Toby Maguire vs Andrew Garfield vs Tom Holland. Which spiderman wins?

Tom Holland will be regular suit not Iron spider

One is still in high school and the other couldn't even save his girlfriend, Toby puts some dirt in their eyes and stomps.

Boy...I have to go with Toby because he has feats against big bads way more than Tom and Drew. Tom did not have a great offensive showing against big bads. Tom's abilities seem more defensive. Toby has the best balance. But Drew should do well against both.

I see Tom going out first, then Drew, and Toby wins.

@nitefall87: so Tom doesn't have good offense yet Andrew does?

Either Toby or Tom wins. They're the strongest and toughest. Andrew can only last due to speed and reaction, but he can't really win without using the environment. He can't deal or take damage like the other two can.

"Stings, doesn't it?"

Tom is the most agile IMO

Toby is the most experienced

And Andrew, well...forget about him

Im gonna go with Tom, simply because he’s faster and more agile.

@eslay03: Garfield is a lightning timer... he’s physically the weakest here though. His agility is way above Tom.

Aw look at little Spider-Man Jrs, gonna cry?

Tobey took a full hit from a train. He solos Iron Man Jr and Gwen killer

This will answer all of your questions.

Garfield blitzes

Tom is the most durable.

Andrew is the fastest.

Tony is the strongest.

@hermes1220: Physically the weakest? I dunno, he seems on par with Tom...maybe not...LOL...

@rebake:I didnt mean that. I was trying to say that Drew is more middle road. He was able to handle thugs on average a lot better. And Croc. Most of Tom's main offensive feats without a tech suit are from Civil War, where he puts on a good showing. I dunno brotha, maybe my memory is just bad.

@nitefall87: Yeah Tom and Toby are stronger iirc. But speed and agility are no contest when you compare him to them.

@hermes1220: Yeah he’s definitely the fastest. The time square scene in The Amazing spiderman 2 clearly shows that. But I just didn’t want to take the time to make an argument for him. I meant that between Toby and Tom, Tom is the faster. But Andrew is obviously the fastest of the three, I just was to lazy to try to argue for him.

If Tom has his FFH suit he wins this

Even In homecoming he showed greater strength feats cuz of lifting a large amount of debris and this was without the spider suit

Holland got no diffed by a train. Tobey solos

Toby stomp.

It doesn’t matter because let’s face it...ps4 Spider-Man would beat all 3 of them. Especially if I’m controlling him

Tobey has experience and organic web shooters. Garfield has speed. Holland has spider sense and edges out Tobey physically. Depends on who goes after who

Tobey beats Tom if he got done fighting garfield

Tom beats Tobey if hes done with garfield

Andrew loses to either one but could beat one of them if they're done fighting the other

Tobey imo beats Tom with experience in a close fight

Tobey has the strength, Andy has the speed, and Tommy has the agility.

Also it's Tobey, not Toby, this misspelling is common as Reeves instead of Reeve.

Tobey has the most strength, willpower, durability and experience against the most eclectic villians

Garfield is the fastest and quickest thinker out of the three

Tom's a baby compared to the others but his web combinations and Stark tech make him the most versatile in terms of gear

Tobey's probably the Spider that comes out on top. Between his insane striking and damage soak the other two won't be able to put him down unless they double team him but he still has the best chance considering he's the only one with experience fighting an enemy with similar powers (Venom)

Tobey overall

Tobey.

@andrewgarfield: I am gonna put some dirt in ur eye!

Tobey by far. Him stopping the train with sheer muscle strength is still by far most impressive direct showing of power and toughness we've seen from any spiderman. He's also the oldest, most mature and experienced one.

Not to mention he's the one with organic webs. So he won't run out of them, and he can't be stripped off this power with any webshooter malfunction.

When it comes to speed all 3 reacted to bullets, so they should be comparable.

Tobey wrecks the other two, one hand each.

@bearderby: @sabracadabra: @comicgirl21:

You guys rock!

@comicgirl21: When did Tobey react to bullets?

Been done.

Maguire is too strong, skilled and durable. He kicks their teeth in.

I don't see how one of them would win against Tobey

The Spiderman 2 intro fight scene for example. Tobey is shot at by goons with machine guns and he swings up around and than below the bullet shot trajectories, clearly going out of their way intentionally.

Tobey solos

Tobey

@comicgirl21: That’s honestly just aim-dodging bad aim.

Some of it perhaps, but you can clearly see he pulls himself UP with one hand, and immediately after he does that, bullets hit where he would be if he didn't do that. And that's not an opening shot from these goons, so that's not aim-dodging. He knew where the bullets are gonna hit, and he dodged them, so he could see them and react to them. What makes it even more impressive is that he does it mid air when he has very limited options for changing his trajectory and overall mobility. Yeah. Tobey can react to bullets just fine.

Holland tanked a speeding bullet train which is on a whole other level that what Tobey stopped and two Holland straight up tanked it while Tobey used multiple buildings and webbing to stop the train. Not comparable. Tom low diffs both on his own.

Tom solos neg diff the other two with eyes closed.

@wolverinebatmanftw @comicgirl21: Tom out here making Cull Obsidian look like a trained pet but Tobey solos sure haha. Been done. Tom solos neg diff.

Tobey stopping a speeding train after fighting to hold back the trains momentum is leagues above anything the other Spideys have done strengthwise. They also haven't taken poundings from a giant sandman either so Tobey takes it, then Tom then Andrew.

Garfield still blitzes

@comicgirl21: No it’s still aim-dodging, there’s no shot seen of him dodging after the bullets were fired.

I don't think you know what aim-dodging means. He was being shot at continuously for the entire scene. He can aim dodge the first few bullets when they take aim at him, sure. That's what is called aim-dodging. But how can he aim-dodge AFTER they started shooting at him? Like, in the very MIDDLE of the shootout he just moves out of the way of the bullets and you say he aim-dodged? That's absurd. Meh, I think I'm done with this conversation. Please don't tag me back. Arguing over established definitions bores me to death.

Tobey negs, holland fans are delusional

@comicgirl21: This exact scene was discussed a number of years ago and was dismissed as aim-dodging. In the gif you posted you can clearly see the bullets hit the building after he’s already moved meaning they were shot after he moved ergo that’s aim-dodging. Unless you’re blind that’s what happening, their trash aim is causing them to shoot where he used to be not where he is.

In the last moments you just see him swinging down as the bullets land above him, he’s not even attempting to dodge the shots themselves unless you believe his downward swing moves faster than bullets.