Avatar image for shanana
#1 Posted by Shanana (59071 posts) - - Show Bio
caption
caption
caption
caption
Avatar image for the_martian
#2 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto seems to have more raw power than Sylar. I'm going with Mags.

Avatar image for fibra
#3 Posted by Fibra (735 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto

Avatar image for john_valentine
#4 Posted by John Valentine (16467 posts) - - Show Bio

Sylar's usefull abilities:

  • Sound Manipulation.
  • TK.
  • Cryokinesis.
  • Induced Radioactivity.
  • Alchemy.
  • Rapid Cellular Regeneration.



I'm going with Sylar.

Avatar image for the_martian
#5 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio
John Valentine said:
"Sylar's usefull abilities:

  • Sound Manipulation.
  • TK.
  • Cryokinesis.
  • Induced Radioactivity.
  • Alchemy.
  • Rapid Cellular Regeneration.



I'm going with Sylar.

"
I forgot about the Radiation power, I might change my vote.
Avatar image for john_valentine
#6 Posted by John Valentine (16467 posts) - - Show Bio

He can kill 200,000 people in one swipe and recover. Yes, Sylar has my vote.

Avatar image for agony
#7 Posted by Agony (5836 posts) - - Show Bio

sylar

Avatar image for tevnoba
#8 Posted by Tevnoba (3451 posts) - - Show Bio

Sylar gains mags abilities . . . mags looses his scalp.

Avatar image for king_saturn
#9 Posted by King Saturn (220943 posts) - - Show Bio
Sylar should win here...
Avatar image for darkhonest
#10 Posted by Darkhonest (272 posts) - - Show Bio

I feal like sylar is going to win here. i mean once he blows of his helmet its a curbstomp, but i think that i could be a good battle

Avatar image for last_guardian
#11 Posted by Last_Guardian (32162 posts) - - Show Bio

I think Mags wins here..he's taken on entire teams of superheroes before...he can shield himself from whatever Sylar throws, including those tricky explosions...

Avatar image for super_buster
#12 Posted by Super-Buster (2567 posts) - - Show Bio

I think Mags will kill Sylar at first, he's just too powerful. But with Sylar's new regeneration power it won't keep him down for long unless Erik does something like stick some metal in Sylar's head and leave it there (Sylar won't be able to regenerate unless the metal is taken out so he can heal). But if Magneto kills him a way that Sylar can come back to life then Sylar would sneak up on Erik while his back is turned and turn him to water or something. I'm not a comic writer but that wasn't too hard to come up with and it sounds plausible unless Mags never lowers his shield. Otherwise Mags.

Avatar image for bart_simpson
#13 Posted by Bart Simpson (618 posts) - - Show Bio

Those amateur heroes and villains on that series get beaten too easily and can't fight worth a damn. Magneto shows Sylar how tough a true villain is suppose to be.

Avatar image for maya_liafador
#14 Posted by Maya_Liafador (5823 posts) - - Show Bio

why are you basing it off the series when sylar is a badass in the comic

Avatar image for bart_simpson
#15 Posted by Bart Simpson (618 posts) - - Show Bio
Maya Lopez said:
"why are you basing it off the series when sylar is a badass in the comic"

Because that's the main source for Heroes. Plus I don't follow the comics. Saw some of them, mainly from season one. I'm not too big of a fan like I use to because I felt alot of the things in that series were letdowns. But why don't you tell me what Sylar did in the comics that puts him so much above his TV counterpart? From the comics I did saw him in the only thing more "badass" is the way they draw him.
Avatar image for maya_liafador
#16 Posted by Maya_Liafador (5823 posts) - - Show Bio

One thing the comic sylar does is focus on him justifying his reasons for killing, he also uses his power more whereas, the tv sylar uses a few every show, i agree with you i think mags would win here but i mean basing a fight between a comic character and the way a character is written on a show isnt a competition.

