• 61 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for the_human_juggernaut
#1 Posted by the human Juggernaut (7276 posts) - - Show Bio

vs

Avatar image for the_devil_tiger
#2 Posted by The Devil Tiger (1278 posts) - - Show Bio

Ouch ! What the hell of a Fight ! I think... the punisher, coz Castle is a psycho with no remorse, and the comedian is just an asshole without remorse. The psycho wins, because he is waaaaaaaay too far in is madness.

The comedian can be broken by a situation moraly ambiguous, just re-read the watchman, on the other hand, Frank Castle, in the end of the world, faced with the only survivor of the world being a bunch of asshole politician, just passby and kill everybody without a thought for the destiny of mankind. That crazyness just do the difference.

Avatar image for the_human_juggernaut
#3 Posted by the human Juggernaut (7276 posts) - - Show Bio

yea, it should be a great fight. i wish more people would post their opinions.

Avatar image for speedlgt
#4 Posted by speedlgt (2138 posts) - - Show Bio
The Devil Tiger said:
"

Ouch ! What the hell of a Fight ! I think... the punisher, coz Castle is a psycho with no remorse, and the comedian is just an asshole without remorse. The psycho wins, because he is waaaaaaaay too far in is madness.

The comedian can be broken by a situation moraly ambiguous, just re-read the watchman, on the other hand, Frank Castle, in the end of the world, faced with the only survivor of the world being a bunch of asshole politician, just passby and kill everybody without a thought for the destiny of mankind. That crazyness just do the difference.

"

wow I didnt think about that way I was really gonna pull the triger on comedian as being just way more badass But I guess in the regard you stated I would go with punisher as well.
Avatar image for detective
#5 Edited by Detective (582 posts) - - Show Bio

in a fist fight ill take The Comedian in a close one, if they are armed with guns im going with The Punisher

Avatar image for vance_astro
#6 Posted by vance_astro (90012 posts) - - Show Bio

The Punisher.OVERKILL.

Moderator
Avatar image for erik
#7 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio
What equipment does each one have?
Avatar image for the_martian
#8 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio
Vance Astro said:
"The Punisher.OVERKILL."

Avatar image for oldmagic
#9 Posted by oldmagic (5265 posts) - - Show Bio

lol you have to ask? WHen Punisher goes, he's a walking armory.

Avatar image for erik
#10 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio
oldmagic said:
"lol you have to ask? WHen Punisher goes, he's a walking armory.
"
I have seen him with nothing but a pistol on more than one occasion. I just wanted to know if he has his standard mess of crap or if he is running around with nothing more than a combat knife. 
Avatar image for the_martian
#11 Posted by The_Martian (37399 posts) - - Show Bio
erik said:
"oldmagic said:
"lol you have to ask? WHen Punisher goes, he's a walking armory.
"
I have seen him with nothing but a pistol on more than one occasion. I just wanted to know if he has his standard mess of crap or if he is running around with nothing more than a combat knife. 
"
Well if this is current Punisher he has some high tech stuff, including Hawkeye bow and arrows, skrull weapons, etc.
Avatar image for erik
#12 Posted by Erik (32504 posts) - - Show Bio

Hmmmm.... With equipment like that, I do not see how Comedian would last very long. 

Avatar image for mr__punisher
#13 Posted by Mr. Punisher (188 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher hands down

Avatar image for lunacyde
#14 Posted by Lunacyde (25640 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher is in another league.....

Moderator
Avatar image for nighthunter
#15 Posted by Nighthunter (29571 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher

Avatar image for ogreman
#16 Posted by OgreMan (366 posts) - - Show Bio

Frank Castle

Avatar image for korg
#17 Posted by Korg (11351 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher has future tech from beyond 1985, which gives him a bit of an advantage.

Avatar image for kentaxx
#18 Posted by Kentaxx (2405 posts) - - Show Bio

lol

Avatar image for kaino12
#19 Posted by kaino12 (3154 posts) - - Show Bio

punisher but it would be interesting.

Avatar image for secret_turchin_man
#20 Posted by Secret Turchin Man (1789 posts) - - Show Bio

Frank Castle.

