Obi-Wan Kenobi ROTS vs Anakin Skywalker TCW

Obi-Wan from ROTS and Anakin from TCW. Anakin is not throwing a temper tantrum or especially angry, he is normal and focused, as is obi-wan. Anakin grows to be stronger and faster as well as a better duelist but had he achieved that at this point? Or is obi-wan's experience cunning and skill still too much for anakin at this point?

I feel like movie ROTS obi-wan would definitely beat anakin from TCW TV show so feats from EU, movies, and show allowed.

Takes place in geonosian execution arena from episode 2 (Battle of Geonosis)

Anakin both rounds.

Yeah, Anakin wins. Unlike Obi-Wan, the majority of Anakin's best feats took place before RotS (to my knowledge) but regardless, he is just better by this point anyway.

Disappointing, I thought this would be a good battle.

Anakin is good as long as he keeps Obi Wan away from the high ground.

I think obi-wan could be able to use his soresu to hold anakin off long enough to get in his head or find some other tactical advantage like he did on mustafar.

It would end up being a good fight, but Anakin should win the majority of the time.

Would Anakin do it, if Obi-Wan had the high ground? Would one, hypothetically, underestimate the power of the other? Anakin was like Obi-Wan's brother and he loved him. Then again, Anakin, is implied to at that point to hate him. I wish they showed this at some point in episode III.

Roughly even in the first round, with a slight lean to Anakin, but Anakin in the second round would win just about every time.

Where battle takes place? If Obi-Wan takes the location which has any sort of high ground he wins 10/10.

Made some changes...

Ani. More adroit duelist, faster, stronger, more powerful in the Force, etc,etc.

The high ground jokes..... *facepalm*

@dccomicsrule2011: I admit I had to look up "adroit"

Tempted to change my opinion here. .

Obiwan stomps via the high ground.

Bump

I don't think it's very clear. Strenght and speed wise I would give Anakin an edge but Obi-Wan has shown some very good durability feats. Skill wise I would put Anakin slightly beneath Dooku/Mace Windu and as per Mace Windu Obi-Wan is not far away from him in skill (arguably of course). Force wise I would give the edge to Anakin but not to the effect that he could ragdoll Obi-Wan.

anakin

Anakin was more powerful in ROTS, and Obi-Wan beat him there...

@eyedcyou: By outsmarting him.