Rorschach vs. Aiden Pearce

Rorschach is armed with his grappling hook, improvised flamethrower and a baseball bat.

Aiden gets a suppressed Colt 1911, his steel police baton and his phone for hacking.

Round 1 - Comic Rorschach

Round 2 - Movie Rorschach

Battle takes place in 1990's New York, so there isn't too many devices to hack.

Win by death or total incapitation

.

Aiden wins both.

Rorschach has better H2H feats. Aiden's biggest feat is overpowering two police officers (with guns) at the same time without a gun.

If this is 1990, then Aiden's phone is useless.

Rorschach wins. If it was modern-day New York, then Aiden wins.

Aiden wins both easily.