Scott Shelby (Heavy Rain) Vs Mike Ehrmantraut (Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul), (READ OP)

Ex-cops turned criminals

Scott Shelby

Mike Ehrmantraut

History:

Scott has moved to Albuquerque, New Mexico and is continuing his work as the Origami Killer in there, Scott has kidnapped Mike's granddaughter, he obviously isn't pleased.

Rules:

• In character,
• Basic knowledge,
• Random encounter,
• Both are given feats from their respective media,
• Both are at their peak,
• Winner by any means necessary.

Rounds:

1. Mike must face the trials set by Scott, does he succeed?
2. Melee fight,
3. Shootout, pistols for each.

Info:

• https://heavyrain.fandom.com/wiki/Scott_Shelby,
• https://breakingbad.fandom.com/wiki/Mike_Ehrmantraut.

Location: Tommy Miller's dam (TLOU)

• Scott starts at the top, Mike at the bottom in R3.

Who wins and why?

@allstarsuperman you seem to like BB/BCS so you might want to comment.

@pawlnewman01: I haven’t played Heavy Rain, but I want to some day, so I don’t really want to see Shelbys feats. I’ll get back to this eventually.

From 00:00 to 01:50, he kill 18 bodyguards in a shootout

From 4:30 to 4:45, he knocks out a thief with one punch.

in durability, he is superior to Norman jayden who is not knocked out despite taking a giant sledgehammer blow to the head. In 2:05 to 2:15.

In 2:50 to 3:30, show some of his fighting skill

Bump

Bump

@pawlnewman01: I know this is an old post but i thought i'll give my opinion:

Round 1: i think some of the trials will seriously mess Mike up and in his age the body might not take it well but he is tough and he shown he can take punishment so i think he will push through he definetly has the mental capacity to kill and sacrifice himself for his granddaughter

Round 2: This is a tough one, on one hand Scott has more impressive showings like beating up 2 bodyguards and fighting Jayden and Mike gets overwhelmed by a bunch of armed punks. However i believe Mike is actually more skilled, he easily breaks the kids arm and one punches Steven Oggs character in the throat who seemed physically similar to Troy the guy Scott fights in his first chapter and he is struggling a bit during the fight even though he wins. Scott is probably stronger and more durable but Mike is faster and more skilles so Mike 6/10

Round 3: Shelby turns into killing machine after Kramer tries to kill Lauren and him and while Mike is impressive with a gun he is not on that level. Mike can win if he sneaks around and somehow shoots Scott from behind or through a wall like he does in the show, it could work but Shelby is smarter than average thugs Mike with deals and might see it coming so for me it's shelby 7/10.