@cregan_stark It was mentioned The Order of the Phoenix by Madame Pomfrey when she was treating McGonagal after she had been Stunned by four Aurors. McGonagal was taken by surprise and it was dark so she didn't see them coming, the actual quote is "As if one of them could have Stunned Minerva McGonagall face-on by daylight!".
Now you could argue that all that means is that McGonagal could beat any one of the Aurors but I think it means that she could beat all of them.
Creating your own spells is impressive: I would consider it superior to McGonagal's Transfiguration essays being published while she was in school and slightly superior to James Potter and Sirius Black becoming Animagi. It doesn't mean he is a superior fighter, just that he knew more about the Dark Arts and was skilled at magic.
He has never shown light magic on par with his dark magic and had never shown anything greater than slightly superior to professor-level magic, other than perhaps flight and that is one spell.
He was better at treating Dark injuries than Madame Pomfrey, assuming he is better at general healing is baseless. In fact when he healed Draco he was healing Sectumsempra, his own spell, for all we know he might be incapable of healing a different Dark spell taht deals similar damage.
Just because he knew one power only Voldemort had does not mean the rest of his abilities and knowledge were on par with Voldemort's, while it is possible he knows other powerful spells it has not been confirmed. Personally I doubt Voldemort thought Snape anything that wasn't slightly superior to what he thought Bellatrix other than flight.
He was powerful at Occlumency, which would be relevant is McGonagal was a Legitimens. Even then it is not a combat based power, and is only a feat of professor level skill and more importantly immense emotional fortitude, and does not mean he is better at magic than McGonagal.
There fight wasn't conclusive, we have no idea to what degree Snape was challenged, although it is likely he was struggling to hold her at bay without killing, but I also believe McGonagal was struggling to break his defenses.
While I would probably say that Snape Dark Arts > McGonagal's Transfiguration we saw her use it very effectively in combat and she was prodigious enough to teach it, earn recognition at an early age and become and Animagus (although to be fair even Rita Skeeter could do that).
Look, I don't want to go round and round either, although that is not to say I'm not enjoying the discussion. I just think Snape isn't exponentially superior or outside McGonagal's weight class and that we can't know for certain that Snape is definitely superior, only that he likely is.
Do you want to continue via PM? This is somewhat off-top.
Log in to comment