Mirajane replaces Erza in these fights

Mirajane

Round 1: Erza Knightwalker

Round 2: Azuma (Mira is at full power)

Round 3: Kagura and Minerva at the GMG

Round 4: Ajeel

Round 5: Irene (Mira has Wendy’s help)

Rules:

Mirajane replaces Erza against some of her former enemies throughout fairy tail. How does she do in each of these rounds? This isn't really a gauntlet just to be clear.

@jk124: loses to Irene

I suppose this is Mirajane in the same arc as Erza when she was against them

R1 : Mirajane high diff

R2 : Mirajane extreme diff

R3 : Mirajane high diff

R4 : Ajeel mid diff

R5 : Irene no diff

I’m curious on your thoughts on round 3. Mira has a problem with stamina and imo if she’s going to beat those two, she’ll have to finish off like say Kagura first which isn’t be easy at all

I'd say Mira loses Round 3, 4 and 5

RD 1) W

RD 2) W

RD 3) L

RD 4) L

RD 5) L

Unfortunately mirajane doesn't have erza's power of bullshit so would clear upto round 4

All of these villains pushed Erza to her limits, so I don't see Mira wins when she's way weaker than Erza.

u mean "friendship"

@citgo: yes power of friendship/bullshit whatever you call it.

@lilgodperv:

If Mirajane in the same arc as Erza:

1) Mira oneshots Edo-Erza (she hadn't any armor) like Freed using "Soul extinctor".

2) FP Mira oneshots Azuma with her nuke, because her base spell overcame his defense while Mira tried to save her mana.

3) Mira stomps Kagura in BSS (like Erza did the same, when became serious), then tanks Minerva's attack and blitzes her in Sitri like she did it with Jenny.

4) Mira. Macro GG.

5) Stops here. Duo die when Irene becomes Dragon.

Technically Mira is Erza but without the plot armor. This means she might actually lose all those fights. Or win them if the writer thinks she can.

I'd say she has the potential to fare as well as Erza does, but I think she just won't be able to do anything to Irene.

Mira can win all of the rounds except for 5

This is incorrect. Her stamina is normal after 3 month training, in GMG and Tartaros Mirajane repeatedly changed TakeOvers without being tired. Erza w/o SO tanked Minerva's strongest spell, but failed to do it with Azuma's base attacks, while Mira did. Kagura and Minerva can't tank something like "Soul extinctor", they haven't armor, while Erza was KOed in her strongest by Jupiter << "Soul extinctor". So, Mira takes it comfortably.

@deactivated-5f5852a1ad297: @dimitri1220: guys, how Kagura and Minerva can tank something like "Soul extinctor" and how feats Ajeel had, which said that he is able to resist Macro?

@emperor99: That was me 7 months ago lol, I think Mira can win every fight except against Irene. Though she might actually still lose to Minerva since Erza needed an armor that cuts through magic to beat her.

If current, beats all but Irene.

If concurrent, idrk

clears except ajeel & irene

@dimitri1220: Ok, l agree.

But there is no way that GMG Mira could lose to Minerva. Erza (and Kagura) tanked her strongest spell w/o armor in the beginning of the fight 3v3, while in the end she was highly injured and needed Nakagami to finish Minerva quickly. Nakagami only works on types of spatial magic (like Minerva's teleport), and Erza needed this advantage cuz she could really barely stand after Kagura treatment and couldn't dodge Minerva's anymore. it's obvious, that creator gave her Nakagami cuz he didn't want that Erza lagged far behind GMG Mira after her Tenru feats. Actually GMG Erza (before using SO) was Tenru Erza, which was beaten by Azuma before Tenru hellfire, while Mira technically didn't manage to win due to time limit while was weakend, but she was able to do it w/o time limit even with scraps of mana, because she stated it by herself, and it indirectly confirmed by fact that her base spell overcame his strongest shield and damaged him, so her strongest BSS attacks would kill him if they continued the fight. We saw that superior soul literally oneshots inferior soul, and after 3 month training Mira could use them without exhausting. So, GMG Mira actually was far stronger than GMG Minerva due to 3 month training, which equal SO boost, and superior souls, while healthy FP Minerva barely stomped injured Erza w/o armor before she activated SO to use Nakagami for a while.

