Moon Knight vs Punisher

I'm gonna go with Moon Knight here

In a recent Moon Knight comic its stated that the Punisher has killed MK's brother to which he said they will settle one day. That time is now, who wins?

Moon Knight:

Superb athlete and combatant. Expert with throwing weapons and hand-to-hand combat. Enhanced strength derived from the phases of the moon.

Punisher:

Highly trained in armed and unarmed combat.

Demolitions expert and has a exceptionally high pain tolerance.

I think Moon Knight would win here. But Punisher could give him a good fight

If Moonknight fights here with his powers then he wins, if not it's punisher's fight

It all depends on what phase the Moon is or whether the fight is at night at all. Otherwise it's a stalemate to me.
Post Edited:2008-05-24 14:12:42

I don't do this often.



Bump.

The Punisher wins.He's on a higher skill level.

They both suck
But Mooney wins

"They both suck
But Mooney wins"

"Scorched said:

"They both suck
But Mooney wins"

Please stop trolling...please."

Punisher wins

Scorched said:

"They both suck
But Mooney wins"

"Vance Astro said:

"Scorched said:

"They both suck
But Mooney wins"

Please stop trolling...please."

Please stop crying"

"The Punisher wins.He's on a higher skill level."

"Scorched said:

"Vance Astro said:

"Scorched said:

"They both suck
But Mooney wins"

Please stop trolling...please."

Please stop crying"

I'm not crying...I just don't get why you are doing this? Why come here and troll.We have enough people trolling..why do you have to join in?"

"

If Moonknight fights here with his powers then he wins, if not it's punisher's fight

"

"Vance Astro said:

"The Punisher wins.He's on a higher skill level."

I will respectfully disagree (about the winning). Punisher might have a higher skill level, but MK has a very high pain threshold, and it seems like he has his powers from the description given in the OP, in which case it would only take a few, maybe one hit, to put Frank down. I think he has a better chance to win this than Frank."

"Acheron said:

"Vance Astro said:

"The Punisher wins.He's on a higher skill level."

I will respectfully disagree (about the winning). Punisher might have a higher skill level, but MK has a very high pain threshold, and it seems like he has his powers from the description given in the OP, in which case it would only take a few, maybe one hit, to put Frank down. I think he has a better chance to win this than Frank."

MK has a high pain threshold until he dies.If Moon Knight has his powers and The Punisher is unarmed..that's just cheating though.If Frank is armed..he wins.Frank can shoot Moon Knight before he gets punched."

MK can take a lot of damage, but it comes a time when he will fall unconscious

@Acheron....

Moon Knight's standard equipment is a joke.He's not even a weapons master.The Punisher is far beyond MK in the Use of weapons...and MK ran from Bullseye..Punisher beat him twice.

punisher can win this if he deterime enought to kill the bad guy "moon knight"

i hope they kill each other

Moon Knight has good chance to win.

"@Acheron....

Moon Knight's standard equipment is a joke.He's not even a weapons master.The Punisher is far beyond MK in the Use of weapons...and MK ran from Bullseye..Punisher beat him twice."

Bu bu bu bu bump!

The biggest factor in this one is the environment.

Punisher wins in almost any scenario, if he's huntin MK, then MK never sees it coming, broad daylight, one shot one kill. He'll go down faster than a Somali pirate.

If MK is hunting Punisher, he's still screwed because big pun don't let his guard down and traps everything.

If they meet at random, Punisher guns his @ss down in cold blood, pain tolerance doesn't matter, your brain has no nerve endings and feels no pain as the bullet tunnels it's way through to freedom on the other side.

sorry for the 4 y/old bump

I'm pretty sure Moon Knight would win this fight with pretty low difficulty.

He has his Carbonadium Armor that protects him from large caliber bullets and enhances his strength to him being able to hold a section of a building from collapsing.

It alsod has mechanical bracelets that mimic spidermans webshooters and caps energy shield, along with built in claws used to mimic wolverines.

most of the above arguments have punisher winning with gunfire so i just wanted to point this out.

You forgot: Punisher has super intelligence, and a HUGE arsenal of weapons. He even took deadpool at one point.

Yeah, he would just snipe from on top a building, moon knight can't do anything.

Frank.

Frank

If you're taking about the scan were he only puts like 4 hand gun shots into DP it's PIS.

Punisher has never been able to defeat Deadpool in a fair fight, with prep or not.

He did in Suicide kings.

@wdc:

Agreed.

The Punisher had lots of prep and was using the weapons of Villains such as Dock Ock's arm, not his standard gear

@wdc said:

No he didn't.

DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #2 Punisher comes in disguised as a pizza delivery man with extra gear and is still defeated.

Gallery

At the end of DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #2, Deadpool is yet again ambushed by Punisher out of nowhere and the fight is interrupted by Daredevil. Hardly a win considering Wade wasn't expecting a fight at all and was at a friend's house.

Gallery

DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #3, yet again, Punisher ambushes them with prep and extra gear to the point where he uses sonic weaponry to put down Daredevil. Deadpool escapes and Wade still dodges Frank's blows with absolute ease until the fight is broken up by a recovered Matt.

Gallery

It's honestly a bit ridiculous now. In DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #4, Deadpool is in a club and Punisher tries to ambush him again. Wade counter-acts and they stalemate.

Gallery

They also encounter in DEADPOOL vol.1 #55 and 56, and Wade was winning and had countless chances to outright kill Punisher, but was interrupted by environmental factors. Frank will never be able to take Deadpool. Even in PUNISHER KILLS THE MARVEL UNIVERSE, it was bad writing since Deadpool can free himself from the chains.

Castle puts two in his brain. /Thread

@carter_esque said:

Except it's not that simple since Moon Knight has dodged bullets on countless occasions, has superior equipment, pain tolerance equal to Punisher's, and hand-to-hand prowess at least equal to that of Punisher's.

@cooldes said:

The problem with this assessment is you're basing who would win on current Moon Knight but you acknowledge that the thread is 4 years old.

What's that gotta do with Frank double-tappin' him??

Frank has history with Moon Knight and knows he's a hero, he's not going to go for a killshot on Marc. There's no details in the OP so that equals they're in character.

You're assuming Punisher is going to tag Moon Knight in the first place, who isn't ignorant to stealth approaches as well. Frank himself has admitted he has tons of respect for Spector, so there's a chance he won't go all out either. On top of that, Moon Knight could just knock the gun out of Punisher's hand.

Back-up pistols? Spector throws his Crescent Darts and slices 'em in half.

@yourneighborhoodcomicgeek said:

@wdc said:

He did in Suicide kings.

No he didn't.

DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #2 Punisher comes in disguised as a pizza delivery man with extra gear and is still defeated.

Gallery

At the end of DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #2, Deadpool is yet again ambushed by Punisher out of nowhere and the fight is interrupted by Daredevil. Hardly a win considering Wade wasn't expecting a fight at all and was at a friend's house.

Gallery

DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #3, yet again, Punisher ambushes them with prep and extra gear to the point where he uses sonic weaponry to put down Daredevil. Deadpool escapes and Wade still dodges Frank's blows with absolute ease until the fight is broken up by a recovered Matt.

Gallery

It's honestly a bit ridiculous now. In DEADPOOL: SUICIDE KINGS #4, Deadpool is in a club and Punisher tries to ambush him again. Wade counter-acts and they stalemate.

Gallery

They also encounter in DEADPOOL vol.1 #55 and 56, and Wade was winning and had countless chances to outright kill Punisher, but was interrupted by environmental factors. Frank will never be able to take Deadpool. Even in PUNISHER KILLS THE MARVEL UNIVERSE, it was bad writing since Deadpool can free himself from the chains.

Damn.. it's kind of hard to see one of my favourite characters fail so hard at trying to take down my other favourite.

@yourneighborhoodcomicgeek: Here's a few more accuracy feats for Marc. So yeah, he definitely enjoys disarming enemies with his crescent daggers :D

Gallery

@i_like_swords: I never was a huge fan of the Punisher but it was like "dude, when is this guy going to stop hunting down Wade?". It got ridiculous fast. It shows how Frank can't really drop Deadpool unless he's not expecting a fight and gets ambushed. The only other time Punisher managed to drop Deadpool was when he appeared out of nowhere and blew his head with a crossbow.

@k4tzm4n: Oh man that feat where he quick-fires into that guy's ear is hilarious. Gonna save those feats if you don't mind me doing.

If anything, you have to credit his persistence. He isn't exactly the most honourable guy but if he wants you dead he'll keep trying and trying. Lol

@i_like_swords: And yet he still fails lol. Punisher and Moon Knight are probably right below mid-tier in street-levelers. Their gear and skill are formidable, but not as impressive as mid-tier or high-tier street levelers.

@yourneighborhoodcomicgeek: Yeah. They'd be complete legends in real life, but no so much by comic standards. What tier would you place Deadpool in?

Deadpool is right below high-tier street-levels. If he was serious I'd put him in the high-tier.