’s pretty tied in comics

Avatar image for gateofbabylon
#10 Posted by GateOfBabylon (5028 posts) - - Show Bio

While DC has more iconic characters, Marvel has more iconic stories imo.

Avatar image for drveo08
#11 Edited by Drveo08 (515 posts) - - Show Bio

@gateofbabylon: what marvel stories are more iconic than Watchmen or The Dark Knight Returns?

Avatar image for supermanfan1938
#12 Edited by Supermanfan1938 (392 posts) - - Show Bio

@jb681131: Why is Identity Crisis, Infinite Crisis and Final Crisis listed together, they're not even remotely similar to each other outside of having Crisis in the name.

Superman Beyond should also be on the list. And For the Man Who Has Everything which got adapted twice already (JL cartoon, CW Supergirl). Also Lucifer by Mike Carey

Avatar image for gateofbabylon
#13 Edited by GateOfBabylon (5028 posts) - - Show Bio

@drveo08: I didn't mean that Marvel stories are more iconic (I see now that my post was worded poorly). I meant they have more iconic stories, as in more of them. But that's just purely in my book. I'd completely understand if you disagree, it's all up to individual exposure.

Avatar image for supermanfan1938
#14 Edited by Supermanfan1938 (392 posts) - - Show Bio

The most iconic stories:

DC: Superman is jesus story

Marvel: Comoc accuracy story lolI love deadpool and spoderman theyare funny like the comics XD

It's a tie

Avatar image for jb681131
#15 Edited by jb681131 (3385 posts) - - Show Bio

@supermanfan1938: I don't know about Lucifer. It's very good, but is it Iconic ?

Superman beyond - never heard of it.

Why not for The Man Who Has Everything. But it's not that well known even if it's been adapted.

The 3 Crisis stories are linked. Maybe Identity/Infinit and Final can be seperated.

Avatar image for ready_4_madness
#16 Posted by Ready_4_Madness (18209 posts) - - Show Bio

DC

Online
Avatar image for killer94
#17 Posted by Killer94 (540 posts) - - Show Bio

DC has far more iconic stories than Marvel. Iconic in a sense that it elevated the comic book medium in a more "serious literature" territory.

Avatar image for mike_fowler
#18 Edited by Mike_Fowler (5372 posts) - - Show Bio

@jb681131: left off the following for marvel

41. The Ultimates Vol. 1 and 2

42. Punisher MAX

43. Spider-Man: The Death of Jean DeWolffe

44: Spider-Man: If This Be My Destiny

45. Fantastic Four (by Jonathan Hickman)

46. Hawkeye’s run by Matt Fraction

And I’m probably forgetting some other iconic runs/stories

Avatar image for killer94
#19 Edited by Killer94 (540 posts) - - Show Bio

@jb681131:

Include the ff for DC:

  • DMZ
  • 100 Bullets
  • Fables
  • Transmetropolitan
  • Planetary
  • League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
  • Promethea
  • The Invisibles
  • Ex Machina
  • Y: The Last Man
  • American Vampire
  • Astro City
  • Daytripper
  • Kid Eternity
  • Loveless
  • Sheriff of Babylon
  • Sweet Tooth
  • Scalped
  • Hitman
  • Superman: Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
  • Superman for All Seasons
  • Superman: Secret Identity
  • Preacher
  • Joker
  • The Multiversity
  • The Authority
  • Identity Crisis
Avatar image for jb681131
#20 Posted by jb681131 (3385 posts) - - Show Bio

@killer94 said:

@jb681131:

Include the ff for DC:

  • DMZ
  • 100 Bullets
  • Fables
  • Transmetropolitan
  • Planetary
  • League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
  • Promethea
  • The Invisibles
  • Ex Machina
  • Y: The Last Man
  • American Vampire
  • Astro City
  • Daytripper
  • Kid Eternity
  • Loveless
  • Sheriff of Babylon
  • Sweet Tooth
  • Scalped
  • Hitman
  • Superman: Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
  • Superman for All Seasons
  • Superman: Secret Identity
  • Preacher
  • Joker
  • The Multiversity
  • The Authority
  • Identity Crisis

I really like those too, but are they really all "Iconic" ? Event if some are of better quality like "100 bullets", "Transmetropolitan" and "Sweet Tooth".

By the way, "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen", is not from DC at all.

Avatar image for cramem
#21 Posted by Cramem (401 posts) - - Show Bio

I'll add these for DC:

-Dark knight Metal

-Doomsday clock

-The return of superman

-Batman: Death of the family

-52

-Trinity war

-Forever evil

-Batman: Requiem

-Batman Eternal

-The great darkness saga

-Injustice: gods among us

-JLA: The tower of Babel

-JLA: Justice for all

Avatar image for scholomance
#22 Edited by Scholomance (65 posts) - - Show Bio

@killer94 said:

DC has far more iconic stories than Marvel. Iconic in a sense that it elevated the comic book medium in a more "serious literature" territory.

Avatar image for scholomance
#23 Posted by Scholomance (65 posts) - - Show Bio

@jb681131 said:

By the way, "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen", is not from DC at all.

LXG was originally published by DC (at least the Vol. 1 & 2 and its OGN, The Black Dossier), but Moore went batshit crazy and decided to switch publishers.

Avatar image for lightingjack
#24 Posted by LightingJack (1474 posts) - - Show Bio

@scholomance: DC recently released a LOEG omnibus ... they still have the rights i think

Avatar image for scholomance
#25 Posted by Scholomance (65 posts) - - Show Bio

@scholomance: DC recently released a LOEG omnibus ... they still have the rights i think

Yes, they have the rights for the first two volumes and the OGN.

