Post Crisis Superman vs New 52 Superman

• No Knowledge
• Other Than That Standard Gear For Both
• No prep
• Win by Death or KO
• Begin 50 feet apart
• Battle on a deserted earth
• Post Crisis to Pre Flashpoint Superman feats
• New 52 feats

Explain your answer.

Post Crisis cuz of years of more feats

Been done.

This is a tough one. I feel that Post Crisis Supes has greater durability and combat speed but New 52 Supes has greater physical strength and he does not hold back at all like his Pre-52 counterpart did. So it really comes down to who can outlast who. Would it be PC Supes thanks to his greater durability? Or will N52 Supe's tendency to not hold back that much make the durability advantage a moot point? Personally, I think Pre-52 just edges it out. Oh, I forgot to add that PC Supes has greater H2H feats as well. So yeah, I think he wins.

N52

Post-Crisis

Got to give it to Post Crisis, has better destruction feats, where new 52 was destroying mountains.

Post crisis easily

Trolling?

Been done. Post-Crisis still wins.

He's just as strong, uses his speed more effectively in combat, and is a more aggressive fighter so I'm backing him. Post-C Supes has more feats but so what? I could be wrong and I probably am but that's where my head is at right now.

I honestly think New 52 superman should win, he has more or less equal stat to Pre-52, only difference is being stronger in strength, which is enough for New 52 to win

Post Crisis

new 52 IMO

slowly edging towards n52 as time goes on

post crisis

@masterkungfu: Can't wait for that upcoming DB.

Pre-Flashpoint stomps.

Now that we've seen more of New 52, he seems to fight a bit more ruthlessly and holds back less. He's also the version with an actual confirmed, legit strength measurement (lifting planet's weight for 5 days, meaning he could lift much more in short bursts), but lifting strength really doesn't help too much in a fight.

Before I'd say Pre 52 wins easily but now I'm actually leaning towards New 52.

New 52.

Post crisis still seems a bit more impressive, but new 52 is almost there.

...and he's losing powers already.

Post-crisis

N52 in a really close fight speed seems pretty much the same N52 physically is stronger as for endurance post crises might have a slight advantage (though N52 did survive a enormous black hole and got out strength and speed feat) N52 5.5/10 times

Post Crisis is better in everything except lifting strength.

New 52 Supes wrecks him with a couple of blows

Post crisis stomps

??? Even Superman fans are divided. I'm always interested when I see this.

@never_give_up: Im personally not divided at all

I hate the new 52 version

I loved the pre 52 version

Buut new 52 has better feats. Like by a lot. So that's that.

Tough one...1 or 2 more solid feats for New-52 Superman, and he can secure my vote against Pre-52 Superman; however now is a toss-up IMO.

New 52.

New 52, probably.

Actually, I have no clue.

New 52 stomps. Pre-52 Superman struggled immensely to move a moon with the help of dozens of Kryptonians. 52 Superman essentially benched pressed the earth for 5 days without sun light.

Strength: New 52
Durability: PC
Speed: PC
==> PC wins

Pc stomps

People keep saying new 52 is a lot stronger. Yes he is stronger but i think he only has a slight strength advantage. Some of PC supes strength feats, while unquantifiable, could be placed at the same level. In i fight though i would say n52 can edge it out.

Pre-Flashpoint Superman got 1 picosecond and 5 nanosecond feats.So by feats,he would blitz the sh*t out of New-52

this

Post Crisis Supes dismantles him with a combination of his speed and skill advantage. Lifting strength holds little significance in this fight.

PC is I'm not mistaken is superior in striking power.

Post Crisis

I'm pretty sure pre-52 held a black hole in his hand.... so pre-52

Still Post Crisis Superman.

New 52

That has been debunked.... pre 52 still wins imo