Better Casting: Alan Ricthson as Jack Reacher or Charlie Cox as Daredevil?

As much as I love Alan Richtson as Jack Reacher, I gotta go with Charlie Cox on this one.

Cox as DD. Alan Ritchson's a great Reacher though.

Cox definitely gave a better performance, but Ritchson is the perfect casting for Reacher.

@frozen: Off-topic, I think Alan Ritchson would be a great Ben Grimm/The Thing.

Got to give it to Cox, even though Ritchson was also great.

I like Charlie as DD more. Reacher was good tho. He’s great as Hawk on Titans. …and Ritchson would’ve made a for a great Captain Marvel/Shazam. For the life of me I don’t know why that never became a thing.

Zachary Levi is perfect as Shazam.

@mazahs117: He could become a Thing though, he's my pick for Ben Grimm.

Yup he is, I think so too. I do also think you darken Ritchson’s hair, throw a Captain Marvel /Shazam costume on him and he’s a spitting image of Alex Ross’s rendition image of the character. Plus he has the natural size, and personality for the role too. Who knows, maybe down the road he could be a Earth2 Captain Marvel since we’re in the “Multiverse“ phase of cbm’s.

Hmmph..Y’know I never thought about him as Grimm before, but I can see it.

Cox is amazing as Daredevil. He, Jon Bernthal as the Punisher, and Krysten Ritter as Jessica Jones should never be recasted in the MCU.

As someone who doesn’t read the source material, both were top notch castings.

@mazahs117: you darken Ritchson’s hair, throw a Captain Marvel /Shazam costume on him and he’s a spitting image of Alex Ross’s rendition image of the character

Gallery

@w3b: Pretty much spot on

@mazahs117: Yeah I can see it, only problem is that Ritchson himself might not want to play yet another DC character after having already played Hawk and pre-Aquaman Arthur Curry (in Smallville).

True, I completely forgot about Smallville. He’s great in all his roles. It’s just a shame he never landed Capt Marvel, I think he would’ve slapped as the character

Charlie cox because I don't even know who alan ritchson is

Ok, although I voted for Cox, I do believe a lot of voters are not familiar with Ritchson's Reacher.

I didn't notice you comment. Glad to see you're still around these parts.