OWK Darth Vader vs Knightfall Vader

OWK Darth Vader

Vs

Knightfall Vader

Rules

• Sabers only

OWK

OWK Vader has ten years' experience on his KFV self. He's more powerful, skilled, and physically superior in every way bar arguably speed.

Is he more skilled though? He was matched by pre hole Obi in sabers (re hole Obi is ROTS Obi). And ROTS Obi had his hands full against Mustafar Vader, who is lesser than KFV.

He's definitely more powerful though.

OWK Vader wins force and all out but I’d back KFV in sabers only tbh

@frozen: stop tagging me pls this is like the 3rd or 4th time I’ve asked.

@landon_rogers00: Make a formal request to be removed from the SW tag list.

@frozen: You’re literally the only person who keeps tagging me like who else do I need to talk to when you’re the only one who does it?

Your post history is nothing but requests to other people to stop being tagged. Clearly you've volunteered yourself on a tag list. You should request it to be removed on that thread.

I told Nasser he can tag me in SW post about Palpatine and Ahsoka I never once told him to add me to a tag list so I could get spammed relentlessly, it’s just crazy how I’ve asked a few other people to stop tagging me and they have… yet it’s a problem when I ask you to stop tagging me.

I see.. in that case I'll remove you. My apologies and thanks for reminding me.

@frozen: thank you!

KFV. OWK Vader was matched by pre-hole Kenobi who is no better than ROTS Kenobi while pre-suit Vader matched ROTS Kenobi while hindered. Even if you think OWK Vader was hindered too, KFV still performed better against Kenobi so he still wins.

@eredin12: Where do you rank twin amped OWK in the force?

@frozen: I don't believe that Knightfall & Mustafar Vader are that different, tbh. I'd also argue OWK Kenobi > RoTS Kenobi.

I don't see why "pre-hole" Kenobi is a lesser duelist to himself out the hole, he still had his composure. After the hole Obi-Wan seemed to move past his fears and become more powerful, sure, but I don't think that changed his technical ability.

Vader would've lost some skill post-RoTS given his transformation but he's had 10 years time of adjustment and active training, I don't see why he'd be a lesser duelist to his KFV self.

Interesting. Vader is probably a worse duelist than KFV but is stronger in the force and more experienced in the dark side. I would have to say Vader wins 6/10 times, though it'll be a great fight.

KFV Vader

KFV might win sabers , but he loses force and all out .

In the show, Darth Vader was intended to be at his apex. A younger, weaker version is going down.