MCU Battle: New Avengers vs Old Avengers

• Carol Danvers
• Ant-Man (Lang)
• Spider-Man
• Black Panther
• Doctor Strange

• Thor
• Hulk
• Captain America
• Iron Man
• Black Widow
• Hawkeye

Rules

• Everyone is in there prime
• Win by any means except BFR
• Standard gear (No time stone for doctor strange, and no mjolnir for cap)
• In character

Location

• Begin 50 feet apart
• Begin visible
• Fight takes place here:

Who wins and why?

Carol beats Thor (sadly).

GiAnt-Man beats the Hulk (again, sadly).

Strange beats Iron Man.

Black Panther beats Cap.

Spidey solos Clint and Nat.

New Avengers win.

Carol probably beats IW Thor though I could see it going to other way too. Hulk beats Giant-Man. New Avengers win every other match up.

NEW Avengers stomps

Carol VS Thor = Carol

Giant/Ant man VS Hulk = Antman

Black Panther vs Cap = Black Panther

Spiderman vs Clint & nat = Spidey solo

Maybe hulk manages to beat Antman Doctor strange solostomps him

the best versions of them? no Mjolnir?

Binary Carol,
Strange,
Insta Kill Iron Spidey,
Giantman,

New Avengers stomps, even without BP

@bearderby: Spider-Man is in character so he likely won't activate instant kill mode.

Why would Ant Man beat Hulk?

Thor, Hulk, Iron Man vs Danvers, Strange, Ant-Man

Cap, Widow, Hawkeye vs Black Panther and Spider-Man

Those are the likely matchups I see given their powersets and power levels, I'm forced to go with the New Avengers here. Danvers and Strange tip the scales, and the street level fight is slanted as well.

The New Avengers comfortably. Carol would beat the crap outta Thor, Giant Man is honestly way stronger than the Hulk and Dr Strange is also better than anyone in the foundings, including Thor.

New Avengers

Carol Beats Thor

Giant Man steps on Hulk

Doctor Strange Beats Iron Man

Captain America beats Spider Man (again)

Black Widow + Hawkeye beat Black Panther

So for this scenario new avengers won 3/5 fights, but the characters left standing will stomp the street levelers left over for the OG Avengers

Team 1 because of Carol and Strange.

Just regarding strange does he have any offensive feats? I think his best feat (I can see being applied offensively) is using TK to hold back all that water in end game. Not sure how impressive that is as a feat. I guess he cut people with sling rings but I don't think that would be easy and might not work on hulk and Thor.

Carol vs Thor = Thor easily

Black Panther vs BW&HE = BW&HE

Ant-Man vs Hulk = Hulk easily

Dr Strange vs Ironman = IM

Spiderman vs Captain America = Cap

The best thing the Avengers could hope for here is that they beat Black Panther and Spider-Man. Doctor Strange, Giant-Man, and Captain Marvel are too much.

Iron Man, Black Panther, Cap, Widow, Spider-Man, and Hawkeye are borderline non-factors. This is between Carol, Giant Man, Hulk, and Thor. Giant Man is extremely slow and doesn't have any durability feats, so he doesn't actually last that long. Carol can probably beat Hulk and Thor by herself if we're just using pre-Ragnarok Thor.

what about doc strange ?

Marvel beats Thor And Strange uses his new shadow spell to remove the rest of the Avengers

Thor can still drop Carol, though Dr. Strange is the MVP here, and Giant Man will drop Hulk. New Avengers in a good fight.

I would consider adding Wanda or Vision tbh.

But without them it’s New Avengers 7/10

He gave Thanos problems by swarming him with clone whips.

He can also turn all of their attacks into butterflies.

Thor vs carol: thor, carol does not posses combat speed other then bullrush, and has not shown thors level of skill. Stormbreaker makes short work of her as for now.

Hulk vs giANTman: cant say, not sure how goods scots duribility is. Gonna go ahead and say draw for now.

Cap vs panther: probably panther after a nice fight.

Strange vs tony: strange wins.

Spider vs clint and widow: in character could go either way, but i would edge towards peter.

So now it would be thor, and -maybe- hulk vs spiderman, strange, and panther. Giant man may be there if hulk lost aswell. I would give it to the new team, only because the insta teleport disoriented the hell out of thor in ragnarok, and he could probably just spam that till thor gives up, or do it while adding in actual attacks. I dont see crimson bands + duplicates as viable, seeing as an AOE deals with it fine, and thor is the king of AoE

New Avengers because of Carol & Strange, Thor would have to carry his team hard.

@supermanthor: Just realized I forgot about him. Avengers get wrecked even harder than I thought.

Team 1

Thor beats Carol, but everyone else gets stomped. I think if Thor took care of Carol, he could solo everyone else besides Dr. Strange.

New Avengers.

Old Avengers.

Hulk would destroy giantman

Both have easily koed leviathans and hulk has been swatted by surtur with no damage.

No one really got close to antman who could do damage but hulk would jump on his head and ko him.

The only reason hulk was trapped under hq was because he could only use one hand and needed to keep the others safe.

What makes that feat really impressive is how long he managed to hold,probably about 10 minutes.

@eri123: Yeah it's very impressive not to mention the snap didn't just lose him his hand but would have certainly weakened him

Carol v Thor= Thor

Dr. Strange v Hulk = Dr. Strange

Giant man v Iron man= Tony

Black Panther v Widow and Hawkeye= Widow and Hawkeye

Cap vs Spidey = Spidey

Thor and Tony v Dr. Strange= Thor and Strange

Widow and Hawkeye v Spidey = Spidey

Thor and Tony v Spidey = Thor and Tony

feel free to @ me i could use a good arguement