Obi-wan Kenobi Vs. Darth Vader

I couldn't find this anywhere else on comicvine. So...

Vs.

Rules:

Both are in their prime

Same battle in Mustafa but both are in their primes now.

All feats apply to theme, including legends.

Who Wins this time on Mustafar?

Vader

Obi-Wan

@rockette: Why does Obi-Wan Win?

@rabumalal: Why does Vader win?

Vader has more and better feats. He wins. Though it should be a decent fight.

I'd give it to Vader personally.

Not only does Vader have superior force abilities/feats but he wouldn't be making the same mistakes as he did in Episode 3, He'd be more cautious and due to this I think it'd give him the edge seeing as in terms of strength and speed((this is more so in Legends)) is on par if not better than Obi Wan

Obi wins, he takes advantage of the good ol high ground.

vader every time and this match has been done before:

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/darth-vader-vs-obi-wan-kenobi-630378/

Dueling is arguable but i still favor vader. His stamina makes kenobi tiring him out a impossibility, he's a more varied version of the anakin who already was more skilled than kenobi, and his speed disparity can certainly be compensated for given vader's has shown he can deal with the speed vs people of comparable/faster speed such as ahsoka, starkiller, and luke(post prime). On the other hand kenobi will struggle with vader's strength which outclasses anyone kenobi has faced save for grevious who kenobi never held up well physically against.

Either way if kenobi gains an edge saber wise, vader can just end the fight via force considering an out of prime vader has ragdolled folks like starkiller.

And yes, vader has made use of the force vs force users of note many times. He bfr'd ahsoka, ragdolled starkiller, choked marek. All of whom are more powerful than kenobi force wise(ahsoka is arguable i suppose)

Obi-Wan in his prime has already beaten Vader in his prime. Anakin just before turning into Vader was at his most powerful. Once Obi-Wan kicked his arse, and Vader was born, he lost much of his Force potential. Vader at his prime would be at an even higher disadvantage. Both in Force power, and in agility/dexterity.

Vader is confirmed to be WEAKER then Anakin Skywalker. Faster (suit tires him down), more durable (vader can hardly breathe without the suit and it makes him vulnerable to suit damage and electricity) more powerful in the force (more body to channel it). So... Obi Wan basically defeated a better version of Anakin, he should win with his robotic, weaker form no problem.

Weaker? You've got it completely reversed. It's stated throughout numerous sources that Vader > Anakin

"Many years later, Obi-Wan and Darth Vader duel a second time. The Sith Lord is now more experienced and powerful."

- Beware the Sith

-

"After a single brief session with Obi-Wan Kenobi years ago, and only a short time with Yoda, Skywalker is able to hold up against a Dark Lord of the Sith at the height of his powers."

- Insider 62

-

"[Vader's] power was great, now, greater than it had ever been."

- Return of the Jedi Novel

-

"More powerful in the force then ever before as well as a master of the lightsaber, Darth Vader prepares for his final battle as the Rebel fleet hammers the fully operational Death Star."

- Darth Vader Return of Anakin Skywalker

OT: Vader wins with moderate difficulty.