Batman Begins vs Batman Year One

Begins, by far. Year One is overrated.

Huh interesting. I would really have to think about it before responding.

Yeah I read Year One twice and still don't really get it.

Although I don't love the Nolan films either so I'm not voting.

I'd take any Frank Miller Batman story (Minus The dark knight strikes again) over every Batman movie.

Year one. One of my favorite batman movies

The movie. it was the same as the comic, only with better character moments, better writing, and none of Frank Miller's fetishes.

Begins.

Both are some of the best Batman material but I have to go with Begins.

Begins, no contest. Year One is a pretty good read, but it still has those excesses that Miller is so prone to (prostitute Catwoman). Begins has none of that.

• Both were good for different reasons..But i prefer Begins by far.
• It was the film that made me a Batman fan as a kid.

The comic was decent, but I always felt like the movie took a decent story and made it great.

Wow reading this made me feel old

I still need to watch Year One.

Year One.

Yep...Its been a minute..lol

Even All-Star Batman & Robin?