One Piece edges out Star Wars IMO with both being better than the other in some regard but OP being superior overall: the sheer grand interstellar scale of Star Wars eclipses OP, however One Piece islands each have their own character as Oda usually takes the time to give a backstory, explain the geography and the history of the people living there. The narrative of SW may not be limited to one planet but the planets themselves I’d argue aren’t as interesting as some islands in OP with many being basic in layout and recycled- Kamino a water planet, Tatooine a desert planet, Jaku another desert planet, Mustafar a volcano planet etc the depth doesn’t go more than the basic geography/general culture info. Whereas in One Piece islands are in the sky, cities on the backs of walking elephants and the lore is intertwined with the location ala Zou and the poneglyphs. Additionally the layout of particular islands is fleshed out when Oda draws the maps, that way we know what is where, the distances in relation to eachother and where the characters are/need to be as seen for Dressrosa, Totland and Wano.
While the planets in Star Wars are simply planets, the islands in OP feel like characters themselves, the rich lore of Wano for example. overshadows any backstory given for a planet in SW taking into account the world itself and its people.
GoT/ASoIAF comes in third. The multi-stranded narrative offers an insight into various locations where we have a good understanding of the struggles of each group of people. The size of settlements for the most part have a well realised sense of scale where we know where things are in relation to eachother- the opening credits do a superb job. But unfortunately, the story sticking to two continents- with only half of Essos being seen on the screen and books- makes its world building lesser overall compared to OP and SW.
Harry Potter’s world building while good, doesn’t even come close to the other three. The bulk of the story takes place in a castle, with more exotic locations like Albania, Romania etc only getting mentioned and the story never taking us there. Hogwarts, Surrey and London make up the majority of seven books with slight departures on occasion like the World Cup but this isn’t nearly good enough. The information the reader/watcher gets is wizard heavy with the other races either only having a cursory overview or a particular representative (Dobby for elves) being an individual to represent the group’s identity. Compare this to the Fishmen in One Piece for example where we have a clear picture of the struggles they face, the discrimination, the slavery, the fight for liberty and freedom with Fishman like Tiger Fisher etc yes we know the House Elves are basically slaves but we don’t get much more depth and it doesn’t help that we only get one character who’s eyes we see most of the story from thereby giving a limited perspective. The addition of Newt and his Beasts helps matters but that still doesn’t move HP from clear last place.
Log in to comment