MCU Winter Soldier vs DCEU Batman

Winter Soldier

Batman

Rules

- Random encounter

- Standard gear

- Bucky is in his "winter soldier" mindset

- Battle takes place in the highway where BUcky fought Steve

- Start 50 feet apart

Bucky

Bucky

I think it's been done 0-o

Been done Bucky stomps

I'm giving this to Bucky.

Winter Soldier. More and better feats.

It hasn´t been done, the other thread is strictly H2H.

@thor_parker82: ah sorry my bad ... Well I still give it to Bucky he's a lot stronger, faster, and more durable I think

batman

Bucky

Bucky wins, also this has been done.

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/winter-soldier-mcu-vs-batman-dceu-1784748/

@jashro44@jedixman@vance_astro@god_spawn

Eh, to be fair that thread is morals on whereas in this thread Bucky is in his winter soldier mindset.

Winter Soldier stomps.

So those threads weren't as terribly mismatched as this one.

@jashro44: Been done as well.

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/batman-dccu-vs-the-winter-soldier-mcu-1691459/

@jashro44: And more.

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/bvs-batman-vs-mcu-winter-soldier-1778154/

http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/mcu-winter-soldier-vs-dceu-batman-h2h-combat-1777702/

That thread is locked because it was made before batman vs superman came out.

@g2_: Those threads are just hand to hand...This thread has standard gear.

@jashro44: Ok.

Bucky demolishes

Broad daylight on a highway isn't exactly a good environment for Batman.

Bucky wins.

Cant batman just shoot him ?

Bucky. this has been done.

Bucky wins though i dont think its a stomp.

Bucky. I finally saw BvS last night and I was stunned by how not Bat God, Batfleck was. It was refreshing to see actually. The movie blew monkey anus, but the "non BatGod" was refreshing

Winter Soldier

Did you see the Ultimate edition or the theatrical cut?

Word is the Ultimate cut fixes stuff, HU. I need to grab it this week.

As far as this fight, Bucky has it in the bag.

@risingbean: I haven't personally seen that version, but it doesn't really 'fix' stuff as much as improve a few scenes. But then again, I should probably watch it and decide for myself.

Winter Soldier takes this solidly

@brucerogers: My understanding is that shaving down the scenes for the theatrical cut is what left it jenky. I believe it was Stegman who said that the additions of the Ultimate cut went a long way to making it a better experience.

Bucky stomps hard Nolan verse is pathetic.

I sure hope so, though I didn't consider the original theatrical cut to be all that bad in the first place. I mean was it a masterpiece? nope, but it sure does get a lot of undeserved flak.

Can't Winter Soldier just shoot him? Batman's grapple gun effectively amounts to a pistol with a single reusable bullet. Winter Soldier's arsenal includes...

-M4A1 Carbine with underslung M203 greendale launcher.

-Skorpion submachine gun.

-SIG-Sauer P220ST handgun.

-COP 375 Derringer.

-Intralec TEC-38 handgun.

and when the occasion calls for it...

-Barrett M82 sniper rifle.

-Milkor MGL grenade launcher.

-modified FN mk 13 grenade launcher.

-M249 SAW machine gun.

Batman is quite literally outgunned here.

This is DCEU Batman.

@brucerogers: oh I saw Nolan pictured then Bucky wins but not a stomp.

Leaning towards bucky. Not by much.

There's about 30 minutes of extra footage. As someone who really liked BvS in theaters, my complaint was that the scene transitions were so weird and random and jarring and just unlike anything I've ever seen in a movie before. The Ultimate Cut definitely fixed that. As far as content goes, the biggest thing it did was strengthen Clark's reasons for disliking Batman. Y'know the Batmobile car chase scene where Superman just suddenly showed up completely randomly and unexpectedly and ripped the Batmobile apart and threatened Batman for no reason? In the Ultimate Cut, there's a scene immediately preceding that one which explained why Clark did that. So that was a very good addition. It's still the same movie though, if you didn't like it in theaters, didn't like the tone or the characters or the writing or the themes it represented, you won't like it now.

Bucky takes this handily, probably with a grenade to Batman's face.

Bucky stomps.

Now uh, I actually, um, kinda think that... Batman... could win... *runs*

Pftt Arrow would still lose to both though *runs faster in opposite direction*

*CHASES*

Bucky is physically superior and has fought proven h2h fighters.

@brucerogers: We're in the same boat it seems. "BvS was good, but flawed". Stegman did a review that alleviated my concerns.

Here's a quick quote

"If you liked the first version, you'll like this one even more. If you are neutral to it, you may find yourself leaning toward the "like" camp. And if you hated the first version...you'll probably continue to hate this one. But I for one am glad they released this and if I had to rate it as a full movie, I'd give it an 8/10!"

Edit: I see @nickzambuto responded via thread skimming. Didn't get a notification.

As for me I dug it. I didn't think it was perfect, or the best CBM of the year, but I didn't feel like my money had been stolen. I'm looking forward to watching the Ultimate cut.

@risingbean: Nice, now I can't wait to see it.

I have the Ultimate Cut, and I agree with Nick. It helps give the film more flow by piecing it together, but if you didn't like it the first time, you most likely won't like it now. I think the film is still as average as when I first saw it.