Revan vs Vader

Vader gets one shotted lmao.

@arkhamasylum3: How does it feel now? Probably what I’m feeling. Disgust.

@i_like_swords: ??? He was never pressed by anything except vitiate in his prime. It is quite clear in TOR. He killed multiple temple guard like they were fodder before moving onto vitiate. Nyriss got dusted, a clear high tier as her lightning is powerful enough to turn people to ash. So nyriss>Dooku in force showings. And she was stronger than scourge as stated by himself. Not that big of a deal just solidifies her as a high tier as scourge himself is high mid. Revan had no issues until the vitiate fight and only got captured because of the literal force void of Nathema. Force voids weaken force users. Huh who knew? Vader can beat sith revan. Not reborn or SOR. Revan just has far superior showings in like literally everything. Unfortunate for Vader who has been getting newer and better feats in canon but still. Not good enough.

Bump

Vader solo him

If composite: then Revan.

Canon: Vader against a feat-less Revan.

Legends: Good Fight, but Still Revan.

SoR Revan takes it in a very close fight. EoO Revan stomps

what dyu mean if composite?

Revan wins

He is better in pretty much everything+better stats

Good job. Another member to join the Revan > Vader clan

@darthor: I also think Revan is the better Character.

Revans Story is better as Anakins/Vaders.Vader is just more iconic,thats pretty obv

yep i agree REVEN FOR LIFE!!!!

Yes. The Order of Revan shall rise again.

Vader stomp him ease

Hard disagree.

You think SoR Revan can beat KFV?

I don't see why not. Considering the fact that KFV's scaling don't apply to Revan, and Revan has way better feats

Why does Prime Vader even take SoR Revan not to mention EoO. Dyu want a CaV on Revan vs Vader?

why? Revan's story is very cool. SWTOR did him no justice in terms of stories tho

I was curious on Uhu's reasoning, as he holds KFV as prime.

@darthor:

why? Revan's story is very cool. SWTOR did him no justice in terms of stories tho

Because Anakin's story is arguably top 5 in all of SW. At the heart of the 6 films from TPM through to ROTJ, is the story of Anakin Skywalker - tragic, compelling and riveting.

TCW adds to the emotional punch and his redemption in ROTJ is immensely satisfying and perhaps the best moment in SW history.

Revan is cool but I don't think his story/arc measures up to Vader's. It's an extremely high bar which most characters fall short of IMO.

I have SoR Revan slightly above or on par with SK. They are IMO around the same level

EoO Revan is IMO Caedus level

I see. But what are your reasons for Vader > Revan?

For SoR Revan I am using his feats more or less. Combined his feats with his scaling over characters such as weakened Valk who can bust temples who got ragdolled by a hindered HoT who is below the version that fought Revan who got ragdolled by Revan

For EoO, he is twice SoR Revan. Thats why I have him at Caedus's level

Ragdolling the Outlander while facing 7 strong opponents

Manipulating 40 meteors while massively hindered from 300 years of mental torture from 7 of the most powerful beings in the universe

Scales massively above city-level, which should easily be above your StarDestroyer feat

etc.

@eredin12 said:

@darthor:

Ragdolling the Outlander while facing 7 strong opponents

Manipulating 40 meteors while massively hindered from 300 years of mental torture from 7 of the most powerful beings in the universe

And where do you hold Outlander at ?

Scales massively above city-level, which should easily be above your StarDestroyer feat

Star Destroyers can tank planet and overpower planet busting force of black hole, city level is completely inconsequential in comparison

1. Outlander >>> Base HoT >>> Hindered HoT who just fought through an army >>>>>> Valk who can bust temples

2. That is correct. But then you have to consider how far above does Revan scale

Revan >>>>>>>>>> SoR EW II >>> Act III EW II > Darth Baras >>> Lord Fulminisis who destroyed a city

It's honestly quite iron-clapsed. And I'm not aware of anything Vader has placing above this feat. But fair enough lol

This is a true battle, 112 votes and dead even?? Amazing!

@frozen: Its a matter of taste

Anakin was...i hated him for "killing" Mace and he was far to often nothing like a brat

His story is longer,yeah.Dude was a Major player in all 6 movies.But i liked Revans Story in KotoR more.

Still a shame we never got KotoR 3.

And somethings telling the new writter for the remake will fuck up Revan

It's no longer a true battle after EoO. But this thread was created before EoO. But I agree, SoR Revan vs Prime Vader is super close. Even me, somebody who have Revan very high believes that Revan wins only by 8/10.

True. Personally I don't think Revan is boring by any means. But ok...

Vader will solos him

DT (prime) Vader wins in a great fight.

:P

Revan in an absolutely spectacular fight

Revan directly scales above DT Revan:
EoO Revan >>> SoR Revan >> Revan Reborn >>> KOTOR Revan > Malak >>>>> Ajunta Pall > Karness Muur >> His spiritual state >> DT Vader

We established in our last debate that this is completely inaccurate.

we haven't established anything. In fact, I don't think you responded to me. Anyways, regarding your arguments on that thread:
1. Vader is afraid of getting possessed by the amulet

You cannot possess characters out of your tier. Thats why Karness Muur did not use his amulet to directly go possess Palps, or why he didn't do it with all the powerful Ancient Sith. They are most certainly comparable, and given how Revan is vastly superior to Muur, it's quite clear that Revan > DT Vader

2. Muur was just able to fill in the gap between Vader and Palps

If so, there are no reasons why Muur will be the new master