@wut said:
@merulezall: I don't count discount Space Marines, so don't worry about that. :P Protoss were winning their slap fest with other Protoss? Well, if Protoss fights Protoss, I hope Protoss would win. Be rather embarrassing if Protoss fights Protoss and some guy named Steve wins.
Probably war? The Tau are jerks. If you don't 'join' them they try to poach your stuff, and the Tau wouldn't join another union.... I mean, you won't get like the UNSC/Covenant hatred, as that was very personal, I imagine it'd be more cordial.
I meant the zerg you dick head Lol. Haha.
I only ask because I think current protoss would actually join the Covenant as Artanis is the leadership, I think pre-great war protoss would be just as bad as the Tau in that aspect. However, I thought the Tau were great diplomats? Maybe they could convince truth otherwise? I mean Current Covenant if we can even call them that, would prolly join the Tau out of the fact that they have even allied themselves with human factions so...
I also noticed a few things. I'm going to break down your post if you don't mind.
So Covenant, with 'help', vs the GAR? Cause the Covenant are going to get back problems after this war with all the carrying they have to do.
Agreed, as IIRC even the protoss empire well in this case the united whatever protoss factions are good, they do indeed lack numbers. However, every protoss warship could hold its own with the minor Republic battleships or even possible use and apply cloaked fleets to ambush republic forces. This should be a big point in the war. As IIRC protoss have the ability to not only cloak their own warships, but have ships near by to cloak others including Covenant as Tau. If the Covenant is agreed to go on the offensive, then the Tau and Protoss could very well play defense with cloaked fleets and by the time the Republic launches an assault even micro jumps wont really matter if you don't know where you're getting your ass railed at.
This is ofc just a thought.
Chimera/Locust/Terminators really only help with ground war and as manpower... Its nice to have but also not needed. You could remove them and it would change nothing.
I disagree, although I'm no expert on the Chimera, but their ground game seems pretty effective as in the SW galaxy is filled with human like creatures, so shouldnt the virus effect them as well? That's a lot of bodies joining now what was once the tiny Chimera force now numbering in the billions and higher. Granted armies don't matter, but that's man power that can be well spent on producing fleets for the Covenant.
Terminators help with the fact they can apply unique black ops missions along with protoss and Tau in the fact of hacking shit and ofc disguising themselves and prolly pulling off better black op missions than even the Tau in the aspect thanks to their T-1000s. I have a hard time not seeing these boys being dropped in mass as well on shipyards left to kill Clones all damn day. I mean really the Clones can't really put them down and if they do it would be as such a high price its not gonna even be funny. Furthermore unlike everyone here besides protoss, the Terminators don't need to rest, they don't need sleep. Their functions and understanding technology could very well help them refit ships as well as they would be working on the clock 24/7 and their ability to make mistakes would be maybe high at first, but low in the grand scheme of things due to their learning nature, and their ability to redo the same stuff over and over again.
I do agree the Locust as cool as they are unless they can breed rapid, wont really apply much. Maybe they can help with production???
Scrin is a wildcard as we know really nothing about them. The forces you fight in Command and Conqueror is a mining expedition. It isn't even their real military. You are fighting what is, essentially, the Chevron company. So... I'm going to assume its just the mining expeditions, in which case, same as the above three.
Agreed, I have a feeling if we included all the Scrin and we are guessed and allowed to believe they own like multiple galaxies.... I think that would in general be too much, even if their ships are dog shit. The sheer amount of numbers would drown the galaxy. However, I got nothing on this, they bring some cool tech, maybe like the Chimera, they can drop sub space fleets onto planets and begin infecting shit as quick as possible???? Boosting manpower and so on???
The Protoss and the Tau are in the same boat, while their ships have the firepower to contribute greatly and they both have solid tech, they lack the numbers and industrial might to really contribute in the grand scheme. But, their assistance is still valuable.. kind of. Tau FTL is pretty garbage. [Refitting a bunch of ships isn't easy to do, so.. you wouldn't see Tau ships with Slipspace or any other FTL for a long time into the war] meaning the Tau fleet assets will likely be left to defend key worlds within Hutt Space.
I knind of alreayd justified this.
In theory, I think the GAR should win via superior industrial ability, only one that can build nearly as fast is the Covenant but that would require a level of mobilization we never really saw from the GAR or, at least, a real application of it. Ground battles don't matter all that much, they look cool. Games focus on them, but space is what matters. Covenant has the ability to compete with the GAR, in that aspect, I'd say. Now... as I said, I think in theory, GAR has the tools it needs to win, it would require some reforms [making more of their military force enlisted men and leaving more specialized roles to the Clones, for instance] as well as really mobilizing and switching to a war economy, but will they do it? Hard to say.
I don't think so, because even when the GAR was coming close and was on the climax of the war, they really didn't draft too many people that I can recall, maybe I'm wrong, but the Republic has a poor means of producing stuff and lets so to speak companies do it for them which although are good, they aren't that good. Plus just because you can produce ships don't mean you can produce pilots, and various other crew members to run those ships. Covenant would lack in this, which is why people like skynet and chimera matter as the terminators can begin mass production I'm sure, and the Chimera swarming planets creating new forces don't need the training as it is already ingrained into them once they actually learn it due to their hive mind mentality, or maybe I'm wrong?
Log in to comment