I have been messing with the Transformers comics and characters lately. The problem is they have gone by multiple publisher creating multiple timeline and alternate universes. GI Joe and TMNT have done similar. The question is what would be the best way to setup the character pages. I'm using Transformers as my example but of course GIJoe and others would be similar.
The First is how "Some" if not most of the pages currently look with each Publisher being listed as it's own Major Story Arc.
Origin
Major Story Arcs
Marvel Comics
Generation 1 Continuity
Marvel UK
Generation 2 Continuity
Devils Due Continuity
GI Joe vs. Transformers
Dreamwave Productions
Dreamwave Continuity
Armada/Energon Continuity
3H Publications
Universe Continuity
Beast Wars
Fun Publications
Shattered Edge Continuity
IDW Publishing
Beast Wars
IDW Continuity
Generation 1 Continuity
Powers and Abilities
Characteristics
- Height:
- Weight:
- Alt-Modes: Tank
- Color Scheme:
Other Media
Television
Film
IDW Film Continuity
Titan Magazine Film Continuity
Video Games
The Second would be breaking them into 2 Story Arcs, Generation 1 Continuity (Marvel, UK, IDW) and the IDW Reboot Continuity with other (Dreamwave, Fun, Beast Wars etc) listed as Alternate Versions (similar to the reboot kings on the DC Comics pages).
Origin
Major Story Arcs
Generation 1
Marvel Comics
Marvel UK
IDW Publishing
IDW Publishing
Devestation
All Hail Megatron
The Transformers
More Than Meets They Eye
Robots in Disguise
Powers and Abilities
Characteristics
- Height:
- Weight:
- Alt-Modes: Tank
- Color Scheme:
Alternate Versions
Devils Due Continuity
Dreamwave Productions
Dreamwave Continuity
Armada/Energon Continuity
3H Publications
Universe Continuity
Fun Publications
Shattered Edge Continuity
Other Media
Television
Film
IDW Film Continuity
Titan Magazine Film Continuity
Video Games
The Third would be more in line with other characters, having the "Main G1" continuity, and all others listed as Alternate Versions with small summaries (similar to how Marvel Ultimates are handled). The only issue with this is what is really considered main now the original G1, or the new IDW ongoing.
Origin
Major Story Arcs
Marvel Comics
Generation 1
Marvel UK
IDW Publishing
Regeneration One
Alternate Versions
Devils Due Continuity
Dreamwave Productions
Dreamwave Continuity
Armada/Energon Continuity
3H Publications
Universe Continuity
Fun Publications
Shattered Edge Continuity
Titan Magazine
IDW Film Continuity
IDW Publishing
Robots in Disguise
More Than Meets the Eye
IDW Film Continuity
Powers and Abilities
Characteristics
- Height:
- Weight:
- Alt-Modes: Tank
- Color Scheme:
Other Media
Television
Film
Video Games
In addition to the Alternate versions they also have a tendency to re-use character names in other Universes that may or may not be related to the original G1 character. Therefore should these character pages have some distinguishing title ie; "Characters Name" (BW) - Beast Wars, (A) - Armada. Currently they don't and would need to be changed one at a time (although I did find one with Armada that another user added). Or since these characters normally only appear in one Publishers books by assigning them to that Publisher would help with confusion. The only issue would then arise if they then appear in an IDW comic in the future as that character (example IDW gets the Armada/Energon rights).
Log in to comment