Avatar image for the_man_of_yesteryear
#17 Posted by The Man of Yesteryear (5592 posts) - - Show Bio

Mags

Avatar image for cly
#18 Posted by cly (15017 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto. He seems to have more power potential and more intellect.

Avatar image for jean_luc_lebeau
#19 Posted by Jean_Luc_LeBeau (82985 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto

Avatar image for john_valentine
#20 Posted by John Valentine (16467 posts) - - Show Bio

When has Magneto withstood a nuclear explosion?

Avatar image for acer
#21 Posted by Acer (14477 posts) - - Show Bio
John Valentine said:
"When has Magneto withstood a nuclear explosion?"
How often does Sylar use his radiation and to that level?
Avatar image for jean_luc_lebeau
#22 Posted by Jean_Luc_LeBeau (82985 posts) - - Show Bio
John Valentine said:
"When has Magneto withstood a nuclear explosion?"
Genoshia
Avatar image for jean_luc_lebeau
#23 Posted by Jean_Luc_LeBeau (82985 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto was hit with TWO Nukes. And still got up (looking for the scans)

Avatar image for zora_arrow
#24 Posted by Zora Arrow (1231 posts) - - Show Bio

Bump :P

Avatar image for jean_luc_lebeau
#25 Posted by Jean_Luc_LeBeau (82985 posts) - - Show Bio

Thanks Zora

John Valentine said:

"When has Magneto withstood a nuclear explosion?"
caption
caption

Avatar image for bart_simpson
#26 Edited by Bart Simpson (618 posts) - - Show Bio
Maya Lopez said:
"One thing the comic sylar does is focus on him justifying his reasons for killing, he also uses his power more whereas, the tv sylar uses a few every show, i agree with you i think mags would win here but i mean basing a fight between a comic character and the way a character is written on a show isnt a competition."

Well both the comics and the TV series were written by the same people right? So I don't see why we can't reference the series. But I don't get what you mean when you say basing a fight between a comic character and the way a characters is written on a show isn't a competition.
Avatar image for jean_luc_lebeau
#27 Posted by Jean_Luc_LeBeau (82985 posts) - - Show Bio
caption
caption
Avatar image for cly
#28 Posted by cly (15017 posts) - - Show Bio
Gambler said:
"
caption
caption
"
DUDE.
Avatar image for maya_liafador
#29 Posted by Maya_Liafador (5823 posts) - - Show Bio

Not nessacarly the comic is made for reading, the show was made for watching therefore some aspects of the comic wont appear on the Tv because of "interest of the veiwers" 

hmmmmmmmmm how can i explain this

in a comic the writer had more freedom to do what he or she pleases, on tv the director must go through with the producer and take out things that wont fly on tv, comics can be written and then get a rating.
Tv shows have to be the same rating week after week, unless specified otherwise. Which means the characters in Tv are weaker then there comic counterparts
Avatar image for bart_simpson
#30 Posted by Bart Simpson (618 posts) - - Show Bio
Maya Lopez said:
"Not nessacarly the comic is made for reading, the show was made for watching therefore some aspects of the comic wont appear on the Tv because of "interest of the veiwers" 
hmmmmmmmmm how can i explain this

in a comic the writer had more freedom to do what he or she pleases, on tv the director must go through with the producer and take out things that wont fly on tv, comics can be written and then get a rating.
Tv shows have to be the same rating week after week, unless specified otherwise. Which means the characters in Tv are weaker then there comic counterparts
"

Okay I kind of get what you're saying. Comics have more freedom, hence why the characters can generally do more. Though it's not always the case. For example X-men the animated series have their characters dead on to their comic counterparts. Though Human-Juggernaut will argue about his controversial loss to Gladatior. Then there's Dragon Ball Z, a manga oriented franchise that took off once the TV show was made where the characters are doing more outrageous things than there comic counterparts. There's also Star Wars Clone Wars (the original, not the new CGI version) where some fans have argued about the over the top powers being displayed. Then there's my series the Simpsons. Where the show has has featured some seriously powerful characters and items. The video games has some, though not as powerful. The comic books have little to none. But these are all cartoon shows, so the standards are probably different.
Avatar image for shanana
#31 Posted by Shanana (59071 posts) - - Show Bio

