There is no objective way (as opposed to subjective, as in "Character X punched Character Y" which I just don't have the skills to do) to discuss this fight without discussing this headline:
http://i.imgur.com/L36hGym.png
That's right, MoS Superman apparently stopped an earthquake. Granted, he did it offscreen, but let's assume the caption is accurate.
One of the ways to measure an earthquake is the "moment magnitude scale". It was created to be a little more objective than the commonly known Richter scale, by using the physics term "moment" aka "force times distance", and based on a magnitude 5 being the same in both. Using either scale, therefore, a magnitude 6.0 (assuming "devastating" means "strong" earthquake) would have a moment of about one quintillion Newton-meters.
The distance in the formula is, of course, the distance created when the fault line shifts. The 1906 San Andreas fault earthquake caused a distance of 21 feet, according to the USGS, at its maximum, and Superman seems to like that fault line. Yeah I know, wrong movie. Bear with me. Using that distance for a 6.0 magnitude quake, the force would have to be 16 trillion tons.
The biggest objective strength feat I could find for Namor was lifting Utopia which is basically Asteroid M.
http://x-men.wikia.com/wiki/Asteroid_M?file=212051-58241-asteroid-m.jpg
http://x-men.wikia.com/wiki/Asteroid_M?file=Utopia_0001.jpg
Now I don't know how big that is, but, let's pretend for now the spires are the size of the Empire State Building. Using that for scaling and assuming Asteroid M is solid iron (Magneto Was Here) that puts it at 300 billion tons.
Superman is still far, far stronger. And that's lowballing the earthquake and highballing Utopia. The MoS struggle with Zod heavily implied the two were about the same strength, or at least, closer than two orders of magnitude that separate MoS Superman and Namor.
So MoS Superman could hurt Namor...but ONLY if he did it off-screen. "On-screen", Superman never gets anywhere near this level of power. Pushing boats through ice, wrecking satelites, smashing holes in buildings, nothing he does is in the same ballpark. Hell, they're not even in the same state as the same ballpark. If off-screen Superman's strength is the Philadelphia Eagles, then Namor is probably the Pittsburgh Steelers, but on-screen MoS Superman is the Cleveland Browns.
The earthquake feat is a ridiculous outlier, and not even the hardest of core Superman fans even saw it. And there's no proof the earthquake was even 6.0 either. Not only is "devastating" a relative term depending on where it hits (poor countries take less to "devastate"), but it's also really hard to measure an earthquake that's prevented. Further, for all we know, Clark Kent wrote that headline himself, making its accuracy questionable.
And Namor's shown speed far greater than anything MoS Superman has done.
http://i.imgur.com/JkTRZrv.png
Check out the curvature of the Earth. Those two are at least a thousand miles up, and did it in "seconds". In BvS, Superman leaves a party in New York and gets to Juarez, Mexico, a distance of 2,000 miles, in fifteen seconds of cinematic time. Again, OFF SCREEEN, bleargh. But even if the time was real time, it'd be tough to argue Superman was faster. At best, you might argue a tie. But based on what happens on-screen during those 15 seconds of movie time, more than 15 real seconds passes, so Superman is almost certainly slower.
Also, Namor can dodge bullets when caught by surprise:
http://i.imgur.com/8IfLGAY.png
MoS Superman just lets anything thrown at him hit him -- including the second shot from Batfleck's kryptonite gas gun, which he knows can hurt him, and he knows is coming because he's staring straight at it -- and that looks a lot slower than a bullet.
Namor's been fighting creatures and supervillains for decades. MoS Superman has no demonstrated combat skill or training to speak of, and gets in a grand total of three challenging fights. He loses two of them. And, in one of them, Superman is too unskilled and inexperienced to throw a spear at a gassed, tied-up, immobilized Doomsday, then chooses to stand within stabbing range, gets stabbed, and DIES. Namor, by contrast, can do this:
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11111/111115760/3338526-1762280266-namor.gif
That's right: Namor has thrown a tank, at a moving plane, and hit it. And that plane's up in the clouds!
Namor has skill, speed, and demonstrably equal or higher strength. The only thing between Superman and getting his ass kicked, is a piece of paper saying "I am awesome off-screen" that we see for a couple seconds. Sorry, but, that's not enough.
I give the fight to Namor 9 times out of 10, and the 10th fight we don't get to watch.
Log in to comment