Victarion Greyjoy Vs Brienne of Tarth

Victarion Greyjoy

Brienne of Tarth

Rules

Morals Off

Bloodlust Off

Standard Gear

Win by death

Fight takes place in a gladiator pit

Book and TV feats

Perfect Teamwork

Prime unless stated otherwise

Bonus Round

Fight takes place on a boat

Callouts:

@kiadisandwich@xerolot@the_red_viper@aatroxxx@discipulus@cregan_stark@lubub55@jedixman@superhero24@rogueshadow@thesuperor@buildhare@ithemanwithoutfeari@the_wspanialy@paragonnate@princeleif@the_fallen_lord@six-deuce@marvelanddcfan24@kingcrimson@green_skaar@helloman@danikerhino@ginman333@thedailybagel@the_fub@destinyman75@jooosh1996@elpizo@omriamar@godren@thorthunder98@chronicplane@keenko@asianantics@cdiddyman911@robertmiles1@thelastwarrior@xerolot: @the_red_viper: @rogueshadow: @cpt_nice: @lubub55:@godren@princeleif@green_skaar@thorthunder98@discipulus@rabumaiai@rabumalal@aatroxxx@chubbs@asianantics@destinyman75@cregan_stark@the_fallen_lord@necromancer76

Victarion murders her, more savage, more experienced and of course with better feats. She's too green right now, but she clearly has potential. I'm talking book versions btw.

If it wad purely book version of Brienne then I'd say Victarion stomps. Adding show feats for Brienne makes this very compelling. I'll have to think on this one

Victarion mid difficulty.

Victorian decimates second round. Wins first with moderate difficulty.

@rogueshadow: I agree that if this is book versions the Vic stomps. Show feats make me pause though

Show Brienne is probably about Victarion level. His superhuman arm might give him the edge he needs to take it, but Valyrian steel is also an advantage.

Mm tough one Victorian is the best fighter of the Iron Islands, but Brienne beat a near equal in the hound..... Going Victorian as he is even more brutal then the hound and will not hold back despite her sex, though Brienne Does make a good fight of it.

I can see Brienne winning. But as others said, if it was strictly book versions, Vic would gut her like a fish.

Any well forged sword will stand up to Valyrian steel just fine, and really the Valyrian-steel-quality honestly is almost a non-factor in most battles.

Sometimes you just have to include book versions in these battles because some characters are literally featless in the show.

I disagree. Much has been made about the sharpness, lightness and fine balance of Valyrian steel, Brienne describes it as coming alive in her hands and that she is faster with it than she ever was without it. Dawn, equal to Valyrian steel, is enough to give Dayne the edge over Barristan, an otherwise equal combatant.

Valyrian steel is never going to give Grenn the victory over the Mountain, but it can be a pivotal factor between two well matched foes.

@princeleif: Vic isn't featless in the show, he just doesn't exist in the show lol. They kinda "merged" his character into Euron.

Oh, is that description in the books? I didn't see it mentioned in the show that it could help with agility in combat, I only knew Dawn could give that sort of advantage in combat, my bad. But still, at least any finely forged sword still won't have to worry about breaking from Valyrian steel.

Well yeah that's what I meant. lol At least they chose Euron, the cooler one.

Victarion

^ My thoughts on this, really. I haven't read the books in a few years and so my memory of Victarion isn't great, but I seem to remember estimating him as someone of the Hound's calibre, which would make show-version Brienne an interesting opponent.

Victarion.

Why would they fight if they had perfect teamwork!? lol

Victarion wins in both cases.

Eh tough. Probably Vic though. Even though Brienne is better on the show the only people of note that she has best were either A. Caught off guard or B. In a weakened state

@chubbs: Sorry, it was just me lazily copying and pasting the rules from one of my old threads that was similar but a 2v2.

@cdiddyman911: lol it's cool. Was just joking around about it. I knew that was the case

Show version include ?(I suppose you talk about Euron in this case because Euron Book+Victarion Book =Euron show)

Anyway

Victarion maybe win (but after a very hard fight)

Euron Win (show version) .(after a pretty good fight)

In a boat ?Victarion.

@thelastwarrior: No, show version was pretty much meant towards her, for Victarion only when it is actually Victarion.