MCU Surtur vs DoS Doomsday

@blackpantherisb: That impact was continent level or higher, so I kind of doubt it.

Nvm from what I've seen on the comments DD wins

after what he did to the justice league? that's better than anything surtur has done.

and aren't you one of those guys who said comic iron man would beat movie surtur?

This version of Surtur doesnt have enough feats or known power levels to put him in a battle with anyone.

He destroyed Asgard which is the size of an island.

Surtur.

@takenstew22:

He also got hurt by a gas station explosion and a missile.

that was early on in his evolution and he still got up and kept fighting. he was taking hits from the league, something surtur wouldn't be able to do

doomsday

LMAO doomsday gets WRECKED. most he can do is stagger Surtur which he would easily do then bam content destroyed.. Continent>>>>>Gas station

DD should win, shaking a country and managing to kill that Superman is pretty good

Bump.

Gonna have to change my mind on this. Surtur wins. He only died after Asgard died just like his counterpart, unless you think 616 Surtur can't survive a fall. And since Asgard has Earth-tier gravity and multiple moons...gg.

DoS Doomsday is building level

Surtur tanked a blow from Hulk who damaged Loki who no-sold a supermassive black hole gg

mismatch

Is the Doomsday: Year One Annual allowed?

It’s canonically a weaker version of Doomsday yet he made Darkseid afraid and mugged a Green Lantern.

Also we’re cherry-picking Doomsday’s lowest. At least be fair. Doomsday did more than get hurt by the gas explosion (gas fires are a big deal in DC for whatever reason- see Captain Marvel vs Eclipso Superman, Kalibak vs Hal, Orion vs the white Martian) he one shot the Bug with a thrown tree, eventually broke through Coluan metal, beat up a B-list Justice League with an arm tied behind his back (they may be jokes but Doomsday tanked the combined blasts of Fire, Bloodwynd, Ice, Booster, Maxima, and Guy with Sinestro’s ring), and inflicted mortal wounds on a rookie Superman. For reference Fire has hurt Despero and even Lobo on separate occasions, Bloodwynd was secretly Martian Manhunter, Booster has Brainiac 5’s forcefield, and Guy got blitzed faster than the eye.

@tifalockhart:

Yeah, I mean logically DoS DD is strictly more powerful than his earlier weaker counterpart.

If pre DoS Doomsday has better feats, then DoS DD would just scale above that.

Some people have a habit of ignoring DoS Doomsdays feats from other stories when more details were revealed, so I went out of my way to specify that all feats are on the table.

Also, Surtur can’t win if he commits kamikaze that’d be a draw.

Surtur wins

@tifalockhart:

Superman in the same comic was knocked out by gasoline explosion, just like Maxima

Superman was sure that throwing Doomsday at half the speed of sound into the ground is >> all of his previous attacks

Booster gold stated in the same issue that regular fire could breach his force field rather quickly

Superman was badly hurt by steel structures falling on him

Doomsday scales from all of that

fodder honestly, everyone in that run was a joke

@alonis3612: Marvel blows DC out of the water then. Gladiator destroyed a planet which is a humongous deal in DC but he’s Marvel’s resident jobber. Rhino punched Nova into space which is Etrigan’s absolute best striking feat ever. Joe Fixit with jet propelled rocket springs obliterated an asteroid twice the size of Earth.

Superman and the other Leaguers have their hands full with the moon.

Surtur has better feats.

If he was seriously hurt by a gas station explosion, the explosion of a planetoid will atomize him. Surtur probably wins

I think kamikaze is Asgard specific since he mentions he can't die until he blows Asgard up. Just like how 616 Surtur died Post-Ragnarok.

Surtur.