Prince Nuada vs Geralt of Rivia

- Hellboy 2 The Golden army feats for Nuada

- Composite Geralt (books+comics+games)

- standard gear (spear and two elvish swords for Nuada and two witcher swords for Geralt) + everyone in character

- Fight takes place in empty, flat arena, they start at 50 feet distance from eachother

- No PIS or CIS (Nuada lost to Hellboy only because PIS so you know)

vs

some callouts:

@foxerdes: I dont remember dodging bullets but I watched the movie long time ago. There's all (or the most) of his fight scenes. He's very agile and his reflexes are very impressive. Of course Geralt has signs but if Nuada will stab him with his spear (even little, Geralt will die some time after fight because of that advanced spearhead that will penetrate the body all the time - no chance to remove it. Only the angel of death was able to save him from dying)

I'd have to say Geralt, while Nuada was impressive, the Witcher has too many feats.

Close fight but Geralt have the experience with heavier weight opponent. Nuada would still wounded him badly, possibly killing Geralt after his own death due to the spear.

Didn't watch Helboy. Once I watch, I'll share my opinion.

@rogueshadow: @foxerdes: @bachh2: How would You compare Nuada to "normal" witcher like for example Eskel or Letho? Could he won against normal witcher? (Geralt is incredibly boosted in terms of reflexes and strenght)

@xerolot: Difficult to say to be honest, both Nuada and the other Witchers don't get a ton of exposure. I'd say that their signs would ultimately tip it in their favour though.

Nuada would get rekt by Detlaff from B&W expansion. Geralt ftw.

Geralt

Geralt should win in a random encounter 9/10.

He'd probably fight with pure swordsmanship for a while and then surprise him with a sign, giving him the win IMO.

@foxerdes: While I always choose the Iorweth way I always thought that Roche way is the canon way. I heard that somewhere, can't find the info right now (still trying) so this could be (and for 99% is) fake. Dunno I was always sure that it has a canon way (You know 0 info about Iorweth or Saskia/Aedirn in the witcher3 but Roche is in game and he doesn't says anything about betraying him for Iorweth [Or I don't remember such dialog]).

@foxerdes: You were probably thinking of that Nazi Sand guy from the first movie. He had an awesome feat of blocking bullets with his swords and directing them back at the shooters.

Geralt takes this

@foxerdes: Actually even if you follow the Roche "canon" way Letho doesn't need to die. He's alive in "canon" because you can see him in the Witcher 3 trailer at 00:30-00:32 seconds. Look at the witcher on the right side. You don't see the face but you can see Letho's body.

Btw: Lambert, Vesemir and Eskel are awesome in this trailer.

Geralt.

@xerolot: normal witcher wouldn't pose too much of a problem. Famous one on the other hand.

@foxerdes: Fair enough.

Geralt should win this. He has a very versatile arsenal and doesn't toy with his enemies