Avatar image for radiante
#21 Posted by Radiante (326 posts) - - Show Bio

They are my favorites!!!!!
Two SO DIFFERENT and similar at the same time carachters. 
Sociopath both, but Castle is morally similar to Rorschach. 
Punisher would win, for sure. 
He is stronger, morally, psicologically, phisically, and better with weapons. No contest. 
No way for Blake.
Avatar image for theguy
#22 Posted by TheGuy (615 posts) - - Show Bio
@Korg: Ah, but have the massive advances in Technology made by Dr. M included advances in firearms?
 
Otherwise, Comedian has nothing on Frank, NOTHING.
Avatar image for the_mjolnir_wielder
#23 Posted by The Mjolnir Wielder (8467 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher would pwn the punk-ass rapist
Avatar image for truepwnge
#24 Posted by TruePwnge (2798 posts) - - Show Bio

The Punisher easy, he survived Nam, survived hell, survived the Italian mob, Kingpin,  the Joker, the Russian , the Yakuza, Mexicans, the Chinese Triads, Jamaicans, the Irish Mob,  corrupt cops and psycho politicians, Civil War, Molly Hayes .
 
The Comedian, he got his butt  throw out an 8-story building and died

Avatar image for phorqe
#25 Posted by Phorqe (2148 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher is too well trained and has been published for 30 years. Comedian was published for 1 year and was dead at the start of the story. Moore never came out with "Lost stories of Comedian" so there isn't much to go with. Castle's kill record must be astronomical. I don't think Comedian killed but one or two.

Avatar image for saiyan_earthling
#26 Posted by saiyan_earthling (5895 posts) - - Show Bio

punisher

Avatar image for batdance
#27 Posted by BatDance (2249 posts) - - Show Bio
@Vance Astro said:
" The Punisher.OVERKILL. "
BANG!
Avatar image for the_human_juggernaut
#28 Posted by the human Juggernaut (7276 posts) - - Show Bio
@Phorqe said:
"Punisher is too well trained and has been published for 30 years. Comedian was published for 1 year and was dead at the start of the story. Moore never came out with "Lost stories of Comedian" so there isn't much to go with. Castle's kill record must be astronomical. I don't think Comedian killed but one or two. "

comedian's killed alot
Avatar image for monsterjackson
#29 Posted by monsterjackson (89 posts) - - Show Bio
@BatDance said:

" @Vance Astro said:

" The Punisher.OVERKILL. "

BANG! "
I don't think so.  Even a drunken and old Comedian did better against Ozymandias than both Rorschach and Nite Owl combined.  
Take away the drunken factor, I think Comedian would have done better, maybe even land some hits on Ozy.  And then if its Comedian in his prime he may even be able to beat Ozymandias. 
 
@TruePwnge said:

" The Punisher easy, he survived Nam, survived hell, survived the Italian mob, Kingpin,  the Joker, the Russian , the Yakuza, Mexicans, the Chinese Triads, Jamaicans, the Irish Mob,  corrupt cops and psycho politicians, Civil War, Molly Hayes . The Comedian, he got his butt  throw out an 8-story building and died "

True, but the Comedian is not to be underestimated.  The Comedian survived World War 2, survived the Vietnam War,  almost brought an end to the New York gangs, survived Persecutions by Uncle Sam, the secret service, the FBI, and much much more.  He has murdered thousands, and he is also the only person to have ever beaten Ozymandias in a h2h fight ( yes I know Ozymandias was young and inexperienced back then).  Think about it this way, if Ozymandias fought Punisher, what would happen?  Ozy would slaughter Punisher no doubt.  
 
Yet even a drunken Comedian way past his prime at the age of 67 wearing a bathrobe managed to put up a fight against a man capable of catching bullets.  I just don't like the way you are putting the Comedian down on this one.
 
 
Avatar image for ferro_vida
#30 Posted by Ferro Vida (34318 posts) - - Show Bio
@monsterjackson said:
"
Yet even a drunken Comedian way past his prime at the age of 67 wearing a bathrobe managed to put up a fight against a man capable of catching bullets.  I just don't like the way you are putting the Comedian down on this one.

