Padmé, Leia and Rey spawn in the forest of the planet Takodana, where they get the urge to kill eachother in a gunfight. Their versions are the first version of each trilogy. Who wins and how do you think it will play out?
Padmé Amidala vs Leia Organa vs Rey
Leia is a typical denzel in distress most of the time, and althugh she has some showings with a gun, it's like 3 kills combined and it's nothing impressive. Rey just is not good with a gun at all, her thing is close-combat. Given her limited screen time and a different default weapon choice combined, she is nearly featless here. Padme is by far the best shot, at least if we go by feats, mostly because of her Clone Wars appearances, but the movies as well. She shot a couple dozen droids without any effort onscreen, was participating in all out battles, spy-missins and in skirmishes several times, went through a pretty nasty traps in the droid factory in AotC unscratched and handled herself very well in the arena, picking the lock and taking down the monster who was supposed to kill her on her own. She even survived battle on Geonosis with nothing but a gun, and most jedis who were participating in the battle were killed with only top fighters surviving. All this proves her skill is FAR ahead of the others. If she gets a gun here, she wins, I dare say she stomps.
However, if you give Rey her staff or lightsaber and a way of closing the distance, she will beat both Leia, and even Padme to a pulp without much trouble. Leia also could potentially pull a win, if this was her jedi version. But in this scenario, Padme wins easily.
Padme has a better shot than all of them, so Rey’s fighting skills won’t be troublesome. Leia is certainly tough, but Padme towers over Leia at 5’5’’ with the latter being 4’11’’. This means a longer reach, and more muscle mass. Leia got shot by a blaster in Rotj and she was definitely injured. Padme got scratched by a Nexus who could tear through droids that a blaster could as well. Padme kept fighting with full strength afterwards. If that’s not enough, Padme sent a Nexus flying through the air with some momentum, even though she weighs 99 lbs, meaning she used pure strength. While Leia needed to use a branch to knock out a stormtrooper. Amidala also fell onto the sand from hundreds of feet above and got up immediately afterwards, while already being injured by the Nexus. So, Padme is far more durable, stronger, and has the benefit of being 6 inches taller.
With a blaster, Leia or Padme takes this. Rey doesn't have much experience with a blaster. Physically, Leia doesn't have as many feats as the other two. Rey is probably the best fighter and her stick helps her plenty. But, Padme has shown to have physical superiority in every way. Her skin is stronger than some metal as a Nexu was able to take out droids with a single swipe and it only left marks that didn't even go through the skin. She also can fall from seemingly any height without the slightest discomfort. So would Padme be at risk with Rey and her weapon? Well, Padme’s body is able to endure injuries that are well above Rey and her weapon. Padme wouldn’t be affected much by Rey’s stick and it would be impossible to take her down in a such a manner. However, Padmé’s skin can obviously be penetrated by a lightsaber. Even though a Nexus could only leave superficial marks on her skin, it caused her obvious distress and the marks pierced a few layers of skin. Even Padmé’s powerful body cannot protect her from a lightsaber so she couldn’t rely on her durability. Although Padme has proven to be vastly stronger, faster, more experienced, and durable. Padme could potentially lose if Rey has a lightsaber, however as Rey is no slow poke in comparison. That’s the closet in physicality. Padmé’s amazing endurance would ensure she can outlast Rey in a long fight, but would a long fight happen? This is where the battle is about even.
Padme vs Leia vs Rey (with no weapons): Padme 10/10 times. Her body is too durable to be hurt in such a manner.
Padme vs Leia vs Rey (blasters): Padme 6/10 times. Leia and Padme are both excellent markswomen, but the latter’s virtually endless stamina and amazing threshold for pain gives her the slight majority.
Padme vs Leia vs Rey (Rey’s stick): Padme 10/10 times, if a Nexus can barely penetrate her skin and the same animal destroys metal casually, Rey’s metal weapon cannot harm her.
Padme vs Leia vs Rey (Lightsaber): Padme 5/10, Rey 5/10. Padmé’s powerful body can give her the victory, but even a novice with a lightsaber is incredibly dangerous.
Please Log In to post.