John Byrne's Man of Steel or Frank Miller's Batman Year One

Which comic did you enjoy more?

Man of Steel was very good for what it was, but Batman Year One , for me, was one of the best comic arcs ever.

Out of those two, Year One.

As a better origin story, Birthright (yes I know it isn't listed).

Year One is my favorite arc of all time.

Hard to say. Year One is very well written, has nice dialogues, very good art and a nice Batman Story.

Year One is Miller's best Batman story in my opinion, but I have to go with The Man of Steel. John Byrne is my favorite.