Spider-Man (MCU) vs Spider-Man (TASM)

In character Win by death/KO/incap

No Iron Spider, just standard gear.

NWH seemed to imply that all three Spidermen are pretty equal, but I'd back MCU Peter due to having fought more impressive enemies like Raimi Goblin & Thanos.

MCU Spidey

They're pretty much equals. It's hard to say.

@settled: they are pretty close. although i’d argue that TASM would struggle to put MCU Pete down. And MCU Pete also has a more advanced Spider Sense and experience fighting super powered enemies. So i’d say he probably takes a majority. Don’t know if you’d agree?

Either way I think

inb4 "Garfield statues"

MCU

The one without shitty Iron Man influence

Garfield blitz

MCU Spidey

Garfield kicks him off the table

Andrew

TASM 1000%. Tanking Electro's full power-grid attack then his full arc reactor revenge attack puts TASM Spidey in looney toons ville of durability. He's the fastest and most agile by far and a better fighter imo. He uses his webs expertly along with his various moves like in the games while MCU Spider-Man often relies on his special webs to do any kind of special moves.

Something crazy as well, we never actually see Garfield seriously struggle in a fight other than the week he got his powers against Lizard. Against Electro, brute force wouldn't win so he had to use his brains to win but he really didn't struggle in that fight, or in his fight with meth Goblin.

MCU Spider-Man is agile and fast as well but TASM Spider-Man is pure silk in his movements.

Also Lizard is significantly more dangerous than Green Goblin, legitimately outscales him in every single way. In fact, Lizard scales stupid high so the fact that Garfield not only didn't die, but gave him a good fight places Garfield very high in terms of skill.

@rajjarsalt: statues don't fight back though

Good point, you'd need to be in a Dr Strange crossover for that to happen

@thequatum: didn't Garfield have an insulated suit or something for the Electro stuff?

@rajjarsalt: Nyet. He and Gwen only magnetized his webshooters so they didn't overload with electricity. I think it was magnetization, whatever it was, it was only the webshooters. They hooked up a car battery to each shooter then tested them to make sure they wouldn't overload, his suit was still just as unsafe as before lol.

https://youtu.be/iVlwYasHOBY

Yep, magnetized only the webshooters.

Probably MCU Spidey , due to his strength and dura feats..but they seem equal..

MCU Spidey seems more experience in fighting tougher foes.

@reaperace: yeah i don’t know about you but i think he should take it on this. Plus better spider sense and striking feats should be enough to do it

The Spiders are intended to be pretty much equals I think.

Holland has better feats tho, and way more movies to draw from.. plus when they were talking about the craziest villains they had fought Garfeild mentioned the rhino and said he was lame..while Holland mentioned Thanos... Holland has also been a avenger while the others apparently hadn’t.

Like I said I think they all scale anyways.. but Holland carries the best feats imo.

Here is a MCU Spider-Man RT I’m working on.

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/death4bunnies-mcu-spider-man-rt-and-feat-breakdown-2247545/

@death4bunnies: thanks for sharing, i’ll check it out. I think MCU Peter probably takes it. As you say, they all scale well to each other. But MCU seems to have the edge in feats and experience with powered foes, as well as the superior spider sense. Should be enough to give him the edge imo. What do you think?

MCU Peter should take based off of NWH. Physically they're all pretty equal, but the MCU Peter has fought Thanos and the like. He's just a tad bit more impressive to me.