Mirajane Strauss vs Erza Scarlet

Neither one is holding back

Who wins

Due to Erza's plot armor she would win quite easily. And this battle should be obvious.

Mirajane herself stated that erza has surpassed her despite them being rivals. IIRC

@deathhero61:

Just because she said that doesnt automatically make it true.

@ghost_rider1: Considering how erza was her greatest rival and this was mainly due to erza being the top mage it should be taken into consideration.

Mira wins. Fu** that ketchup head bi***.

I'm obviously fanboying. Don't get bent over my obvious joke. Still hate Erza tho.

@justsomerandomkid: finals or they are on par with each other so basically it's a 50-50 split in my opinion

unless Erza has a anti-demon Magic armor somewhere. That weakens the Demonic magic by 50% like her flame emperorus armor

@cjdavis103: Aren't we all forgetting the armor that let's her bend Law of Magic? With that armor would she just negate Mira's Takeover, and we really haven't seen any actual skill from her without her magic

@justsomerandomkid: keep in mind that armor burns up enormous amounts of energy and Mira knows all of erza's tricks so if she pulls that Armero she will know to keep her distance until erza runs out of magical energy

Erza, Erza has surpassed Mirajane.

@dbvse7: Only because Mira is two years out of practice while Erza got stronger.

And Mirajane surpasses Erza in not being close to a Mary sue.

LOL

Ezra. Like natsu she is a walking plot device. She also has better showings.

*Builds shrine to Goddess Mirajane*

@blackwind: Still surpassed Mira.. So whats your point. Erza would win based on feats alone.

erza ftw her powers are more effective in a straight fight and she has a antidemon armour for sure.

On the other hand mirajane being able to fly and her taking control of demons can make her winner in a good setting.

Leaning toward erza for this one7/10

@dbvse7: My point is that Erza sucks and will never reach the levels of fabulousness that is Mirajane.

Duh!

@blackwind: No she really doesn't annnd.. We just went over how she already did?..

@blackwind: Mirajane is kind of boring in comparison to erza. Remember those 100 monsters? In the manga version of the battle she only did it with her katana, no armors, nothing.

Mirajane wins this easily, she always holds back and she is more durable, fast and stronger than Erza. Mirajane can destroy an entire city with one blast if she wants to with her She Devil vision, Demon God Halphas is even more powerful than that. They overrated Erza too much but she shouldn't be equal to Mirajane.

#1-Gildart

#2-Mirajane

#3-Laxus

#5-Erza

She was even fast enough to match Racer and surpass him easily. I think she should be even powerful enough to match Gildart. Just bcz she isn't a main charecter doesn't mean she is weak, she holds back all the time bcz she has experienced pain and lost her way to battle. So Mirajane ftw.

Xoxo~::/Gossip~Guy!!!!!!.......?????

@guled120: I guess I agree what you said..

Mirajane wins with ease, y? Let me break it to u. Erza is somewhat = Satan Soul, even tho it is hard to imagine but whatever. Demon God Halphas, Sitri, and Alegria r beyond the level of SS.

Not to mention that Mirajane has the deadliest power "MARCO" and we all saw How Seilah made Erza her bitch so Y do ppl blind themselves from what's obvious?

Mira is the most powerful ISHGARIAN due to Alegria and Seilah. I would even say that she is the top 5 most powerful mages while Erza wont even make the top 20.

Erza Scarlet in a very difficult match.

Erza with mid to high difficulty

Mira macros Erza to sleep.

Mirajane wins

Mirajane is so powerful an ability of her’s is banned due to being too powerful. The same definitely can’t be said for Erza

@emmafrostxmen: What? Mirajane has been jobbing throughout the series, while Erza beats opponents that beat Mirajane. Do you think Mirajane would last as long as Erza did, against Laxus?

@grandtoaa: Mira doesn’t job. She factually holds back in character. She’s more powerful than Erza though in universe. She’s so powerful they literally banned her abilities

Erza's got lots of plot armor on her side and she stomps with that but without it it would be a very equal fight, but Erza still wins high diff

@grandtoaa: and no I don’t think Mira would last as long against Laxus, but Erza did that with aid of PIS. She doesn’t usually perform at this level and has lost to opponents under him

@emmafrostxmen: Out Of curiosity, rank the S Class mages in the guild, from Strongest to weakest.

@emmett_frost: @guled120: False False False

@grandtoaa: at full power:

1- Gildart (Obviously)

2- Mirajane (her damage output is actually insane)

3- Laxus

5- Erza (without plot armor I put her here)

@emmafrostxmen: Laxus > Erza >> Mirajane

Erza gived a extreme diff to Laxus. Laxus has way better feats than Mirajane in every arc.

Laxus no diff Kiria who is comparable to Skullion, the same Skullion who give a hard fight to Mirajane.

DF Gajeel & Enraged Gray have both better feats than Mirajane.

Actually, Mirajane is not even top 5 strongest fairy tail members.

@etherious: again Mira’s 4th strongest take over is banned from use by the guild. Nobody you mentioned is powerful enough to limit their abilities

It was proven multiples times that higher MP > Hax

Laxus is way faster than Mira, she would be destroyed before she can even react. Erza is as strong as Laxus. Gray has DS magic who is a big advantage against her. Gajeel DF one-shotted a Spriggan, Mira was tired after fighting 2 sword of Eileen.

Mira is not above any of them, let alone the fact that Laxus has Fairy Law.

@etherious: I’m not arguing who she can beat although I still think without plot armor in effect Mira can beat Erza but whatever

I was strictly talking about magic power which has nothing to do with individual versus battles

@emmafrostxmen: Erza was on par with Laxus without plot armor. Mira has no feats who put him stronger than Erza, Gray or Gajeel.

@etherious: how about destroying a city with her fourth strongest take over?

Also I don’t think Erza has any feat that lets her resist “Marco”. You would need resistance feats to resist

Mira was so powerful an entire ocean evaporated just with her standing there doing nothing

@emmafrostxmen: the entire ocean did not evaporate. It was only evaporating where she was flying over

Erza destroyed Irene meteor, a way strongest attack than anything Mirajane can do. Let alone the fact that Mirajane macro doesn't work on some of Alvarez fodders soldiers.

Still not better than Erza feats.

@etherious: Those “fodder” resisted which is a feat for them. Erza’s resistance cannot be scaled off of them because they are nothing alike

Resistance feats cannot be scaled because everyone has different willpower

Erza dies to Marco

How is fodders soldiers having a better resistance than Erza who is at Spriggan level ?

Now give me one feats who proove that Mira macro work against Spriggan level characters.

I mean you're not wrong.

@etherious: give me a feat it won’t.

That’s not how feats work. You need feats to resist mind control, not feats for the mind control

You’re wrong

How the- how is Mirajane above Laxus?

This and the fact that BoS Laxus has better speed feats than Mirajane's best speed feats, plus Laxus' ridiculous endurance and durability, Mirajane isn't stronger than him.

@cocacolaman: Mira is the only character with a banned ability in the guild and it’s not even close to her strongest form

Macro, you mean? You specified her damage output in the post I quoted. And being the only person with a banned ability in the guild means nothing when Natsu Dragneel and Gildarts Clive are also part of that guild (unless Mirajane is superior to either of those two?)