Avatar image for cloudguy
#5501 Posted by Cloudguy (2347 posts) - - Show Bio

@kaneundertaker2: I think the problem with those characters is that most of what happens to them is superficial in the grand scheme of things. The Pikachu example wouldn't apply as we consider Pikachu(s) their own character so the fact it evolves wouldn't factor into that decision.

Although, I do think that if the Japanese counterpart of Ash has enough information that can be detailed out, it can be merged with the Ash Ketchum page explaining that he was based on Satoshi as off the top off my head their is no information about his Japanese origins.

@pikahyper@renchamp Any thoughts.

Avatar image for kaneundertaker2
#5502 Edited by kaneundertaker2 (49 posts) - - Show Bio

@cloudguy: It shouldn't be merged with Ash at all as he is Red's counterpart not Ash's. Red is the game character from the original games and the manga Satoshi appears in is based directly off those games (even including the hunt for the Safari Zone Warden's dentures) The anime where Ash originates from is only loosely based on those games and many locations and characters that appear in the anime do not appear in the games or the manga. So if the mods do decided to merge the pages it should be with Blue and Red not Ash and Gary. But if they did that they'd probably have to do the same with Emerald & Jun, Diamond & Hareta and Platinum & Mitsumi as well.

Avatar image for herrdoktorbd
#5504 Edited by HerrDoktorBD (33 posts) - - Show Bio

Please delete the second (incorrect) image for Bors Bergsen. Thanks!

Avatar image for cloudguy
#5506 Posted by Cloudguy (2347 posts) - - Show Bio

@kaneundertaker2: I'm not sure if the site is eating your posts or you're deleting them after posting them (I can see them in my notifications tab, just not here). But I do think you've made your argument.

While I do think that their isn't enough to differentiate them to be their own unique characters in the same way Elseworlds or What If characters don't have their own pages (most of the time). You seem passionate about them having their own pages and I don't know enough about Pokémon manga to honestly say how different they are.

Avatar image for kaneundertaker2
#5507 Posted by kaneundertaker2 (49 posts) - - Show Bio

@cloudguy: I deleted a few of them because my spelling was terrible. The Elseworlds/What If comparison is a fair point, however in most of those cases the characters have exactly the same name as there counterpart in this case they have two (four) very different names and characters.

Avatar image for cloudguy
#5509 Edited by Cloudguy (2347 posts) - - Show Bio

@kaneundertaker2: No need to delete them. You can edit posts after you've posted them if you refresh the page.

I think what I'm doing is associating the Ash character with this Different version of Satoshi; because if you watch the Japanese version of any of the Pokémon shows. He's called Satoshi.

Avatar image for kaneundertaker2
#5510 Edited by kaneundertaker2 (49 posts) - - Show Bio

@cloudguy: so is Red in some cases (mainly the games) they are all named after Satoshi Tajiri, the creator of Pokemon but this particular Satoshi is not known by any other name.

Avatar image for kaneundertaker2
#5511 Posted by kaneundertaker2 (49 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for herrdoktorbd
#5512 Edited by HerrDoktorBD (33 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for lawiedc
#5513 Posted by lawiedc (7 posts) - - Show Bio

Apologies - I put up several poor quality images this week in the 1950 volume Eagle ( https://comicvine.gamespot.com/eagle/4050-20802/ ). For issues 530-534 I have added a second cover which is re-levelled and trimmed.

Also, issue 528 has the cover for an October issue showing. I have added the correct issue as a second cover.

Avatar image for cloudguy
#5514 Posted by Cloudguy (2347 posts) - - Show Bio

Hawkman Megaband should be deleted as it already exists as two separate volumes. The latter being the correct listing.

Avatar image for cloudguy
#5515 Posted by Cloudguy (2347 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for jazz1987
#5516 Posted by jazz1987 (218 posts) - - Show Bio

Bill Cipher should be deleted since he appears in no issue.

Avatar image for chasexclamationpoint
#5517 Edited by chasexclamationpoint (1 posts) - - Show Bio

The cover used for Metalshark Bro #1 is incorrect. This was before the team members were changed--Shawn Greenleaf is no longer associated with the project. The correct cover (with Chas! Pangburn listed) has been uploaded below it. If these could be swapped, that'd be great. Thank you so much!

Avatar image for herrdoktorbd
#5518 Posted by HerrDoktorBD (33 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for cloudguy
#5519 Posted by Cloudguy (2347 posts) - - Show Bio

This image in the Stephanie Brown gallery should be moved to Knightfall as it's the latter character,

Avatar image for herrdoktorbd
#5520 Posted by HerrDoktorBD (33 posts) - - Show Bio