@etragedy: yes and no to your question...
This list DOES have an inital order based upon the cosigns from last step (I have you cosigning a few things, but it's been a few months since we did that step).
You are correct in saying in spots it is alphetized. However, all the stories have some total from cosigning whcih we used to make this inital order. In the spots the story totals had ties they were automatically alphabetized.
ex:
- Amazing fantasy #15
- Amazing Spider-man #50
- The Death of Gwen Stacy
- Amazing Spider-Man #300
all of the above have the same ranking based on cosigning. You can look at votes to see which title is ahead such. I will not deprive you of that information.
However, I can not stress enough that voting DOES matter. This is a very rough estimate of what the list will be like and there are a number ties, but it is an estimate never the less that you should REALLY pay attention to.
As you have sort of noticed and I can confirm without giving any totals there IS a tie between 55-79 of the initial order, so there is a little leyway on the actual ranking of this group of stories, but there is a possibility that the story that @jedixman didn't like will make the list. You have participated in my lists before so you might know that I never guarantee any story 100 % to be on the list, but I believe my advice still holds importance because unlike past lists we only have 110 stories. that means there are only 10 slots for the runner up list and thus better chances of stories staying on the list.
The story in question is ranked 70. What does that mean exactly? There is no guarantee it will be on the list and there is no guarantee the other way either, but it does mean that it is 30 slots from being off the list. Heed my words and my warning. if you find something you disagree with...fix it now while you still have chance to
Log in to comment