Spider-man Trio (NWH) vs Sinister Six (Insomniac Games)

Some callouts:

Fox Amazing Spider-Man

MCU

Spider-Man PS4

Interesting Battle, I think the NWH trio would take a majority of the fights taking the prep time and Iron Spider into account.

Spider Trio high diff

The NWH Trio take the victory with moderate difficulty.

Six

Trio high diff.

Insomniac Electro > TASM Electro

Scorption's poison is a one shot

Rhino is a tank that no sells large building explosions and rams through skyscrapers like paper, they cannot damage him

Mr. Negative has ranged attacks and can corrupt them with a touch

Docks seem about equal with maybe Insomniac having slight edge in AP

Vulture is fodder

@gaoron said:

Do you think they could resist Mister Negatives corruption, and would Scorpion's poison get through the Iron Spider?

Rhino would definitely a problem since they were physically being overpowered by The Lizard.

@gaoron:

Insomniac Electro > TASM Electro

TASM Electro was more impressive.

I'm curious, do people think Insomniac Scorpion is about as strong as NWH Lizard?

Rhino would body all of them in strength, Mr Negative’s TP takes over all of them(could have them kill themselves or just become a servant of him), none of them have resistance to poison. I could see them potentially taking vulture or electro though but not with the rest of the six here(in electro’s case)

Mr Negative can also create a large army of fodder to make this worse for the trio

They definitely have nothing to say they can overcome Mr Negative’s corruption but the iron spider would be more than enough to stop Peter from getting pierced and poisoned by scorpion

Rhino and Scorpion have terrible teamwork and their attacks could easily be dodged and used against the rest of the team. Which is something that can be done in missions and Rhino bullrushing things to his detriment is implemented into missions consistently.

Scorpion‘s tail isn’t going to be a factor when Doc Ock’s longer, more coordinated prosthetics arms can be deflected and struggle to get ahold of Tobey/Tom Spider-Mans, even Garfield managed to rip of Lizard’s tail. The tail wouldn’t even penetrate Iron Spider and the poison projectiles are telegraphed and easy to dodge.

Mister Negative isn’t going to get ahold of any Spider-Man, the field is too open for any of them to engage him hand to hand, he gets webbed up

Electro has been beaten by web incap so I don’t see any reason it can’t be done again

Tobey has beaten New Goblin mid difficulty after getting ambushed who’s a better version of Toomes in everything

Doc Ock doesn’t offer anything much to his team.

The Sinister Six have poor coordination, the Peters already have a system to take out villains and have an additional hour to coordinate. It won’t be easy but they’re not losing.

I think Tobey does, if you count the games.

Other than that, I agree. Life-action Spider-Men struggled to beat their version of Sinister Six (or rather Four, since Octavius was a double agent, and Osborne appeared after they had already been beaten), even while having one-shot weapons for some of them. Insomniac SS does actually have decent teamwork when operating under Octavius' supervision (when they beat Pete during the prison riot).

@thewatcherking said:

Initially I was hesitant of adding him in, but this is a thematic battle and he was part of the original Sinister Six in the game. Also, a giant Demon Li boss battle with multiple Spider-men would look super amazing. The main question is though, can they take down the other villains in time to team-up against Demon Li...?!

Doc Ock is definitely the brains of the bunch (although he is pretty decent in CQC - quickly shredding Insomniac Spider-man without his armoured suit), so shouldn't be underestimated here.

He is basically taking Tom Holland's lead in the NWH final battle, making sure his team/Sinister Six is fighting as efficiently as possible...

@adamanouer: You brought some insightful points in the sister/mirror thread to this one here:

Spider-man Duo (Insomniac Games) vs Sinister Six (NWH & MCU)

Care to share your thoughts on this match up?

Speed-wise I think they all should be in the same level.

IRC Mr Negative had some kind of mind manipulation. He needs to touch his opponent to use it, but if he does, it's endgame for any of them(I don't recall them showing any kind of TP resistance).

Insomniac Elektro and TASM Elektro seems at similar levels(though the arc reactor probably gives TASM version the edge).

Rhino and Lizard should be pretty similar, Lizard may be even superior(He is not a dummy).

Scorpion has an one-shot weapon, but Iron Spider could counter that.

Spider-Man needed a special suit in order to defeat Otto, before that he stomped Peter, so considering Insomniac Spider-Man is at a similar level to any of the NWH Spideys I'd say he is > Raimi Otto.

I will be given the fight to the Sinister Six mainly because:

1.-Elektro was soloing the trio before Otto arrived.

2.-They only fought Lizard, Sandman and Elektro at a time. Otto and Lizard arrived later. Here they have to face the whole Six.

The Sinister Six probably wins due to Mr Negative and Rhino.

Bump.

@baldur_odinson said:

The NWH Trio take the victory with moderate difficulty.

Cool picture.

@officer_batman: Much appreciated.

Bump.

@waking_dreamer: Sorry for responding 3 month's late to this bud I forgot my account details but the long story short is I think it would result in a similar fight to what happened in the movie and the games. It's the domino effect I think they'd bait them into attacking each other. Rhino, Scorpion and Vulture basically beat each other and you could quite easily bait Electro into taking them out as well. The leaves the 3 biggest threats Ock, Li and Electro.

When it comes to Electro himself it's a case of luring him away from any power sources and unlike MCU electro webbing does subdue him pretty well it's simply a case of doing it long enough to knock him out. When it came to the games beating Li was mostly a matter of having him unleash all his attacks consecutively before tiring him out and knocking him out, which can work but if any of the other Peter's get influenced by his touch the fight becomes much harder. As for Ock you'd need to disable his chip and unlike the movies it's unlikely this Ock would be kind enough to help them with that so we resort to the bait and switch have 2 peters distract the 3rd destroys the chip.

Majority win for Spider-Man.

The six. I think insomniac spider-man is well above any of the MCU trio and the six almost killed him.