That's only in the movie. He wasn't even demonstrated as putting up a fight in the comic, which is the version we are using based on the OP. Even if we are including movies, Punisher has three, and I'm pretty confident that Ray Stevenson would murder him.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#31 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@Ferro Vida:  If Punisher fought Ozy Punisher would bring a large arsenal and blow is f*cking brains out!
Avatar image for ferro_vida
#32 Posted by Ferro Vida (34318 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge: D@mn straight he would. He's a better hand to hand fighter then Comedian too.
Avatar image for andferne
#33 Posted by Andferne (38281 posts) - - Show Bio
@Nobody said:
" Vance Astro said:
"The Punisher.OVERKILL."
"
Avatar image for geraldthesloth
#34 Posted by geraldthesloth (32689 posts) - - Show Bio

Comedian is outclassed in everything, he couldn't hope to beat Frank even on his best day.

Avatar image for crabtree
#35 Posted by crabtree (1704 posts) - - Show Bio

punisher wins

Avatar image for kadeem
#36 Posted by kadeem (3120 posts) - - Show Bio

The Punisher:
A. He has fought villains that have powers, and won.
B. He has a much wider artillery than the Comedian.
C. He actually believes in what he is fighting for.
D. Most likely if they ever met the Punisher would catch the Comedian with his pants down and shoot him down while trying to save a rape victim from him.

Avatar image for comicstooge
#37 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem: In mu opinion Frank dosen't 'save' anybody...he just kills people and if he saves somebody in the proses so be it... I think he leaves the 'saving' thing for the heros...
Avatar image for kadeem
#38 Posted by kadeem (3120 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge said:
" @kadeem: In mu opinion Frank dosen't 'save' anybody...he just kills people and if he saves somebody in the proses so be it... I think he leaves the 'saving' thing for the heros... "
He usually hunts down gang hide outs and things like that, so I don't think you are wrong, but I think if he saw someone being victimized I think he would stop it.
Avatar image for secret_turchin_man
#39 Posted by Secret Turchin Man (1789 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem said:
" The Punisher: A. He has fought villains that have powers, and won. B. He has a much wider artillery than the Comedian. C. He actually believes in what he is fighting for. D. Most likely if they ever met the Punisher would catch the Comedian with his pants down and shoot him down while trying to save a rape victim from him. "
This is a good argument...
Avatar image for comicstooge
#40 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem:  If Frank saw, say a few kids (13 years old) attempting to kill somebody would he kill the kids who are committing the crime?
Avatar image for kadeem
#41 Posted by kadeem (3120 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge said:
" @kadeem:  If Frank saw, say a few kids (13 years old) attempting to kill somebody would he kill the kids who are committing the crime? "
It depends on who's writing his character at the time. Some writers seem to have a more sympathetic view of the character than others.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#42 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem:
 OK but if it was the more gritty MAX Version of Frank? 
Avatar image for kadeem
#43 Posted by kadeem (3120 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge said:
" @kadeem:  OK but if it was the more gritty MAX Version of Frank?  "
oh yeah. They dead.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#44 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio

Jesus Christ wouldn't Frank just beat the shit out of them or something?

Avatar image for kadeem
#45 Posted by kadeem (3120 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge said:
" Jesus Christ wouldn't Frank just beat the shit out of them or something? "
I didn't say I would agree with his actions.  He is a disturbed and broken man after all.  He's just not a straight up evil guy like the Comedian.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#46 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem:
 Agreed...Punisher tortures him for being a disgrace to soldiers and then go kills Ozy... 
Avatar image for kadeem
#47 Posted by kadeem (3120 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge said:
" @kadeem:  Agreed...Punisher tortures him for being a disgrace to soldiers and then go kills Ozy...  "
I would see this as a good opportunity for an unlikely team-up where Pun takes down the Comedian, and the Black Panther takes down Ozymandias.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#48 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem: That would be pretty epic...if it where a comic hell, I'd by it...
Avatar image for galactus_himself
#49 Posted by Galactus-himself (5 posts) - - Show Bio
@kadeem:  LMFAO!!!!!!!!!! I agree 100% especially with the D answer.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#50 Posted by ComicStooge (21920 posts) - - Show Bio
@Galactus-himself:
'D' Answser?