Mira Sitri can stop a FP BSS blast, which destroyed abandoned city and some hills into surroundings, only using one hand, and tanked all Kamika's attacks (and she easily negated Natsu' roar) in human form, which stats equal to Erza w/o armor:

Gallery

Difference between pre- GMG BSS and Sitri:

Gallery

Difference between one of Mirajane's base spells and Minerva's strongest spell:

Gallery

Difference between Jupiter (which KOed Erza in Adamantine) and BSS:

Gallery

Also durability and defense depend on level of MP (due to Laxus', Erza' and Makarov statements), and it's laughable to see that BoS Mirajane's MP far exceeds the sum of three strongest female wizards in GMG:

Gallery

So I think Minerva's attacks can't even scratch GMG Mira, while Kagura and Minerva are glass cannons and would be evaporazed by her nukes (Minerva dura <= Kagura dura = BoS Erza dura w/o armor <<< BoS Erza with Adamantine, which was destroyed by Jupiter and Jupiter << BSS nukes) cuz only ones who tanked her nuke and survived in whole series were J&H, which were strongest person enchants in the verse.

If we are talking about current Mira, she oneshots current Minerva and Kagura like J&H by simple power scaling.

I always thought Mira wasn't so far behind Erza in power

Actually they are in the same league, while usually Mira shows better feats (like she did it in FF, Tenru and Tartaros) until Erza pulls some plot or PoF out of her ass, like she did with Azuma, Kyoka, Irene, etc.

That pic of Mira is hot so she clears. JK, stops at Irene.

She stops at Irene because Mira doesn't have Erza's friendship bullshit, with that she would one shot her

lol at mira having better feats than erza, she's not even a little close to erza feats.

Elf Ears looks sOoooooo cool

@emperor99: True, I get what you're saying

@etherious: What Erza's feats were better in FF, Tenru or especially Tartaros?

comparable in these arcs, but not in alvarez & 100yq

In FF, Tenru and Tartaros Mira had better feats for some reasons:

Erza had some trouble with Eva, the weakest legion member and then stalemated Laxus for a while using anti-lightning armor. Mirajane w/o training negated Freed's hax, which could stop anyone in the guild, and beat him by two base spells.

In Tenru Mirajane had a huge chance to beat Azuma w/o time limit, while was weakend and locked to weakest Soul. Erza was beaten by Azuma and all her armor was broken before Tenru power protected her and destroyed Azuma shield, letting Erza kill him.

In Tartaros Mira was able to beat Etherious Seilah, which is equal to Etherious Kyoka by stats, after got beating up in human form and hitting by blast, which was stronger than 500 Jupiter Cannons, twice (you can say, that Elfman saved her, but without Mirajane's Macro he wouldn't be there and couldn't beat Seilah, even weakend by Mira, without Macro empowering), and than helped Erza to beat Kyoka and overcome her curse, while Erza was stomped by Kyoka in her strongest armor and won even with "friendly" help only because she spent her life energy on Faces activation. Also Mira played key role destroying the laboratory and absorbing souls of already dead demons, she literally deprived them an opportunity to resurrect and fight again.

In Alvarez they were comparable until Erza used PoF to destroy Meteor, which doesn't correspond her real feats. Meteor is not even Irene's strongest spell, while J&H took a long time to create and were stronger than some spriggans in terms of AP. Erza beat Ajeel using advantage (anti-spatial armor against spatial magic) and Mirajane beat Jacob, while was highly injured and exhausted (before you will say that Jacob didn't use Transport, I remind that he used all other types of his magic, including stealth, invisible weapon, which could hurt even ghosts, his extrasensory abilities and excellent combat skills, while his defense, durability and other stats were good in terms of AP).

100yq Mirajane was under hypnosys after beating up by her siblings and didn't even fight seriously, lol. She didn't use Macro on Gray or take him over as soon as she made eye contact with him. Also, her TakeOvers grows at the same degree as other wizards like Erza or Laxus.

I think that Irene would have trouble in her human form, because enchantments like any kind of magic can't affect curse power, so she can't suck magic or soul out of Mira, while enchantmens don't negate something like Macro, but Dragon Irene still wins, although F.Rogue and WW already undermind dragons' reputation.

don't care about PoF, feats are feats, and she has much better feats in alvarez and 100yq

agree with FF & tenru

Irene simply turns Mira into a mouse most likely...

@morningstar999: Can Irene turn someone, like Bloodman, for example, into a mouse? Do I need to remind you, why August, which literally knew all about magic, copied all Twelwe's abilities except, Larcade, Irene, GS and Bloodman?

