Avatar image for captainamerica119
Edited 3 years, 9 months ago

Poll: Does anyone wlse not really consider Watchmen DC? (38 votes)

Yes 47%
No 50%

I mean it was published under DC but it was basically an independent comic. It was a lot darker than other DC comics

Avatar image for rulerofthisuniverse
#1 Posted by RulerOfThisUniverse (6518 posts) - - Show Bio

No, it was published by DC. Therefore it is a DC comic, no matter what the tone. If the question was "Does Watchmen have a different tone than other DC Comics?" The answer would be an obvious yes.

Avatar image for soa
#2 Posted by SoA (6245 posts) - - Show Bio

it was its own entity just like vertigo and wildstorm characters were independent of DC at one point

Avatar image for gator4eva
#3 Posted by gator4eva (409 posts) - - Show Bio

When I think of DC comics Watchmen doesn't come into mind so in that sense yes, but technically is is considered a DC comic. So yes it is a DC comic, no I don't really think of it as a DC comic.

Avatar image for tupiaz
#4 Edited by tupiaz (2259 posts) - - Show Bio

It is Allan Moore's work and he got screwed by DC and it has nothing to do with DC's universes. Also what do you what to have answered? I don't think this is a question about how wise you are but how you view creators rights. Do you want my opinion if I think Watchmen belongs to DC or do you want to know if I think only wise people think it doesn't belong to DC? Maybe I' over thinking this.

Avatar image for MadeinBangladesh
#5 Posted by MadeinBangladesh (12470 posts) - - Show Bio

It was DC but not part of the Universe.

Avatar image for ssejllenrad
#6 Edited by ssejllenrad (13109 posts) - - Show Bio

It's a part of the DC Multiverse. And as for the tone, DC elseworlds stories have mostly been dark so that argument is invalid.

Avatar image for codysf
#7 Posted by CODYSF (2240 posts) - - Show Bio

It's DC

Avatar image for jonny_anonymous
#8 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (45699 posts) - - Show Bio

What are you pepole talking about? Watchmen is 100% a DC comic with DC characters

Avatar image for sinestro_gl
#9 Posted by sinestro_GL (3651 posts) - - Show Bio

DC doesn't automatically mean DCU

Avatar image for rustyroy
#10 Posted by RustyRoy (16535 posts) - - Show Bio

It's a part of the DC Multiverse. And as for the tone, DC elseworlds stories have mostly been dark so that argument is invalid.

Avatar image for longbowhunter
#11 Edited by longbowhunter (9425 posts) - - Show Bio

DC doesn't automatically mean DCU

Here Here

Avatar image for rdclip
#12 Posted by RDClip (2222 posts) - - Show Bio

It was published by DC and Moore was working for DC while writing it for DC. Just because it doesn't take place in the DCU, doesn't mean that it isn't a DC book. It would be like saying since Marvel doesn't have fantasy princesses and musical animals, it isn't part of Disney.

Avatar image for zeeguy91
#13 Posted by Zeeguy91 (1624 posts) - - Show Bio

DC doesn't automatically mean DCU

Yeah, but the question is pertaining to DC. A lot of titles that DC published are not set in the main DCU. Hell, a lot of elseworlds like Dark Knight Returns and All Star Superman were never canon in the DC Universe. Does that make them any less DC? No.

And I know the retort that while they aren't set in the DCU, they still have the DC characters, while Watchmen doesn't. However, the Watchment characters are all based off of DC characters that already existed. I'm sure that you know this, but Alan Moore was originally going to use Captain Atom, Blue Beetle, and other Charton characters that were owned by DC.

Avatar image for awesam
#14 Edited by AweSam (7527 posts) - - Show Bio

It's DC. You can't not consider it DC.

Avatar image for sinestro_gl
#15 Posted by sinestro_GL (3651 posts) - - Show Bio

@zeeguy91 said:

@sinestro_gl said:

DC doesn't automatically mean DCU

Yeah, but the question is pertaining to DC. A lot of titles that DC published are not set in the main DCU. Hell, a lot of elseworlds like Dark Knight Returns and All Star Superman were never canon in the DC Universe. Does that make them any less DC? No.

And I know the retort that while they aren't set in the DCU, they still have the DC characters, while Watchmen doesn't. However, the Watchment characters are all based off of DC characters that already existed. I'm sure that you know this, but Alan Moore was originally going to use Captain Atom, Blue Beetle, and other Charton characters that were owned by DC.

Elseworlds is a pretty niche area of DC...Watchmen isn't directly comparable to Elseworlds because...Watchmen isn't Elseworlds...

Avatar image for brcomicbookguy
#16 Posted by Brcomicbookguy (23 posts) - - Show Bio

I know there all copy's of other heros and a lot of people loved the watchmen comic. But with the 52 reboot maybe they could introduce the watchmen to the main DCU as a team without the events of the comic taking place. I think the comedian had more story's in him.

Avatar image for chocolatefrogs
#17 Posted by ChocolateFrogs (194 posts) - - Show Bio

It has the DC imprint, so it's a DC comic.

Nowadays I would expect it to be published under the Vertigo imprint.

Avatar image for princeimc
#18 Edited by PrinceIMC (5506 posts) - - Show Bio

Isn't Rorshach based off the Question? Isn't Nite Owl based off Blue Beetle? Isn't Dr. Manhattan based off Captain Atom? Isn't Silk Spectre sort of based off Black Canary? It definitely feels like a DC book to me even though they were mainly Charlton comic characters.

Avatar image for billy_batson
#19 Edited by Billy Batson (59808 posts) - - Show Bio

Isn't Rorshach based off the Question? Isn't Nite Owl based off Blue Beetle? Isn't Dr. Manhattan based off Captain Atom? Isn't Silk Spectre sort of based off Black Canary? It definitely feels like a DC book to me even though they were mainly Charlton comic characters.

Silk Spectre is based on Nightshade, Ozymandias on Peter Cannon and the Comedian on Peacemaker.

BB

Avatar image for princeimc
#20 Posted by PrinceIMC (5506 posts) - - Show Bio

@princeimc said:

Isn't Rorshach based off the Question? Isn't Nite Owl based off Blue Beetle? Isn't Dr. Manhattan based off Captain Atom? Isn't Silk Spectre sort of based off Black Canary? It definitely feels like a DC book to me even though they were mainly Charlton comic characters.

Silk Spectre is based on Nightshade, Ozymandias on Peter Cannon and the Comedian on Peacemaker.

BB

I'm not really as familiar with those original characters but you gotta admit there's at least a little bit of Black Canary in Silk Spectre.