MCU Captain America vs. MCU Thor (read OP)

Avatar image for crunch5481
#1 Edited by Crunch5481 (1540 posts) - - Show Bio

MCU Captain America

No Caption Provided

VS.

MCU Thor

No Caption Provided

Let's see a bunch of different scenarios...

Rules:

  • Equalized stats to Thor's level (unless otherwise noted)
  • Both fighting to the best of their ability
  • Fully healed/rested between rounds and area restored
  • Setting: Thor Ragnarok Arena
  • Fit Thor with endgame feats
  • Cap as of Endgame
  • All Weapons in peak condition

Round 1:

  • H2H, no weapons, no shield
  • Starting distance: 10 feet

Round 2:

  • Both with Mjolnir
  • They can only use their own Mjolnir

Round 3:

  • Cap with Shield
  • Thor with Mjolnir
  • Cap can pick up Mjolnir if Thor drops it

Round 4:

  • Thor with Stormbreaker
  • Cap with Mjolnir
  • They can only use their own weapons

Round 5:

  • Captain America with Shield and Mjolnir
  • Thor with Stormbreaker
  • Can only use their own weapons

Round 6:

  • Captain America with Shield and Mjolnir
  • Thor with Stormbreaker and Mjolnir
  • Can only use their own weapons

Round 7:

  • Captain America with Stormbreaker
  • Thor with Mjolnir
  • Can only use their weapons

Round 8:

  • Cap with shield and mjolnir, as shown in Endgame
  • Cap has the stats he had in Endgame when he was shown to use Mjolnir
  • Thor without a weapon and no lightning mode from Ragnarok
  • Thor cannot use mjolnir or shield

Round 9:

  • Captain America with Thor's lightning mode feats attributed to him (from Ragnarok)
  • No weapon for Cap
  • Thor with Stormbreaker
  • There is no ban on Cap using Stormbreaker
  • Only the last person to hold the weapon can call it to them.

Round 10:

  • Who had the better beard in Infinity War?

(EDIT: Added in more rounds)

Extra R. 1:

  • Cap with no weapons
  • Thor with Stormbreaker and Mjolnir
  • Cap cannot use weapons

Extra R. 2:

  • Cap with Iron Man (1st Avengers movie suit) level stats (durability and strength mainly)
  • Cap has shield
  • Thor with Mjolnir
  • No using the other person's gear

Extra R. 3:

  • Depowered Thor from Thor 1
  • Setting: Elevator scene from Winter Soldier
  • Cap is eqaul to depowered Thor stats
  • Cap has one hand stuck to elevator wall like he did in WS from the magnet
  • His hand is stuck there for the duration of the fight
  • Indestructible elevator

Extra R. 4:

Which was the better scene, Captain America picking up Mjolnir and fighting Thanos, or Thor arriving in Wakanda?

Avatar image for boc
#2 Posted by BOC (2022 posts) - - Show Bio

Below are how I see the fights ending. They're all Cap

Round 1 - Cap easily

Round 2 - Cap with slightly less ease

Round 3 - Cap

Round 4 - Cap with pretty high difficulty

Round 5 - Cap mid difficulty

Round 6 - Cap mid difficulty

Round 7 - Cap

Round 8 - Cap

Round 9 - Cap, interesting though

Round 10 - Cap in a stomp

Avatar image for crunch5481
#3 Posted by Crunch5481 (1540 posts) - - Show Bio

@boc:

Maybe I should add an easier round for Thor then XD

Avatar image for el-kun
#4 Posted by el-kun (834 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap should win all rounds since u made stats equal

And capis hilariously more skilled Dan him thus cap wining

Avatar image for methoki
#5 Posted by MethoKi (12588 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap. All rounds.

Avatar image for boc
#6 Edited by BOC (2022 posts) - - Show Bio

@crunch5481 said:

@boc:

Maybe I should add an easier round for Thor then XD

Lol, maybe. Let's see how this plays out first. It's interesting.

Avatar image for crunch5481
#7 Posted by Crunch5481 (1540 posts) - - Show Bio

Added extra rounds.

Avatar image for tayssti
#8 Posted by Tayssti (1329 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for crunch5481
#9 Posted by Crunch5481 (1540 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for tayssti
#10 Edited by Tayssti (1329 posts) - - Show Bio

@crunch5481:

Extra Rd 1 =Thor

Extra Rd 2 = Cap

Extra Rd 3 =Thor

Extra Rd 4 = Cap

Avatar image for apex_pretador
#11 Posted by APEX_pretador (21469 posts) - - Show Bio

That's a lot of rounds.

Avatar image for crunch5481
#12 Posted by Crunch5481 (1540 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for jayc1324
#13 Posted by jayc1324 (26432 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor all rounds

Avatar image for ash101
#14 Edited by Ash101 (40 posts) - - Show Bio

Too many rounds. Does equalizing stats also means equalized durability? If not then Thor takes all rounds, but if durability is also equalized along with speed & strength then -

R1- Cap. Much more skilled.

R2- Thor. Thor has way more experience with mjolnir than Cap. He knows to use its power better. Thor VS Surther and his minions in the beginning of Ragnarok clearly shows how good is Thor with mjolnir compared to Cap.

R3-Thor. Same reason as R2. Cap is only weaker this time

R4-Thor. Stormbreaker > Mjolnir. Thor almost killed a Complete gauntlet Thanos with stormbreaker. It was meant to be the weapon of Asgaurds new king, meaning it's a tier above mjolnir.

R5- Thor. Basically same as R4

R6 - Thor. Again

R7 - Interesting match. Considering that stats are equalized Cap should be able to wield Storm breaker without dying or turning crazy. He decapitates Thor.

R8- Captain. Thor is seriously nerfed here.

R9- The conditions are ridiculous but Thor wins anyway.

R10- Thor since Steve copied his beard..lol

Extra R.1 - Thor stomps.

R.2 - Considering It's IW Thor, he stomps again.

R.3 - Steve is obviously more skilled and is much stronger/faster than depowered Thor who is basically an average human with muscles.Even in that condition Cap took down multiple trained hydra soldiers. Odinson gets destroyed in this scenario

R.4 - Thor's wakanda entrance is still the most hyped scene in cinematic history imo

Avatar image for anthp2000
#15 Posted by ANTHP2000 (30457 posts) - - Show Bio

  1. Steve.
  2. Could go either way.
  3. Thor.
  4. Thor probably.
  5. Could go either way.
  6. Thor.
  7. Steve.
  8. Steve I guess.
  9. Steve.
  10. Thor.
  11. Thor.
  12. Thor.
  13. Thor.
  14. Thor.
Avatar image for crunch5481
#16 Posted by Crunch5481 (1540 posts) - - Show Bio

@ash101:

I apologize for so many rounds, I am trying to see how people view these characters relative to each other in as many scenarios as possible.

Yes equal stats means equal durability.

Thank you for your input