@etherious: We can't exclude PoF, when we try to compare two characters, while one of them often uses it and the other just even can't use it, lol. Erza's PoF is a real thing. Jellal and Zeref like Mirajane can't get access to it, and Zeref even explained why. They are all dark magic/ black arts users and their magic has only negative emotions, while PoF boost depends only on positive emotions. The only thing when Erza overshadowed her in Alvarez was Meteor and she cut using the same sword, which kill Azuma, because it was enchanted only to damage Irene.

J/H were only ones in the series, who were able to tank her nuke and survive. And then they got stomped. Fodder soldiers empowered by simple enchantments were able to give Erza some trouble.

Mira was only one person, who fought Spriggan partically w/o magic and also she hadn't any advantages to beat him while had a huge disadvantage. Gildarts, Mirajane, Laxus and Natsu hadn't any advantages to beat Spriggan, while Erza countered Spriggan's magic, "enraged" Gray actually countered Invel's ice and Invel was a fodder in h2h.

In Tartaros even PoF couldn't help Erza to beat Kyoka and overcome her curse (hint, one curse can negate another curse), actually it literally were girls trio (Erza, Mirajane and Minerva) against Kyoka. Ironically, the fact, that Erza was affected by Kyoka's Historia, destroyed some people's representation that Erza overcame it in Tartaros "cuz she is Erza", lol.

If girl fought and beat a guy, who fodderized someone in one league with people, which usually gives some trouble to Laxus, who barely stronger than Erza, being locked to her weakest form despite her opponent had an advantage to dodge her main attacks, I think this is a great feat, lol.

Don't think Mirajane can cut a dragon, nor destroy a meteor with broken bones. Irene already cleaned her before, she'll do it again.

@grandtoaa: Mirajane faced Irene without any mana. You need by far more AP to kill J/H, than destroy a meteor. Erza did it by the sword, which killed Azuma. It was enchanted by Wendy to cut Irene, not Meteor. Meteor is her BASE attack. Creating J/H spent by far more time cuz Irene couldn't create them again. And Irene is a master of enchantments in all terms. They tanked BSS strongest nuke attack, which could not be tanked by anyone in the series. (Analogy with Adamantine Erza and Jupiter, the second analogy with Jura and Brain, Jura was famous by his invincible defense but had a lot of trouble to stop his attack, and Brain/Zero/Joze are just users of dark magic/black arts, which was created by demons, while Mira is a "true" user of this power cuz she gets access to it by demon "souls"). Mirajane needed CP (Allegria soul) do destroy enchantments using simple blow, this mean that any type of enchant could not affect curses (also stated by Mard and other 9D that magic can not affect curse, and enchant is a kind of magic), so enchants can't negate Macro (indirectly confirmed that August could copy all types of Twelve's magic, except DS (Irene, GS) and CP (Bloodman, Larcade)), so Irene NEEDS Dragon form to beat her here, although we saw that mental manipulation already worked on dragons, just Macro still has not feats in this field. Just creator doesn't like OP, imagine Mira calls dragons to fight on her side 😂😂😂

P.S. What about my last question in "Laxus vs Mira vs Gray vs Wendy"?

Mira wins round 1. She loses the other rounds.

She wins all rounds but 5.

I honestly don't see how R3 is even debatable when Tenrou Erza was able to keep up with the likes of Kagura and Minerva and Mira before the 3 months training which was the equivalent of SO was at that level or higher.

Given how Mira did better than Azuma at a fraction of her power she high and mid diffs 1 and 2 respectively.

As for 4, I see it going the same way as Erza v Ajeel. Ajeel gets cocky then get sideswiped by Bisca, and either BSS or any form above finishes the job. Heck, I could see her soloing w/Alegria due to having the ability to vape away all the sand in the area with a power flex like she did the sea and the mountain structures in it.

Even with PoF Erza still lost against Irene. Irene is not a winnable opponent for anyone in FT bar Natsu.

Mira stops at Irene.

@jdogg: Gildarts

Gildarts vs Dragon again. Isn't it wank, lol?

@grandtoaa: Gildarts is not beating Irene. He had no chance against August (who was Irene's rival in human form) let alone an actual Dragon. Irene would clap him before he even knew what hit him.

Gildarts def beat human irene, but loose against his dragon form. human irene don't rival august lol.

Probably cuz Irene could not copy magic unlike August. But she can win if uses separation first.