Yuppers^^

Avatar image for nerx
#32 Posted by Nerx (15351 posts) - - Show Bio

Mags FTW, Sylar will be pin-cushioned with pipes then hurled to the sun

Avatar image for john_valentine
#33 Edited by John Valentine (16467 posts) - - Show Bio
Nerx said:
"Mags FTW, Sylar will be pin-cushioned with pipes then hurled to the sun"

No.

Sylar's an empath.

If he gets Magneto's power, he understands how to use it due to his intuitive aptitude.
Avatar image for the_scourge
#34 Posted by The_Scourge (5335 posts) - - Show Bio

sylar would win. if only he and everyone else on heroes still had their powers

Avatar image for king_saturn
#35 Posted by King Saturn (220943 posts) - - Show Bio
Respect 2009 Mr. Spock  !
Avatar image for zoom
#36 Posted by Zoom (14751 posts) - - Show Bio

Mags.

Avatar image for iceprince_x
#37 Posted by IcePrince_X (5092 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto for the win. Sylar may end up in a thousand pieces.

Magneto's shield can protect him from radiation blast

Avatar image for telekineticsun
#38 Posted by TelekineticSun (359 posts) - - Show Bio

magneto would destroy sylar...( i like heroes) but magneto would kill everyone in that universe...

magneto would be angry that sylar selflishly kills others with powers with no leginamate reason and would be disgusted in how powerful sylar thinks himself to be... magneto would crush and impale him with metal a hundred times over and then launch him into orbit towards the sun ( let me see him heal, i dare him to)

Avatar image for mortein
#39 Posted by Mortein (5553 posts) - - Show Bio

this would be a close fight, I give 6/10 for Sylar

Avatar image for magnus_murdock
#40 Posted by Magnus/Murdock (509 posts) - - Show Bio

Sylaw won't last 10 minutes

Avatar image for warlock2792
#41 Posted by WARLOCK2792 (18072 posts) - - Show Bio
John Valentine said:
"Nerx said:
"Mags FTW, Sylar will be pin-cushioned with pipes then hurled to the sun"
No.Sylar's an empath. If he gets Magneto's power, he understands how to use it due to his intuitive aptitude."
So he'll know precisely how Magneto is going to tear him apart?  Quite frankly, I don't see how Sylar will win this.  He has yet to absorb someone with powers that match Magneto, and the fact that he is an empath doesn't mean much when Magneto has a helmet and experience to boot.
Avatar image for mira
#42 Posted by mira (1545 posts) - - Show Bio

Maybe Sylar.

Avatar image for korg
#43 Posted by Korg (11351 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto with ridiculous ease.

Avatar image for andferne
#44 Posted by Andferne (38281 posts) - - Show Bio

Going to back up Mags in this. Although Sylar is a bad dude, Mags is just one potent person when it comes to his power.

Avatar image for spekqj
#45 Posted by spekqj (610 posts) - - Show Bio

Megneto for the win.

Avatar image for triumphant
#46 Posted by Triumphant (2578 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto ftw

Avatar image for psi_fire
#47 Posted by Psi-Fire (974 posts) - - Show Bio

Mags ftw

Avatar image for erik
#48 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto will win this. There is not really anything in Sylar's bag of tricks that he can win with. Assuming this is Sylar at his best. 

Avatar image for yaujtapool
#49 Posted by Yaujtapool (7929 posts) - - Show Bio

Sylar is more versitile but mags has got way more raw power .
Mags FTW

Avatar image for korg
#50 Posted by Korg (11351 posts) - - Show Bio

Bump.