Avatar image for lightingjack
#26 Posted by LightingJack (1474 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for lightingjack
#28 Edited by LightingJack (1474 posts) - - Show Bio

@scholomance: hey another question does dc also holds rights of top 10 by alan moore ?

Avatar image for scholomance
#29 Posted by Scholomance (65 posts) - - Show Bio

@scholomance: hey another question does dc also holds rights of top 10 by alan moore ?

Technically Yes. America's Best Comics is a subsidiary/imprint of DC.

Avatar image for entropy_aegis
#30 Posted by entropy_aegis (20960 posts) - - Show Bio

@cramem: Return of Superman is considered part of the Death saga. I'll give you Great Darkness Saga and maybe Tower of Babek but the rest are far from iconic. Doomsday Clock in particular isn't even finished yet.

Avatar image for thehercules
#31 Posted by TheHercules (1199 posts) - - Show Bio

I think this a battle between, JL against X-Men, which is very hard, but I vote DC

Avatar image for thedeathstroke
#32 Posted by TheDeathstroke (3068 posts) - - Show Bio

DC imo

Avatar image for nucleon
#33 Posted by Nucleon (3889 posts) - - Show Bio

In general, Marvel's run-of-the-mill and continuity is better than at DC's, but DC's stories are more, well, iconic, more full of red, white and blue, more grandiose in scope and symbolism.

Avatar image for tdk_1997
#34 Posted by TDK_1997 (18919 posts) - - Show Bio

The older DC comics stories and most of the Batman stories are iconic, but they are nowhere near as much as the iconic Marvel ones. What I am saying is not that Marvel's stories are better but they are just better recognized, more acclaimed and people actually know about them.

Online
Avatar image for the_agent_of_chaos
#35 Posted by The_Agent_Of_Chaos (986 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for tdk_1997
#36 Posted by TDK_1997 (18919 posts) - - Show Bio
Online
Avatar image for nucleon
#37 Edited by Nucleon (3889 posts) - - Show Bio

@entropy_aegis: Have you re-read "Great Darkness Saga" of late? Terrible, infantile story, horribly written, all over the place, with drawings to match it. But damn, it was so good when I was 14.

Avatar image for finalkingthanos
#38 Posted by FinalKingThanos (3028 posts) - - Show Bio

I would say it’s pretty even overall tbh probably DC has more solo iconic stories due to Batman but both sides have great stories and characters in spades.

Avatar image for ready_4_madness
#39 Posted by Ready_4_Madness (18209 posts) - - Show Bio

@tdk_1997: Watchmen is arguably more iconic than any Marvel storyline.

Online
Avatar image for scholomance
#40 Posted by Scholomance (65 posts) - - Show Bio

@tdk_1997 said:

The older DC comics stories and most of the Batman stories are iconic, but they are nowhere near as much as the iconic Marvel ones. What I am saying is not that Marvel's stories are better but they are just better recognized, more acclaimed and people actually know about them.

What's more iconic than Watchmen and TDKR?

both comics revitalized the comics industry in the 80's, these two classic stories influenced a generation of future writers to create a more adult oriented comics.

Avatar image for tdk_1997
#41 Posted by TDK_1997 (18919 posts) - - Show Bio

@scholomance: @ready_4_madness: The question of the thread isn't which publisher has the most most iconic story but which one has more of them. So, what the creator of the thread is asking is for more than one storyline. All I am saying is that Marvel has a bigger number of them than DC.

Online
Avatar image for zaggran
#42 Posted by Zaggran (203 posts) - - Show Bio
@tdk_1997 said:

The older DC comics stories and most of the Batman stories are iconic, but they are nowhere near as much as the iconic Marvel ones. What I am saying is not that Marvel's stories are better but they are just better recognized, more acclaimed and people actually know about them.

What's more iconic than Watchmen and TDKR?

Crisis on Infinite Earths.

Which is also DC, obv.

Avatar image for ready_4_madness
#43 Posted by Ready_4_Madness (18209 posts) - - Show Bio
Online
Avatar image for tdk_1997
#44 Posted by TDK_1997 (18919 posts) - - Show Bio
Online
Avatar image for ready_4_madness
#45 Posted by Ready_4_Madness (18209 posts) - - Show Bio

@tdk_1997: how? You said that most of the classics came from Batman, without naming where all the other classics come from.

Online
Avatar image for tdk_1997
#46 Posted by TDK_1997 (18919 posts) - - Show Bio

@tdk_1997: how? You said that most of the classics came from Batman, without naming where all the other classics come from.

You want me to list all of the classic stories?

Online
Avatar image for bayman007
#47 Posted by Bayman007 (2498 posts) - - Show Bio

DC

Avatar image for captainsweatpan
#48 Posted by CaptainSweatpan (2618 posts) - - Show Bio

This thread is just calling for fanboyism and wankage

Avatar image for ready_4_madness
#49 Posted by Ready_4_Madness (18209 posts) - - Show Bio

@tdk_1997: I want you to tell me which other characters have classics of their own.

Online
Avatar image for gracetrack
#50 Edited by Gracetrack (4785 posts) - - Show Bio

DC for sure.

And personally, I'd also include these on DC's list.

  • The Return of Bruce Wayne
  • Swamp Thing by Scott Snyder
  • Aquaman: The Trench
  • Batman: Endgame
  • Dark Nights: Metal
  • The Batman Who Laughs
  • Batman: Last Knight on Earth (depending on how well issue #3 finishes things out)