Melinda May vs Davos

Agent May from Agents of SHIELD is pitted against Davos from Iron Fist.

Hand to hand unarmed combat, morals off. Who wins?

In my opinion, May wins by feats. It's close though, due to Davos' skill.

In-universe, this would be an interesting match to see. It would be extremely close: master martial artist from Kun'Lun versus SHIELD's most lethal and skilled agent. I think May would likely win in-universe by logic & reputation as well, but it'd be a cool battle.

I'm assuming Davos doesn't have the fist. In which case, I'm siding with May. Davos is impressive, but the best he's done is beat fodder. Without the fist, he loses to Danny, Mary Walker, and Colleen Wing.

Davos, scaling from Danny.

Melinda stomps.

I read Davos as Qovas and I was like "?"

OT: May should body him

May.

I don't think his fodder wrecking feats and losing to Danny is impressive enough to beat Malinda May.

May, Davos was relatively unimpressive. Wrecking fodder and losing to Danny doesn't put him near May

May.

May. Davos doesn't have the feats.

May wins, but this might change after IF S2.

Davos! If he's on par with Iron Fist martial arts wise, he kicks May's ass!

May 7/3

May for now

Davos by scaling and logic wise.

May by feats.

Melinda because superior feats and stats and because she a badass

Davos should win in universe but May does have better feats.

May due to much superior feats...

bump

Davos, mid difficulty

As of episode 5, I'd still go with May

Still May

Her feats against Sinara and that telepathic Meta as well as her multitude of other fights place her above him. She’s more on Matt’s level IMO

Davos takes this, not a stomp but not really that close either.

May.

Davos.

In theory, I could see Davos winning, but I'm not sure how well I could back that up with feats

May

bump

bump

Davos.

Does he have the fist? With the fist, he can punch out a guy's heart soooo...

May.

The Calvary

Davos sucks, with chi he cant even take an injured Danny but he can take may.

May stomps

May.

May

May stomps

May

Melinda comfortably

Davos every time. Ignoring his obvious physical superiority, he was trained to be an iron fist. Also I love how people say dudes with guns are suddenly fodder, despite the fact they are armed, yet he took down multiple gang houses with just his hands which I can't see May doing.

Without the iron fist he's almost as good as Danny so I'll be nice and say Davos 6/10.

With the iron fist she dies in the first 10 seconds.

@greysentinel365: Reasons?

bump.

Bump. Let's see some people who haven't responded yet offer their input.